Thematic Field: Democracy, Human Rights and Peace
WorkgroupCritical legal thinking and sociopolitical conflicts
[+ View productions and content]Center for Interdisciplinary Research in Sciences and Humanities
National Autonomous University of Mexico
Mexico
Center for Latin American Studies and Research
University of Nariño
Colombia
Center for Political and Social Studies of Latin America
-University of Los Andes
Venezuela
In recent years, the Latin American and Caribbean region has been embroiled in momentous events. On the one hand, the global pandemic caused by SARS-CoV-2 exacerbated existing structural inequalities, placing the most vulnerable populations in conditions of greater health, economic, labor, and social vulnerability (ECLAC, 2020). On the other hand, the impact of social unrest in several countries of the region, such as Chile, Ecuador, and Colombia, starkly revealed the symptoms of a feverish state resulting from the implementation of neoliberal policies and long-standing social processes that have contributed to the erosion of the social fabric (Rajlan & Benente, 2016).
In the context of the pandemic, several Latin American and Caribbean states, some co-opted by transnational corporations and others by criminal organizations, chose to present themselves as having deficits (Jessop, 2016) and minimalist approaches (Álvarez, 2005) in their decisions during crucial moments when strong social protection for their populations was essential. Some even repressed protesters, human rights defenders, and groups maintaining neighborhood barricades during the pre- and post-pandemic social uprisings. Many of these protests were sparked precisely by the exacerbation of inequality brought about by the health emergency.
Simultaneously, the health and social emergencies fostered the emergence and strengthening of combative resistance actions, political and community-based care networks, massive and popular artistic interventions, independent healthcare and legal organizations, alternative forms of public denunciation, community kitchens, and a complete takeover of social media, among other things. This led to Latin America becoming the stage for disruptive and emblematic social protests for other countries around the world, such as the marches and rallies in favor of the decriminalization of abortion.
This confluence of events is taking place in a region still struggling to rebuild progressive or national-popular political projects. This does not diminish the interesting tension arising from disputes over the dominance of different trends in public governance, both in electoral arenas and in social and redistributive policies (Benente & Navas, 2019). In this regard, it is worth noting the return of Peronism to power in Argentina, led by Alberto Fernández and Cristina Fernández; the victories of Gabriel Boric in Chile, Luis Arce Catacora in Bolivia, and Andrés Manuel López Obrador in Mexico; and the historic rise to power of Gustavo Petro in Colombia, in addition to the positive projections for Lula da Silva in Brazil. Meanwhile, Cuba and Venezuela continue to resist the constant economic and political attacks carried out by the United States and its allies through economic blockades or so-called Unilateral Coercive Measures (Boueiri, 2020).
Furthermore, beyond the political and social circumstances in which our region finds itself, it is important to highlight the socio-legal implications of contemporary processes of accumulation by dispossession (Harvey, 2005). The current stage of capitalism, in its phase of accumulation by dispossession, along with the implementation of neoliberal policies by many of our states, has unleashed intense social struggles against the dispossession of territories and natural resources by transnational corporations, many of which are linked to states and even organized crime. This has also revealed a dispute in the realm of constitutions and laws, highlighting tensions between the legal framework governing dispossession and the emancipatory nature of law.
All these socio-political changes have an impact on the legal field that can foster alternative legal narratives that, on the one hand, document unnamed and incompassionate structural injustices (Médici, 2015; Molina, 2022) to empower subjects who are subaltern or excluded from political and economic power and, on the other hand, challenge configurations of the official universalist normative reality of Human Rights that tend to delegitimize and falsify policies and decisions with a vocation for justice (Rosillo & Machado, 2020; Sánchez, 2018).
To succinctly present the contexts of our lines of work involves, first and foremost, mentioning these panoramas, which can be interpreted through the lens of recent history, but also considering those that are more genealogical and rooted in generational academic trajectories in Latin America. It is crucial to keep alive the tradition of a combative hermeneutics (Wolkmer, 2017) as well as legal critique (Correas, 2002) that permeates the disciplinary and methodological treatment we give to the various tensions between law and society in our research. Contexts of crisis in the human sciences (Echeverría, 1995), the drive to document cultural malaise through structural patterns of domination (Matamoros & Hernández, 2019), and also the intricate webs of political subjectivities, are some of the influences that are reinterpreted in the development of our lines of work.
Finally, we agreed to prioritize some social and normative phenomena that will impact the course of our individual and collective reflections, among them: the tensions of the uses of law by the State and/or diverse social and political actors, the presence of new communication and information technologies in daily life where technopolitics and cyberculture predominate (Sierra Caballero, 2017; Marino, 2016); the gravitational movements that feminisms and dissidences bring to grassroots political militancy; neoliberal policies transformed into legislation and regulations that affect rights; the so-called legal battle (or lawfare), understood as the illegitimate use of the Law in judicial proceedings to harm an adversary and obtain a political result (Rivera, 2021); Social concern about climate change and the demand for environmental protection, as well as the concentration of media and the messages that hegemonic media constantly broadcast against emancipatory social processes (Estepa and Maisonnave, 2019).
The social transformations in our region and the challenges we face require critical, contextual, and situated legal thinking, based on critical hermeneutics, that takes into account the material basis of the phenomena analyzed, but above all, requires thinking about new categories of legal thought that foster liberating frameworks for social action.
Benente, M. & Navas, M. (2019). Law, social conflict and emancipation. Between depression and hope. ILSA, CLACSO, University of Nariño.
Boueiri, S. (2021). Unilateral coercive measures (sanctions) in Venezuelan historical development. In Grupo Ruptura I Institut Sobiranies. Post-pandemic moments. New powers, new resistances (pp. 201-227). Ruptura.
Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean, ECLAC. (2020). Social Panorama of Latin America. ECLAC.
Correas, O. (2000). Introduction to the Critique of Modern Law. Fontamara
Echeverría, B. (1995). The illusions of modernity. UNAM, El Equilibrista.
Estepa, C. & Maisonnave, M. (2020). Discussions and strategies surrounding democracy, human rights, and the State. In Estepa, C. and Maisonnave, M. (Eds.). Human Rights from Latin America: Current Discussions and Strategies (pp. 30-58). Editorial de la Universidad del Rosario. https://rephip.unr.edu.ar/handle/2133/18438
Harvey, D. (2005). The new imperialism: accumulation by dispossession. Socialist Register 2004. CLACSO.
Jessop, B. (2016). The State, past, present and future (Trans. Valdés, C.). Catarata.
Médici, A. (2015). Powers and rights in Latin American constitutionalism. In Rosillo, A. & Pérez, M. (Eds.). Historicizing Justice. Studies on the thought of Ignacio Ellacuría (pp. 127-144). CENEJUS, Mispat.
Hernández, A. & Burgos, M. (2019). The dispute over law: Hegemonic globalization vs. the defense of peoples and social groups. CEICH.
Marino, S. (2016). The regulation of the Expanded Audiovisual Space in Argentina from 2007-2015. Famecos Journal, 23(3). https://doi.org/10.15448/1980-3729.2016.3.22535
Molina, D. (2022). Historicity of Human Rights and anthropologies of pain in Modernity. In Costa, C.; Machado, L. & Da Silva, J. (Orgs.). Human rights from Latin America, vol. 2: Práxis, Insurgência e Libertação (pp. 54-78). Editor Fi.
Rajland, B. & Benente, M. et al. (2016). Law and the state, political and constituent processes in Our America. CLACSO.
Rivera, C. (Ed.). (2021). Lawfare: A disputed concept. Legal and political critique in our Latin America, (7). CLACSO.
Rosillo, A. & Machado, L. (2020). Law and Liberation: Critical Legal Thought from the Philosophy of Liberation. Ilsa.
Sanchez, D. (2018). Constituent human rights, critical thinking and liberation praxis. Akal
Sierra, F. (2017). Technopolitics and the new sensorium. Notes for a theory of cyberculture and collective action in Sierra Caballero and Gravante, Technopolitics in Latin America and the Caribbean. Social Communication Editions and Publications.
Wolkmer, A. (2017). Critical Theory of Law from Latin America. Akal
The collaborative work, research, and discussion activities of the Group and Project proposed in this call for proposals are based on the work of a consolidated and productive working group that has successfully presented its findings on several occasions to CLACSO, namely: the Working Group on "Latin American Legal Critique: Social Movements and Emancipatory Processes" (2013-2016); "Critical Legal Thought" (2016-2019); and "Legal Critique and Sociopolitical Conflicts" (2019-2022). Each of these working groups has studied law as a social phenomenon that expresses power relations, the various uses of law by social movements, constituent assemblies, and the constitutions that have emerged from them in Latin America (Venezuela, Bolivia, and Ecuador). In turn, the tensions that exist within the legal field between Law as a reproducer of oppressions and status quo, and Law as a possible instrument to promote processes of social emancipation have been studied in depth, all of the above analyzed and debated from approaches of legal pluralism and decoloniality, as well as from Marxism.
The research and articulation of different critical perspectives on Law in Latin America and the Caribbean are increasingly solid and necessary in contemporary social sciences, as they allow us to explain and analyze socio-legal phenomena in their specificities, as well as the political, economic and social implications they entail.
In this sense, critical theories of law start from common premises, among them, that law is not neutral, objective and universal; that law is a social and power phenomenon; and that the State is not the only producer of law, that is, that there is a legal pluralism that needs to be analyzed in its particularities, even though the State has the monopoly on the use of force, that is, coercion.
Critical legal theories tend to dismantle the mythology and fetishism (Rivera Lugo, 202) embedded in the positivist conception of law and to account for new legal narratives that offer alternatives to the dominant ones, revealing structural inequalities, asymmetries, oppressions, subalternities, and injustices. Critique, as cognitive knowledge and an exercise in emancipation, must demonstrate the degree of alienation and automation experienced by human beings and highlight processes that instill mythical representations used to conceal these realities (Wolkmer, 2019).
However, the critical perspectives on law that this Group adopts to address the issues raised do not remain solely at the descriptive and critical analysis level of the diverse socio-legal realities experienced by our Latin American and Caribbean societies—which in itself constitutes a contribution to the field—but rather propose the development of analytical categories and concrete approaches that can be expressed at epistemological and pedagogical levels as well as at normative and political levels (political constitutions, legislation, analysis of court rulings, normative production of indigenous peoples and communities, among others). All of this is directed toward generating a legal common sense to materialize processes of social emancipation (Santos, 2010).
Within this framework, each of the lines of work that the members of the Group delve into allows for the configuration of a theoretical corpus useful for understanding sociopolitical phenomena from the perspectives of epistemologies of the South, Marxist, feminist, decolonial, the philosophy of liberation, the hermeneutic-critical approach to human rights, the peoples and from legal pluralism, as well as from understandings that do not escape contemporary geopolitics (Rajland, Burgos and Machado, in press).
It is of social and intellectual importance to continue delving deeper into the analysis of the role that law and legal expressions have played in the current stage of the capitalist system, characterized by accumulation by dispossession (Harvey, 2005; Federici, 2021). This will allow us to understand the legal forms that dispossession, neo-extractivism, and neoliberal policies take, and the impacts these have on the lives of individuals and communities. Within this framework, several of our research projects are developed within the field of social struggles and in collaboration with those who are building new political approaches to the commons.
On the other hand, explain from the approaches indicated, the wide range of conservatisms and actions against progressive governments that have been occurring in the countries of the region, such as: the judicialization of politics in a broad sense, the phenomenon of lawfare, coups d'état, soft coups, hybrid wars and their respective unilateral coercive measures that include legal, psychological and economic warfare.
Furthermore, we intend to continue deepening the analysis of the problems presented by our progressive governments within their geopolitical frameworks and conditioned by neoliberal policies within global capitalism, showing limitations, failures, or proposals that are not very committed to changing the socio-political and legal structures of domination and hegemony that we have in them.
Finally, we propose to expose the facets of the different legal disputes that occur within social groups, communities and peoples, related to human rights, with specificity in feminist, sex-gender diversities and indigenous peoples where critical, anti-capitalist perspectives, construction of otherness and patterns of liberation of them and their social environments predominate.
Barrera, A. (2001) Collective action and political crisis, the Ecuadorian indigenous movement in the nineties (Quito: Ciudad-Abya-Yala).
Benente Mauro, Navas Alvear Marco (comp.) 2019 Law, social conflict and emancipation. Between depression and hope, (GT CLACSO Collection, ILSA, University of Nariño, Colombia).
Bravo Espinosa, Yacotzin (2015) “Elements to understand the limits and possibilities of law and rights in the face of the dispossession of indigenous territories” in (Amicus Curie, v. 12, núm. 2, jul- dez, Universidade do Extremo Sul Catarinense).
Burgos Matamoros, Mylai and Hernández Cervantes, Aleida (Coord.) 2018, The dispute over the right: Hegemonic globalization vs the defense of peoples and social groups, (CEIICH, UNAM, Bonilla Artigas Editores, Mexico).
Correas, Oscar (2000) Introduction to the Critique of Modern Law (Mexico City: Fontamara).
____________, (2015) Critique of Legal Ideology (Mexico: Coyoacán Editions).
Echeverría, Bolívar (2012) Use value and utopia (Mexico, Siglo XXI).
Estupiñán-Achury, Liliana and Balmant, Lilian. (ed.). (2022). Constitutionalism from a decolonial perspective. Bogotá: Universidad Libre. Available at https://repository.unilibre.edu.co/handle/10901/22419.
Federici, Silvia (2020) Re-enchanting the world. Feminism and the politics of the commons, (Madrid, Traficantes de Sueños).
Gandarilla Salgado, José Guadalupe (2018) Neoliberal Colonialism. Modernity, Devastation and Market Automatism, (Ediciones Herramienta).
Gutiérrez Aguilar, R. (2008) Los pitmos del Pachakuti (Buenos Aires: Tinta limon).
Hernández Cervantes, Aleida (2019) “Legal structures of dispossession: a case of structural reform in Mexico”, in Mauro Benente and Marcos Navas Alvear (coords.), Law, social conflict and emancipation: between depression and hope.
Harvey, David (2017) A Brief History of Neoliberalism (Madrid, Akal).
Hinkelammert, Franz (2018) Totalitarianism of the market. The capitalist market as supreme being (Madrid, Akal).
López, López Liliana (2019) "Dispossession and reactionary use of state law. The case of Nestora Salgado", Gaussens, Pierre and Benítez, David (coords.) Political processes and social movements in Guerrero, (Mexico City, Metropolitan Autonomous University-Xochimilco).
Mascaro, Alysson Leandro (2013) State and political form (São Paulo: Boitempo).
Pisarello, G. (2011) A Long Thermidor (Quito, Constitutional Court for the Transition Period).
Ordoñez, Freddy (2018) Biocultural rights and the recognition of the Atrato River as an entity subject to rights. A look from socio-environmentalism and the rights of nature. The Other Right, (Bogotá: Latin American Institute for an Alternative Society and Law, ILSA)
Rivera Lugo, Carlos. (2011). “The Time of Non-Law”, Critical Review of Arts and Thought. Madrid.
________________. (2011). “The constitution of the common” in Daniel Nina (ed.), The common: Postcoloniality and law. San Juan, Puerto Rico, Isla Negra: Barco de Papel.
________________. (2019). Lawfare: A disputed concept. Argentina: CLACSO
Santos, Boaventura de Sousa and César A. Rodríguez Garavito (eds.) (Law and globalization from below. Towards a cosmopolitan legality (UAM Cuajimalpa- Anthropos, Mexico).
Santos, Boaventura de Sousa, et. to the. (2021). Decolonizing constitutionalism. Mexico: Akal.
Toro, Catalina, et al. (2020). The struggle for the commons and alternatives to development in the face of extractivism: perspectives from Latin American political ecology(ies). Buenos Aires: CLACSO.
Vega, Oki. (2011). “The Plurinational State”, Decolonization in Bolivia. La Paz: Vice Presidency of the Plurinational State.
Wolkmer, Antonio (2017). Critical Theory of Law from Latin America. Madrid: Akal.
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
To strengthen generational academic trajectories in critical legal thinking, especially in Latin America, the unnamed structural injustices and the disputes in the configuration of normative reality in legal and political contexts for the countries of Latin America and the Caribbean.
To organize theoretically and in working subgroups the interests of the GT with a view to generating academic production of greater impact and relevance in strengthening critical legal theory for Latin America and the Caribbean
To interpret and discuss lines of academic production from the perspective of intergenerational academic dialogue and horizontally with social movements and civil society organizations.
Development of products related to academic research, dissemination materials and instruments for use by civil society in document and video format, especially maintaining the CLACSO Bulletin of the Working Group on Critical Legal Thought
Publication and presentation of printed material: articles for scientific journals, popular science texts, press releases, newsletters, thematic brochures of the members of the GT in our lines of work.
Submission of contributions to CLACSO's periodical publications.
Preparation of a DOSSIER on the topics of the Working Group, in conjunction with social movements, NGOs and unions.
Academic activity: Co-creation dialogues for the protection of rights and resistance strategies with civil society organizations and social movements.
Activities with other GTs
GT: Agricultural work, inequalities and ruralities
Exploratory discussion: Agrarian work and legal structures of dispossession in Latin America.
GT: Political Economy of Information, Communication and Culture
First Meeting on Lawfare, Technopolitics and Communication Policies
Presentations and discussion of the same
Dialogue on research in the field
Development of joint work plans
-Strengthening the lines of work, academic trajectories and prioritized research questions in our working group through individual and collective publications and discussion and dissemination scenarios positioned in research centers and groups and in the Latin American and Caribbean academic community in general
-Public access to the knowledge produced by the Working Group in terms of thematic brochures, scientific articles, informative texts, press and dossiers and videos.
-Consolidation of the GT for joint research in the mutual exchange of knowledge and experiences from our different locations.
-Consolidation of relationships with other GTs (Agricultural work, inequalities and ruralities; Legacies and perspectives of Marxism; Lex mercatoria, human rights and democracy; Political economy of information, communication and culture) in the generation of new situated and relevant knowledge for the region in academic and praxis spaces
-Involvement, collaboration and participation in socio-political and legal activism in support of the affirmation of human rights and democracy in the countries of Our America with civil society organizations and social movements, state organizations and science and technology entities.
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
-To generate reflective spaces for academic training in the development of the group's thematic and research lines, such as the emerging issues of unequal social reality and the democratic and socio-political legal crisis of Our America, and to stimulate the training of new researchers in strategic socio-legal issues for Our America.
-To maintain and expand the academic and curricular positioning of the group in the region, reflected in the dialogues and interpretations that its production in postgraduate works generates, as well as its involvement in lectures and reading documents concerning lines of critical legal thought for Latin America and the Caribbean.
-Co-create spaces for the diversification of counter-hegemonic resistances from civil society, academia, social movements, NGOs and the various activisms with which a combative narrative and defense of rights converge.
-Disseminate the results of the Working Group's research periodically as a strategy for the group's academic-political positioning in public, university, community and social spheres.
-Maintain publicly available in virtual and printed form the results of the academic reflective work of the working group, adhering to the policies of open science and free access to knowledge.
-Dissemination of scientific and press articles, both individual and collective, related to academic research, as instruments for use by civil society in document and video format.
-Publication and presentation of printed material: articles for scientific journals, popular science texts, press releases, newsletters, thematic brochures of the members of the GT in our lines of work.
-Submission of contributions to CLACSO's periodical publications.
-Publication of dossiers on the topics of the Working Group, in conjunction with social movements, NGOs and unions.
-Academic activity: Our American leaderships: agendas, emergencies and disputes in direct dialogue with its actors.
-Strategic public placement of research for social movements, popular movements and civil society in general, embracing open science policies and free access to knowledge.
-Creation of videos on the web to promote/disseminate the debate on urgent issues in politics, economics and society related to legal, political, economic and social issues.
-Conducting workshops on research advances at various Latin American universities.
-Conducting workshops to disseminate and raise awareness about the GT's collaboration and support with social movements and civil society with whom work is carried out.
-Support in the creation of networks of seedbeds for young researchers
Activities with other GTs
GT: Legacies and perspectives of Marxism
Seminar 1: The relevance of Marxism in contemporary political debates, legal critique, and transformative practices;
GT: Lex mercatoria, human rights and democracy.
Seminar: Lex mercatoria and extra-state legal manifestations in Latin America and the Caribbean
-Consolidation of the training of new researchers in strategic areas of critical legal thought in Latin America, through monitoring and support of their work and initiatives. This also includes the consolidation of common spaces for reflection in the development of the thematic and research lines of the Working Group.
-Curricular innovations and inclusions of the GT's lines of debate reflected in the dialogues and interpretations of postgraduate works as well as in the inclusion of its lectures and reading documents concerning the lines of critical legal thought for Latin America and the Caribbean.
-Popular events and various forms of resistance, led especially by civil society, social movements, and NGOs, organized by the GT and led by its members
-Periodization in the dissemination of the results of the research of the Working Group as a political academic positioning strategy of the group in public, academic, community and social spheres.
-Consolidation of bibliographic, media, and film material in virtual and printed form of the results of the academic reflective work of the working group in a public manner.
-Participation in social networks, in the spaces of the annual meetings, integrating young researchers so that they can present their research and develop their knowledge collectively.
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
-Collaborate with government projects or participate in the search for resources so that the GT's research has an impact on the execution of public projects.
-Participate in schools, courses and spaces of interaction with NGOs and social movements, making visible, promoting and exchanging the uses of law and other ways of seeing and building the legal.
-To approach science and technology bodies to contribute in strategic areas for the countries of Our America.
-Promotion of courses and seminars in offices for state agents.
Delivery of courses and meetings with NGOs
FUNDALATIN. Latin American Foundation for Human Rights and Social Development (Venezuela)
-PRODESC-NGO Mexico (2020)
- Heinrich Boell Foundation for Latin America (Mexico headquarters)
- Territorial Liberation Movement (Argentina)
- Central de Trabajadores de la Argentina – Autónoma.
ATTAC (Argentina)
- ILSA Colombia
-Execute agreements with government bodies for the performance of studies or research.
Seek collaboration with science and technology organizations.
CONACYT-Mexico (2020)
Capes / CNPq (Brazil).
Colciencias (Colombia).
Conicet, National Agency for the Promotion of Research, Technological Development and Innovation (I+D+i Agency), Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovation (Argentina).
Ministry of the Interior: Vice Ministry of Social Dialogue, Human Rights and Equality - different directorates (indigenous affairs, Afro, human rights, prior consultation) (Colombia)
Ministry of Mines and Energy and Ministry of Environment. (Colombia)
Administrative Department of the Presidency: Presidential Youth Council. (Colombia)
Ministry of Culture (Colombia)
Exchange and feedback on work done with social movements regarding socio-legal struggles:
- Popular Democratic Youth (Colombia)
- Movement for a People's Constituent Assembly (Colombia)
-LGBTIQ+ and Women's Movement (Havana, Cuba)
- Socio-environmental movement (Cuba)
- Indigenous peoples' movements (Guerrero, Oaxaca- Mexico) (Colombian Amazon)
- Territorial Liberation Movement (Argentina)
- Central de Trabajadores de la Argentina – Autónoma.
ATTAC (Argentina)
- Feminist movements and diversities (Argentina)
-Social and trade union movement of the National Central Union of Education Workers (Mexico)
-University Network for Peace Gabriel Izquierdo REDUNIPAZ (Colombia)
-Peasant environmental movement of eastern Caldas- MACO- Colombia and Embracing the La Miel River (Colombia)
-Seminars, courses.
-Participatory support and research with local movements and/or organizations.
-Workshops to strengthen and expand the scientific and technological Research and Development (R&D) capacities of communities and young researchers
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
-Participate and connect with Latin American social science networks.
-To collaborate with academic institutions related to our research topics.
GT: Legacies and perspectives of Marxism
Seminar: Political and legal culture, malaise and inequality. The relevance of Marxism in contemporary debates on the crisis of law as a discipline and as an institution.
GT: Lex mercatoria, human rights and democracy.
Seminar: Lex mercatoria and extra-state legal manifestations in Latin America and the Caribbean
GT: Agricultural work, inequalities and ruralities
Exploratory discussion: Agrarian labor and legal institutions for dispossession in Latin America.
GT: Political Economy of Information, Communication and Culture
First Meeting on Lawfare, Technopolitics and Communication Policies
- Presentations and discussion of them
- Dialogue on research in the field
- Development of joint work plans
Participate in national, regional and international civil society networks that are related to the themes of the GT.
Participate in Social Science networks and carry out dissemination, exchanges and cooperation.
a. - Latin American Studies Association-LASA- Latin America (May 2021)
b. - Latin American Conference on Legal Criticism (CDMX, October 2021)
c. – Latin American Network of Constitutional Women
d.- Latin American Network of Critical Constitutionalism
e.- International Political Science Association (IPSA, Canada)
f.- Research Committee on Sociology of Law (RCSL)
Participate in network events
Apply to national and international calls for proposals from Science and Technology organizations that promote the generation of new scientific and technological knowledge developed by researchers belonging to the working groups with which it will be coordinated.
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
To maintain the purpose of strengthening generational academic trajectories in critical legal thinking, especially in Latin America, the unnamed structural injustices and the disputes in the configuration of normative reality in legal and political contexts for the countries of Latin America and the Caribbean.
To give continuity to the processes of organization and theoretical activity, and by working subgroups, of the interests of the GT with a view to generating academic production of greater impact and relevance in the strengthening of critical legal theory for Latin America and the Caribbean
To sustain the processes of interpretation and discussion of the thematic lines from the perspective of intergenerational academic dialogue and in horizontality with social movements and civil society organizations.
Production of a first book resulting from scientific articles and research discussed among the various member countries of the GT.
The scheduled meetings, both general, sub-regional and those of thematic interest, will continue to be held for the purpose of generating knowledge, with the aim of providing feedback on research by members of the Working Group from different countries for comparative studies in the disciplinary and socio-legal situation.
Development of products related to academic research, dissemination and instruments for use by civil society in document and video format.
The publication of new installments is planned through the CLACSO Bulletin of the Working Group on Critical Legal Thought
Publication and presentation of printed material: articles for scientific journals, popular science texts, press releases, newsletters, thematic brochures of the members of the GT in our lines of work.
Submission of contributions to CLACSO's periodical publications.
Implementation of academic activity: 2024 version of co-creation dialogues for the protection of rights and resistance strategies with civil society organizations
Individual and collective publications, subregional events in Latin American and Caribbean universities, with the participation of the members of the GT in reflective and discussion contexts around the research questions prioritized in our working group
Consolidation of GT research work.
Books, thematic brochures, scientific articles, popular science texts and press materials created in the GT
Instruments resulting from work with civil society and social movements.
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
Maintain and strengthen the spaces generated for academic training in the development of the group's thematic and research lines, such as the emerging issues of unequal social reality and the democratic and socio-political legal crisis of Our America, and continue to stimulate the training of new researchers in the strategic socio-legal issues for Our America.
Maintain the actions and initiatives of the first year and other calls which have achieved the academic and curricular positioning of the group in the region reflected in the dialogues and interpretations that its production provokes in postgraduate works as well as its incursion into the chairs and reading documents in what concerns the lines of critical legal thought for Latin America and the Caribbean.
To materialize products, reflections and actions associated with co-creation spaces with social movements, NGOs and the various activisms with which combative and rights-defending narratives converge.
To sustain the dissemination of the results of the Working Group's research on a regular basis as a political and academic positioning strategy of the group in public, university, community and social spheres.
To make publicly available, both virtually and in print, the results of the working group's academic reflection work, adhering to the policies of open science and free access to knowledge.
To provide training courses and hold debates on the most urgent issues in our political, legal, social and economic landscape.
To present the growth of training spaces for research seedbeds from the perspective of critical legal thinking.
Consolidate virtual public spaces for disseminating GT research.
Conducting general, subregional, and thematic academic events with civil society through roundtables, debates, seminars, and public colloquia to reflect on the state of our political and legal realities in the context of the GT's lines of work
Dissemination of scientific and press articles, both individual and collective, related to academic research, as instruments for use by civil society in document and video format.
Publication and presentation of printed material: articles for scientific journals, popular science texts, press releases, newsletters, thematic brochures of the members of the GT in our lines of work.
Submission of contributions to CLACSO's periodical publications.
Publication of dossiers on the topics of the Working Group, in conjunction with social movements, NGOs and trade unions.
Strategic public placement of research for social movements, popular movements and civil society in general, embracing open science policies and free access to knowledge.
Production of videos on the web to promote/disseminate the debate of urgent issues in politics, economics and society related to legal, political, economic and social issues.
Conducting workshops on research advances at various Latin American universities.
Conducting workshops to disseminate and raise awareness about the GT's collaboration and support with social movements and civil society with whom work is carried out.
Support in the creation of networks of seedbeds for young researchers
Activities with other GTs
GT: Legacies and perspectives of Marxism
Seminar 2: The relevance of Marxism for the analysis of the State, specifically Latin American and Caribbean states, and their emerging modes of societal normativity and justice.
GT: Agricultural work, inequalities and ruralities
Seminar 2 for public discussion: Modes and relationships of agricultural labor exploitation with legal institutions for dispossession in Latin America
Consolidation of the training of new researchers in strategic areas of critical legal thought in Latin America, through monitoring and support of their work and initiatives. This also includes the consolidation of common spaces for reflection in the development of the thematic and research lines of the Working Group.
Innovations and curricular inclusions of the GT's lines of debate reflected in the dialogues and interpretations of postgraduate works as well as in the inclusion of its lectures and reading documents concerning the lines of critical legal thought for Latin America and the Caribbean.
Popular events and various forms of resistance, led especially by civil society, social movements, and NGOs, organized by the GT and led by its members
Periodization in the dissemination of the results of the research of the Working Group as a political academic positioning strategy of the group in public, academic, community and social spheres.
Consolidation of bibliographic, media, and film material in virtual and printed form of the results of the academic reflective work of the working group in a public manner.
Participation in social networks, in the spaces of the annual meetings, integrating young researchers so that they can present their research and develop their knowledge collectively.
Among the most representative results that have been common during the GT's operations in other years are: Videos, virtual classes, public access workshops, public access seminars, meetings with civil society, participation in social networks, spaces for annual and partial meetings of young researchers, virtual networks, research on critical legal thinking.
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
Continue collaborating with government projects or participate in the search for resources so that the GT's research has an impact on the execution of public projects.
Participating in schools, courses and spaces of interaction with NGOs and social movements, making visible, promoting and exchanging the uses of law and other ways of seeing and constructing the legal.
To materialize the approach to science and technology bodies to contribute in strategic areas for the countries of Our America in projects, publications or actions to support academic production.
Promotion of courses and seminars in offices for state agents.
Delivery of courses and meetings with NGOs
FUNDALATIN. Latin American Foundation for Human Rights and Social Development (Venezuela)
-PRODESC-NGO Mexico (2020)
- Heinrich Boell Foundation for Latin America (Mexico headquarters)
- Territorial Liberation Movement (Argentina)
- Central de Trabajadores de la Argentina – Autónoma.
ATTAC (Argentina)
- ILSA Colombia
Seek collaboration with science and technology organizations.
CONACYT-Mexico (2020)
Capes / CNPq (Brazil).
Colciencias (Colombia).
Conicet, National Agency for the Promotion of Research, Technological Development and Innovation (I+D+i Agency), Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovation (Argentina).
Ministry of the Interior: Vice Ministry of Social Dialogue, Human Rights and Equality - different directorates (indigenous affairs, Afro, human rights, prior consultation) (Colombia)
Ministry of Mines and Energy and Ministry of Environment. (Colombia)
Administrative Department of the Presidency: Presidential Youth Council. (Colombia)
Ministry of Culture (Colombia)
Exchange and feedback on work done with social movements regarding socio-legal struggles:
- Popular Democratic Youth (Colombia)
- Movement for a People's Constituent Assembly (Colombia)
-LGBTIQ+ and Women's Movement (Havana, Cuba)
- Socio-environmental movement (Cuba)
- Indigenous peoples' movements (Guerrero, Oaxaca- Mexico) (Colombian Amazon)
- Territorial Liberation Movement (Argentina)
- Central de Trabajadores de la Argentina – Autónoma.
ATTAC (Argentina)
- Feminist movements and diversities (Argentina)
Social and trade union movement of the National Central Union of Education Workers (Mexico)
University Network for Peace Gabriel Izquierdo REDUNIPAZ (Colombia)
Peasant environmental movement of eastern Caldas - MACO - Colombia and Embracing the La Miel River (Colombia)
-Seminars, courses.
-Participatory support and research with local movements and/or organizations.
-Workshops to strengthen and expand the scientific and technological Research and Development (R&D) capacities of communities and young researchers
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
Participate and connect with Latin American social science networks.
To collaborate with academic institutions related to our research topics.
GT: Legacies and perspectives of Marxism
Seminar: Political and legal culture, malaise and inequality. The relevance of Marxism in contemporary debates on the crisis of law as a discipline and as an institution.
GT: Lex mercatoria, human rights and democracy.
Seminar 2: Lex mercatoria and extra-state legal manifestations in Latin America and the Caribbean
GT: Agricultural work, inequalities and ruralities
Seminar 2 for public discussion: Modes and relationships of agricultural labor exploitation with legal institutions for dispossession in Latin America
GT: Political Economy of Information, Communication and Culture
First Meeting on Lawfare, Technopolitics and Communication Policies
- Presentations and discussion of them
- Dialogue on research in the field
- Development of joint work plans
Participate in network events
Apply to national and international calls for proposals from Science and Technology organizations that promote the generation of new scientific and technological knowledge developed by researchers belonging to the working groups with which it will be coordinated.
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
To close and consolidate the processes of strengthening generational academic trajectories in critical legal thinking, especially in Latin America, the unnamed structural injustices and the disputes in the configuration of normative reality in legal and political contexts for the countries of Latin America and the Caribbean.
To give continuity to the processes of organization and theoretical activity, and by working subgroups, of the interests of the GT with a view to generating academic production of greater impact and relevance in the strengthening of critical legal theory for Latin America and the Caribbean.
To sustain the processes of interpretation and discussion of the thematic lines from the perspective of intergenerational academic dialogue and in horizontality with social movements and civil society organizations.
Production of a second book resulting from scientific articles and research discussed among the various member countries of the GT.
To fulfill the final agenda of scheduled meetings, both general, subregional and by thematic interest, for the purpose of generating knowledge, in the logic of providing feedback to research of the members of the GT from different countries for comparative studies in the disciplinary and socio-legal social situation.
Development of products related to academic research, dissemination and instruments for use by civil society in document and video format.
Publication of new installments through the CLACSO Bulletin of the Working Group on Critical Legal Thought
Publication and presentation of printed material: articles for scientific journals, popular science texts, press releases, newsletters, thematic brochures of the members of the GT in our lines of work.
Submission of contributions to CLACSO's periodical publications.
Implementation of academic activity: 2025 version of co-creation dialogues for the protection of rights and resistance strategies with civil society organizations
Individual and collective publications, subregional events in Latin American and Caribbean universities, with the participation of the members of the GT in reflective and discussion contexts around the research questions prioritized in our working group
Consolidation of GT research work.
Books, thematic brochures, scientific articles, popular science texts and press materials created in the GT
Instruments resulting from work with civil society and social movements.
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
Maintain and strengthen the spaces generated for academic training in the development of the group's thematic and research lines, such as the emerging issues of unequal social reality and the democratic and socio-political legal crisis of Our America, and continue to stimulate the training of new researchers in the strategic socio-legal issues for Our America.
Maintain the actions and initiatives of the first and second year and other calls which have achieved the academic and curricular positioning of the group in the region reflected in the dialogues and interpretations that its production provokes in postgraduate works as well as its incursion into the chairs and reading documents in what concerns the lines of critical legal thought for Latin America and the Caribbean.
To materialize products, reflections and actions associated with co-creation spaces with social movements, NGOs and the various activisms with which combative and rights-defending narratives converge.
To comply with the dissemination agendas of the Working Group's research results on a regular basis as a political and academic positioning strategy of the group in public, university, community and social spheres.
To make publicly available, both virtually and in print, the results of the working group's academic reflection work, adhering to the policies of open science and free access to knowledge.
To conclude with the final training sessions for research groups based on critical legal thinking.
Consolidate virtual public spaces for disseminating GT research.
Conducting general, subregional, and thematic academic events with civil society through roundtables, debates, seminars, and public colloquia to reflect on the state of our political and legal realities in the context of the GT's lines of work
Dissemination of scientific and press articles, both individual and collective, related to academic research, as instruments for use by civil society in document and video format.
Publication and presentation of printed material: articles for scientific journals, popular science texts, press releases, newsletters, thematic brochures of the members of the GT in our lines of work.
Submission of contributions to CLACSO's periodical publications.
Publication of dossiers on the topics of the Working Group, in conjunction with social movements, NGOs and trade unions.
Strategic public placement of research for social movements, popular movements and civil society in general, embracing open science policies and free access to knowledge.
Production of videos on the web to promote/disseminate the debate of urgent issues in politics, economics and society related to legal, political, economic and social issues.
Conducting workshops on research advances at various Latin American universities.
Conducting workshops to disseminate and raise awareness about the GT's collaboration and support with social movements and civil society with whom work is carried out.
Activities with other GTs
GT: Legacies and perspectives of Marxism
Seminar 2: The relevance of Marxism for the analysis of the State, specifically Latin American and Caribbean states, and their emerging modes of societal normativity and justice.
GT: Agricultural work, inequalities and ruralities
Seminar 3 for public discussion: Modes and relationships of agricultural labor exploitation with legal institutions for dispossession in Latin America
GT: Political Economy of Information, Communication and Culture
Second Meeting on Lawfare, Technopolitics and Communication Policies
- Discussion of papers
- Dialogue on research in the field
- Preparation of conclusions with the possibility of joint publication with articles by researchers
Consolidation of the training of new researchers in strategic areas of critical legal thought in Latin America, through monitoring and support of their work and initiatives. This also includes the consolidation of common spaces for reflection in the development of the thematic and research lines of the Working Group.
Innovations and curricular inclusions of the GT's lines of debate reflected in the dialogues and interpretations of postgraduate works as well as in the inclusion of its lectures and reading documents concerning the lines of critical legal thought for Latin America and the Caribbean.
Popular events and various forms of resistance, led especially by civil society, social movements, and NGOs, organized by the GT and led by its members
Periodization in the dissemination of the results of the research of the Working Group as a political academic positioning strategy of the group in public, academic, community and social spheres.
Consolidation of bibliographic, media, and film material in virtual and printed form of the results of the academic reflective work of the working group in a public manner.
Participation in social networks, in the spaces of the annual meetings, integrating young researchers so that they can present their research and develop their knowledge collectively.
Among the most representative results that have been common during the GT's operations in other years are: Videos, virtual classes, public access workshops, public access seminars, meetings with civil society, participation in social networks, spaces for annual and partial meetings of young researchers, virtual networks, research on critical legal thinking.
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
Continue collaborating with government projects or participate in the search for resources so that the GT's research has an impact on the execution of public projects.
Participating in schools, courses and spaces of interaction with NGOs and social movements, making visible, promoting and exchanging the uses of law and other ways of seeing and constructing the legal.
To materialize the approach to science and technology bodies to contribute in strategic areas for the countries of Our America in projects, publications or actions to support academic production.
Promotion of courses and seminars in offices for state agents.
Delivery of courses and meetings with NGOs
FUNDALATIN. Latin American Foundation for Human Rights and Social Development (Venezuela)
-PRODESC-NGO Mexico (2020)
- Heinrich Boell Foundation for Latin America (Mexico headquarters)
- Territorial Liberation Movement (Argentina)
- Central de Trabajadores de la Argentina – Autónoma.
ATTAC (Argentina)
- ILSA Colombia
To execute agreements with government bodies for the execution of studies or research.
Seek collaboration with science and technology organizations.
CONACYT-Mexico (2020)
Capes / CNPq (Brazil).
Colciencias (Colombia).
Conicet, National Agency for the Promotion of Research, Technological Development and Innovation (I+D+i Agency), Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovation (Argentina).
Ministry of the Interior: Vice Ministry of Social Dialogue, Human Rights and Equality - different directorates (indigenous affairs, Afro, human rights, prior consultation) (Colombia)
Ministry of Mines and Energy and Ministry of Environment. (Colombia)
Administrative Department of the Presidency: Presidential Youth Council. (Colombia)
Ministry of Culture (Colombia)
Exchange and feedback on work done with social movements regarding socio-legal struggles:
- Popular Democratic Youth (Colombia)
- Movement for a People's Constituent Assembly (Colombia)
-LGBTIQ+ and Women's Movement (Havana, Cuba)
- Socio-environmental movement (Cuba)
- Indigenous peoples' movements (Guerrero, Oaxaca- Mexico) (Colombian Amazon)
- Territorial Liberation Movement (Argentina)
- Central de Trabajadores de la Argentina – Autónoma.
ATTAC (Argentina)
- Feminist movements and diversities (Argentina)
Social and trade union movement of the National Central Union of Education Workers (Mexico)
University Network for Peace Gabriel Izquierdo REDUNIPAZ (Colombia)
Peasant environmental movement of eastern Caldas - MACO - Colombia and Embracing the La Miel River (Colombia)
-Seminars, courses.
-Participatory support and research with local movements and/or organizations.
-Workshops to strengthen and expand the scientific and technological Research and Development (R&D) capacities of communities and young researchers
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
Participate and connect with Latin American social science networks.
To collaborate with academic institutions related to our research topics.
GT: Legacies and perspectives of Marxism
Seminar: Political and legal culture, malaise and inequality. The relevance of Marxism in contemporary debates on the crisis of law as a discipline and as an institution.
GT: Lex mercatoria, human rights and democracy.
Seminar 2: Lex mercatoria and extra-state legal manifestations in Latin America and the Caribbean
GT: Agricultural work, inequalities and ruralities
Seminar 3 for public discussion: Modes and relationships of agricultural labor exploitation with legal institutions for dispossession in Latin America
GT: Political Economy of Information, Communication and Culture
First Meeting on Lawfare, Technopolitics and Communication Policies
- Presentations and discussion of them
- Dialogue on research in the field
- Development of joint work plans
Participate in national, regional and international civil society networks that are related to the themes of the GT.
Participate in Social Science networks and carry out dissemination, exchanges and cooperation.
a. - Latin American Studies Association-LASA- Latin America (May 2021)
b. - Latin American Conference on Legal Criticism (CDMX, October 2021)
c. – Latin American Network of Constitutional Women
d.- Latin American Network of Critical Constitutionalism
e.- International Political Science Association (IPSA, Canada)
f.- Research Committee on Sociology of Law (RCSL)
Participate in network events
Apply to national and international calls for proposals from Science and Technology organizations that promote the generation of new scientific and technological knowledge developed by researchers belonging to the working groups with which it will be coordinated.
Total number of researchers admitted: 60
School of law and social sciences
Caldas University
Colombia
Latin American Network of Constitutional Women
Bolivia
Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities
Autonomous University of San Luis Potosí
Mexico
Foundation for Social and Political Research
Argentina
Postgraduate degree in Law from LaSalle University
Brazil
Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities
Autonomous University of San Luis Potosí
Mexico
Research Coordination of the Faculty of Philosophy and Letters
Faculty of Philosophy and Letters
National Autonomous University of Mexico
Mexico
Center for Political and Social Studies of Latin America
-University of Los Andes
Venezuela
Latin American Studies Program
Simón Bolívar Andean University
Ecuador
Joaquín Herrera Flores Institute - Latin America
Brazil
Institute of Higher National Studies
State Graduate University
Ecuador
Research Group State, Government and Dependent Capitalism – Federal University of Alagoas
Brazil
Federal University of Viçosa
Brazil
Faculty of Legal and Social Sciences, National University of La Plata
Argentina
Fundação Getulio Vargas
Brazil
Center for Latin American Studies and Research
University of Nariño
Colombia
Central University of Venezuela
Venezuela
Institute for Latin American Cooperation
Universidad Nacional de Rosario
Argentina
Postgraduate Program in Latin American Studies
Postgraduate Coordination Area, Faculty of Philosophy and Letters
National Autonomous University of Mexico
Mexico
University of São Paulo
Brazil
Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences, Argentina
Argentina Program
Argentina
Latin American Institute for an Alternative Society and Law
Colombia
Faculty of Law/ National Autonomous University of Mexico
Mexico
Autonomous University of Mexico City
Academic coordination
Autonomous University of Mexico City
Mexico
Center for Social Sciences and Humanities
Autonomous University of Aguascalientes
Mexico
Center for Research and Higher Studies in Social Anthropology
Member of the CONACyT Public Research Center System
Mexico
Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities
Autonomous University of San Luis Potosí
Mexico
Louis Joseph Lebret OP Research Center for Economics and Humanism
Santo Tomas University
Colombia
Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities
Autonomous University of San Luis Potosí
Mexico
School of Psychology
Pontifical Catholic University of Valparaíso
Chile
Higher School of Tourism, National Polytechnic Institute
Mexico
Foundation for Social and Political Research
Argentina
Foundation for Social and Political Research
Argentina
Institute for Latin American Cooperation
Universidad Nacional de Rosario
Argentina
Center for Research on Latin America and the Caribbean
National Autonomous University of Mexico
Mexico
Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities
Autonomous University of San Luis Potosí
Mexico
Vice-Rectorate for Research and Innovation
University of Cuenca
Ecuador
Post-Graduation Program in Socioeconomic Development. Academic Unit of Applied Social Sciences. Universidade do Extremo Sul Catarinense.
Universidade do Extremo Sul Catarinense.
Brazil
Division of Social Sciences and Humanities
Metropolitan Autonomous University - Xochimilco Unit
Mexico
Master's Degree in Cultural Management and Administration
Program in Interdisciplinary Studies, Faculty of Humanities, Río Piedras Campus
University of Puerto Rico
Puerto Rico
Center for Interdisciplinary Research in Sciences and Humanities
National Autonomous University of Mexico
Mexico
Institute for Latin American Cooperation
Universidad Nacional de Rosario
Argentina
Center for Interdisciplinary Research in Sciences and Humanities
National Autonomous University of Mexico
Mexico
Center for Social Studies
Faculty of Economics
historic university
Portugal
School of law and social sciences
Caldas University
Colombia