Thematic Field: Public and Collective Health
WorkgroupSocial studies for health
Oswaldo Cruz Foundation
Brazil
Master's Degree in Social Medicine/Doctorate in Public Health Sciences
Division of Biological and Health Sciences
Autonomous Metropolitan University Xochimilco
Mexico
Alejandro Lipschutz Institute of Sciences
Non-Governmental Development Organization
Chile
The focus of this Working Group, "Social Studies for Health," is a social science perspective on the health conditions of Latin American and Caribbean populations, the social determinants that define them, especially structural inequalities related to class, gender, ethnicity, sexual orientation, and other factors associated with individuals' membership in large social groups, resulting in an unequal distribution of material and symbolic wealth. Similarly, the topic is linked to access to the right to health, the conception, construction, and development of health systems, the development processes and political systems of the region's countries, and their orientations within the framework of major global trends and planetary power relations. Most of the members have belonged to this CLACSO group since its inception in 2013, making it the first of its kind to bring together health professionals with training in Public Health and Social Medicine. This field shares a common perspective from the social sciences to study and understand the processes of health and disease, their distribution, the policies that design the social responses of the State or communities; the impacts of industrial society and predatory neoliberal society on the environment and the transformation of territories, resources and their inhabitants;
The major problems addressed in the Working Group's reflections can be summarized as follows: health inequalities among Latin American and Caribbean populations stemming from the accumulation of historical problems related to poverty, which determine disease patterns; simultaneously, inequalities in access to healthcare determine morbidity and mortality patterns; chronic diseases resulting from development conditions exacerbated by the capitalist system of exploitation and aggravated by neoliberalism, characterized by the intensification of predatory, extractive, and polluting processes, individualization, the breakdown of social networks, and the commodification of social life, all of which threaten the lives and health of individuals in their territories. The effects on health are diverse and well-documented, for example, the relationship between these transformations and cancers; the exponential growth of chronic diseases due to dietary changes and food insecurity linked to the loss of food sovereignty and the cultural erosion of indigenous peoples; and mental health problems resulting from a poor quality of life in terms of health. Climate change with consequences in catastrophes such as the COVID-19 pandemic, hurricanes, fires, etc.
The members of the Working Group bring together the following thematic expertise: Collective Health - Social Determinants - Health Systems - Health Sciences Education; Collective action and social participation in health; Social security, aging and older persons; Health Policies and Systems, Political Economy of Health; Social determinants of health; Digital technologies and health; Policy Analysis in Health, Health Policies and Systems. Participatory Management in Health, Gender and Health;
Social Policy; health and social security policies and systems; International Health and Health Cooperation. Management and evaluation of programs and projects; Organization of Health Services. Health Economics; Public Health - Collective, Occupational Health, Social Movements in Health, Health Systems, Occupational Risk Systems; Health, Gender; Collective Health, Health Policies, Development and Social Protection Policies, Democracy; Health Policy, Health System, Workers' Health; Health policies, systems and practices; Communication and health, Knowledge and health, Gender and health, Violence, Qualitative Research; Public Health Policies/Management of Public Health and Social Policies; Health Policies, Immigration, Agrochemicals and health; Sociology of health, Civil society. Collective action; Health policies, Health financing, Economic policies, Inequalities, Intellectual Property Rights; Mental Health, Social participation in health; Comparative history of health systems and policies and social projection; Equity in health; Territory and health; Cultural heritage of health;
Social protection, Care, Citizen participation, Social policies; Social medicine; Health policy and social security; Intercultural health, Prison health, Qualitative research methodology in health.
ECLAC (2022). Repercussions in Latin America and the Caribbean of the war in Ukraine: how to face this new crisis?
Costa, Ana Maria; RIZZOTTO, Maria Lucia; LOBATO, Lenaura. The Covid-19 pandemic, or Brazil enxerga or SUS. SAÚDE EM DEBATE, v. 44, p. 289-296, 2020.
Costa, Ana Maria Politica de Saúde Integral da Mulher e Direitos Sexuais e Reprodutivos in Politicas e Sistema de Saude no Brasil, 2.ed rev e amp/Organized by Ligia Giovanella, Sarah Escorel, Lenaura de Vasconcelos Lobato et al. Rio de Janeiro: Editora Fiocruz, 2012 1100p il tab,graf ISBN 978.85.7541.417-0
Costa, Ana Maria. Health and Development in Lula and Dilma: 10 years of Post Neoliberal Governments in Brazil. Emir Sader, Org São Paulo,SP: Boitempo, Rio de Janeiro,RJ:FLACSO Brasil.2013 ISBN 978-85-7559-328-8
Eibenschutz, Catalina and Vázquez, Aurora, 2019, The Doctor, a superman?, in Chapela, Ma. del Consuelo (Ed.), Being a doctor. Stories, histories and reflections in search of its elusive essence, UAM-Xochimilco, Mexico, pp. 195-215.
Feo, Oscar, Venezuela. The national public health system and the management of the pandemic. A view from collective health. Revista Territorios Comunes, No. 4 August 2021.
Gadelha Vieira, Paulo Ernani; Noronha, José Carvalho; Castro, Leonardo; Pereira, Telma Ruth (Org.) . Economy and financing of the Brazilian health system. 1st. ed. Rio de Janeiro: Edições Livres, 2021. 286p.
Giovanella, Ligia, Vega, Román, Tejerina-Silva, Herland, Acosta-Ramirez, Naidú, Parada-Lezcano, Mario, Ríos, G., ... & Feo, Oscar. (2020). Is comprehensive primary health care part of the response to the Covid-19 pandemic in Latin America? Trabalho, Educação e Saúde, 19.
Hernández-Álvarez, M. (2022) "A single public health system for Colombia is possible and necessary" in: Otálvaro Castro, GJ, Guerrero Espinel, JE (editors). The fundamental right to health and social security 30 years after the 1991 Political Constitution: challenges and lessons learned. (Medellín: University of Antioquia, FCSH Publishing Fund of the Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities; University of Antioquia, National School of Public Health: 412-433).
Hernández, Macarena; Rodríguez, Claudio (2022). Social policy and care experiences in times of pandemic, social uprising and constituent process. Challenges for social protection. In Tetelboin, Carolina; Iturrieta, Daisy; Noronha José (Coords.) Pandemics, Inequalities and social practices in health. Perspectives for transformation in Latin America. Ed CLACSO, Buenos Aires.
Human Rights Report Paraguay 2020. A country living in a state of emergency and a 90s-era health reform. Martin, Mariluz; Lima, Patricia. Available at: https://ddhh2020.codehupy.org.py/un-pais-que-vive-en-emergencia/
Human Rights Report Paraguay 2021. Right to Health. The imprint of social grief is the driving force for the refounding of a single, universal health system. Martin, Mariluz. Available at: https://ddhh2021.codehupy.org.py/la-huella-del-duelo-social-es-el-motor-para-la-refundacion-de-un-sistema-unico-y-universal-de-salud/
Iturrieta, Daisy. Institutional Responses to the COVID-19 Pandemic in Chilean Prisons: A Perspective from Public Health in Latin America. Society, Politics and Health in Times of Pandemics (Buenos Aires: CLACSO, March 2021). ISBN 978-987-722-841-0.
Iturrieta, Daisy. Tensions and challenges of culturally relevant care for indigenous peoples in the context of pandemics in Chile, in Pandemics, inequalities and social practices in health: Perspectives for the transformation of Latin America (Buenos Aires: CLACSO, June 2022). ISBN 978-987-813-212-9.
Laurell, Asa Cristina (2020) The dimensions of the pandemic, Trimestre Económico vol. LXXX
The theoretical relevance of this topic lies in recognizing health as a definable field of study within the social sphere, specifically in the expressions of health and illness, and the social response to healthcare, all within the context of socio-historical processes. The analytical perspective can be summarized as the development of what is known as social medicine and Latin American collective health. This field originated as an academic concern and a concern of organized groups beginning in the 1970s, in response to one of the explanatory limitations of analyses based on a biological, medicalized, disease-centered, hospital-based, and physician-centered perspective, and with a training system that reproduces a classist, racist, and exclusionary social order that marginalizes diverse identities.
This current of thought, centered on health and life, care, and its determinants, has drawn on the critical thinking available at each stage of the field's theoretical and practical development. It identifies the dimensions and distribution of the diverse problems that comprise it, while also understanding the functions associated with these problems within so-called medical practice, considered the hegemonic model within the framework of capitalist production and reproduction processes. Especially since the 1980s, during its neoliberal phase, the field has been oriented toward reinforcing the characteristics of the medical model through the influence of international financial institutions on public policy, privatizing public resources and diminishing the direct functions of states. Within the framework of current progressive processes, there are attempts and difficulties in rethinking policies and reclaiming the public sphere, while simultaneously reconstructing a model that responds to the social needs and health demands of organizations, placing the conditions for the social reproduction of life and health of populations at the center of public and social concerns.
Among these sources, one can cite the 4/10/22, 13:18 CLACSO Working Groups https://www.clacso.org.ar/clacso_grupos_de_trabajo/sistema_gt-en-migracion-nuevo-servidor/convocatoria_nuevos_gt_2019/evaluacion_integracion_resultado? 4/13 social medicine of the 19th century that defined the processes of health and disease as
As a consequence of the unhealthy environment and miserable living conditions, social medicine and public health have drawn from critical social sciences, including authors like Marx and Engels, who contributed to the relationship between living conditions and health while also describing the first forms of intervention in the construction of the capitalist state; the Frankfurt School's concept of instrumental reason (Horkheimer); the analytical theory of science versus dialectics (Habermas); and the limits of legitimacy and accumulation (Offe). French post-structuralism and the contributions of Foucault and Bourdieu, as well as Passeron's contributions to the field of education and the reproduction of ideas, have also played a significant role. Among Latin American thinkers, there is already a vast body of theoretical work that has identified problems surrounding economic, political, and ideological relationships in the field of health. In this way, health in general, and its two objects of study—health-disease processes and the social response—are understood within their social determinants. That is to say, the characteristics of the intrinsic object or essential function are determined by the specific and long-term context, based on the functions of capitalist production and reproduction in general, and in this case, in dependent societies.
Other areas of concern include the consequences for work processes, the flexibilization that has meant longer working hours, precarious wages, high levels of technology, and the existence of a parallel economy of drug and human trafficking, among 28 other causes. At the same time, neoliberalism has freed or reduced state controls on companies, which, along with the use of networks and media with market models, have bombarded the population with information.
Intensifying the consumption of processed products has resulted in the loss of productive capacity, a lack of public oversight, unemployment, and increased domestic and social violence, which have deteriorated the health of populations. Furthermore, healthcare systems have become increasingly commodified, with varying degrees of intensity in each country, leading to the destruction and discrediting of public and social security institutions. This has fostered the development of a healthcare industry through the use of workers' contributions, state-funded private insurance, public procurement from private entities, and many other mechanisms. Simultaneously, this has meant a shift in the operation and characteristics of the medical-biological model, replacing medical criteria with economic ones and changing the central agents from physicians to economists, among other changes. Overall, we are facing deteriorating health conditions and dysfunctional healthcare systems. On the other hand, we are witnessing the rise of progressive governments that have improved the living and health conditions of their people, as in the cases of Bolivia and Venezuela before the end of the boycott, while also exploring the difficult path towards decommodification and universal healthcare in local, regional, and national governments.
Alzueta, Igor; Rodríguez, Claudio (2021). Pandemic, public policies and the dispute surrounding the State. The comparative case of Chile and Spain. In González, Sergio (ed), Chile at the vertex of social transformation. (Re)considerations psychosocial in times of global crisis. Ed. USACH, Santiago de Chile.
Arouca, S. (2008). The preventive dilemma: Contributions to the understanding and critique of
Preventive medicine. Editorial Place. Buenos Aires. ISBN 978-950-892-308-0.
Assoun, Paul-Lurent (1991), The Frankfurt School, Presses Universitaires de France/Cruz Publications, Mexico, 111p.
Basile, Gonzalo, Feo, Oscar (2022). Towards an epistemology of refounding health systems in the 21st century: contributions to the decolonization of theories, policies and practices. Rev. Fac. Nac. Salud Pública. Vol. 40 No. 2: May-August.
Benach, J. and Carles Muntaner (2005), Learning to look at health. How social inequality
damages our health, Dr. Arnoldo Gabaldón Institute of Advanced Studies in Public Health
Maracay, Venezuela, Chapter VIII.
Berlinguer, Giovanni (1975), a) Capital as a pathogenic factor, in Medicine and Politics, Ed.
Fourth World, Buenos Aires, Chapter I.
Berlinguer, Giovanni (2001), The disease, Lugar Editorial, Buenos Aires, chapter III.
Beveridge, WH (2008), Social Security in England. Beveridge Plan, CIESS, Mexico, pp.7-31.
Biagini, Graciela. Public good or commodity? Civil society and COVID-19 vaccines. XV National Conference on Interdisciplinary Debate in Health and Population, July 2022. Conference Proceedings.
Biagini, Graciela. COVID-19 Pandemic: State, Communication and Social Construction (co-author), Latin America: Society, Politics and Health in Times of Pandemics, CLACSO, 2021.
Bourdieu, P. (1999), The Misery of the World. Mexico: Fondo de Cultura Económica, 161-269.
Bourdieu, P. (2002), “Reproduction Strategies and Modes of Domination”. Collection
Pedagogical University; (37-38):1-27.
Braudel, Fernand (1968), History and the Social Sciences, The Long Duration, Alianza
Editorial, Madrid, p.60-106.
Brehil, Jaime, The social determinants of health as a tool for transformation, towards a new public health, Rev., Fac. Nac. Salud. Pública 2013, 31.
Breilh J. (2003), Bases for a counter-hegemonic epidemiology, in Critical Epidemiology. Emancipatory Science and Interculturality. Lugar Editorial/National University of Lanus, Buenos Aires, Argentina, Chapter VI and VII.
Breilh, J. (2010). Critical epidemiology: a new way of looking at health in urban space. Collective Health, 6(1): 83-101.
Breilh, J. (2013), The social determination of health as a tool for transformation towards a new public health (collective health), in Rev. Fac. Nacional de Salud Pública, vol. 3 (suppl.1), University of Antioquia, Colombia, p. 13-27.
Breilh, Jaime, (1997), “A epidemiologia na humanizacao da vida: convergences desencontros das currents”, in Barradas, Rita and et. Al., Equidade e health. Contribuicoes da epidemiología, Editora Fiocruz, RJ, Brazil, pp. 23-37.
BURLANDY, Luciene. ; LOBATO, Lenaura; SENNA, Monica. Transformations in social assistance, food and nutritional security and health policies in Brazil. In: Senna, M.
Canguilhem C. (1978) The Normal and the Pathological, Mexico: Siglo XXI. pp. 137-177.
Chalmers, Alan F. (1997), What Is This Thing Called Science? An Appraisal of the Nature and Status of Science and Its Methods, Siglo XXI Editores, Mexico, XIX Spanish edition, chapters 8, 9 and 10, pp. 127-172.
Collins, Ch; Green, A. (1994) Decentralization and primary health care: some negative implications in developing countries. International Journal of Health Services 24(3):459-475.
COMMISSION ON SOCIAL DETERMINANTS OF HEALTH (2005), Towards a framework with
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
To produce relevant and comparative social research on the determinants of health from regional and national trends in policies, especially social and health policies, in the living and health conditions of populations, and the forms of institutional and social responses in neoliberal and progressive contexts of Latin America and the Caribbean.
GT work a) virtual b) face-to-face for the planning and evaluation of activities;
Participation in meetings
Latin Americans from the GT networks: CLACSO, ALAS, ALAMES, ABRASCO, People's Summit and/or academic and social.
Development of the GT Health Training project (2024-2025).
- 1 Draft of a collective book with a view to publication: "Political democratization and the process of universalization and the right to health in Latin America and the Caribbean."
- 1 preparation of the GT's thematic bulletin.
-1 course proposal for 2024
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
2.- Dissemination of the GT newsletter
3.- Public thematic webinars on current or theoretical topics.
-Conferences
-Presence in the media.
Dissemination of the newsletter by CLACSO and GT networks and academia.
4 Working Group Webinars on various topics related to the book in progress.
2 appearances in Media
communication
2 conferences
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
and defend the right to health
in all policies and a universal public and social health system, with responsibility of the State in its
Funding. Government bodies: Ministries or State Secretariats; political organizations; trade unions; academic institutions, NGOs, social movements.
3 institutional links
3 relevant contributions
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
that the GT maintains relationships for the advancement of the universal right to health and the recovery of the State in the strengthening of its institutions, public financing, the defense of life and territories, with a perspective of rights, equity and against privatization in health.
2 Relationships in activities with other GT
3 Relationships with other networks and institutions.
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
To produce relevant and comparative social research on the determinants of health from regional and national trends in policies, especially social and health policies, in the living and health conditions of populations, and the forms of institutional and social responses in neoliberal and progressive contexts of Latin America and the Caribbean.
2. Presentations at meetings
Latin Americans from the GT of the year networks (CLACSO, ALAMES, ABRASCO, and/or academic and social).
3.- Development of the GT's "Health Training" project.
- Development of the GT book 5 project.
- 1 publication of the collective book 4: "Political democratization and the process of universalization and the right to health in Latin America and the Caribbean."
- 1 GT Thematic Bulletin.
- 1 thematic course for 2024 annually.
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
process, and health training.
2.- Dissemination of the GT newsletter.
3.- Public thematic webinars on current events and/or theoretical topics.
- Dissemination of the newsletter by CLACSO to CLACSO and GT networks and academia.
- 4 public online webinars from the GT on GT topics.
- 2 appearances in Media
communication.
- 2 conferences
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
3 institutional links
3 relevant contributions
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
that the GT maintains relationships for the advancement of the universal right to health.
2 Relationships in activities with other GT
3 Relationships with other networks and institutions.
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
To produce relevant and comparative social research on the determinants of health from regional and national trends in policies, especially social and health policies, in the living and health conditions of populations, and the forms of institutional and social responses in neoliberal and progressive contexts of Latin America and the Caribbean.
GT work a) virtual b) face-to-face for the planning and evaluation of activities;
- Participation in meetings
Latin Americans from the GT networks: CLACSO, ALAS, ALAMES, ABRASCO, People's Summit and/or academic and social.
Development of the Health Training project of the GT.
- 1 Draft of a collective book with a view to publication.
- 1 preparation of the GT's thematic bulletin.
-1 course proposal for 2025.
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
process, and health training.
- Dissemination of the GT newsletter.
- Thematic webinars.
- GT training course.
- Dissemination of the newsletter by CLACSO and GT networks and academia.
- 4 GT Webinars on various topics related to the book or current events.
- 2 appearances in Media
communication.
- 2 lectures.
-1 Training course
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
3 institutional links
3 relevant contributions
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
that the GT maintains relationships for the advancement of the universal right to health.
- 2 Relationships in meetings and/or activities with other GT
- 3 Relationships with other networks and institutions.
Total number of researchers admitted: 28
Mexican Social Security Institute
Mexico
Western Paraná State University (Unioeste)
Brazil
Department of Social Sciences
National University of Avellaneda
Argentina
Oswaldo Cruz Foundation
Brazil
Oswaldo Cruz Foundation
Brazil
Ministry of Health
Bolivia
Institute of Social Sciences
Paraguay
Documentation and Studies Center
Paraguay
Department of Political Science
Faculty of Law, Political Science and Social Sciences
National University of Colombia
Colombia
Master's Degree in Social Medicine/Doctorate in Public Health Sciences
Division of Biological and Health Sciences
Autonomous Metropolitan University Xochimilco
Mexico
Master's Degree in Social Medicine/Doctorate in Public Health Sciences
Division of Biological and Health Sciences
Autonomous Metropolitan University Xochimilco
Mexico
Institute of Political Studies and International Relations
National University of Colombia
Colombia
Higher School of Health Sciences
Brazil
Master's Degree in Social Medicine/Doctorate in Public Health Sciences
Division of Biological and Health Sciences
Autonomous Metropolitan University Xochimilco
Mexico
university of Carabobo
Venezuela
ALAMES Collective Margarita Posada
El Salvador
Alejandro Lipschutz Institute of Sciences
Non-Governmental Development Organization
Chile
Center for Studies and Research in Humanities
Faculty of Philosophy and Human Sciences
federal university of Bahia
Brazil
Master's Degree in Social Medicine/Doctorate in Public Health Sciences
Division of Biological and Health Sciences
Autonomous Metropolitan University Xochimilco
Mexico
Postgraduate Studies Program in Social Policy - Universidade Federal Fluminense
Postgraduate Studies Program in Social Policy
Federal Fluminense University
Brazil
Alejandro Lipschutz Institute of Sciences
Non-Governmental Development Organization
Chile
University of Valparaíso
Chile
Department of Social Sciences
National University of Avellaneda
Argentina
JAINA Study Community
Bolivia
Center for Women's Studies
Central University of Venezuela
Venezuela
Department of Social Sciences
National University of Avellaneda
Argentina
Oswaldo Cruz Foundation
Brazil
Universidad Austral de Chile
Chile