Thematic Field: Epistemologies of the South and Decolonial
WorkgroupLatin American and Caribbean critical geographical thought
[+ View productions and content]Faculty of Social Work
Faculty of Social Work
National University of La Plata
Argentina
Center for Social Research, Puerto Rico
Faculty of Social Sciences
University of Puerto Rico
Puerto Rico
Center for Studies and Promotion of Development
Peru
Latin American and Caribbean critical geographical thought is a field of knowledge and practice that intertwines multiple perspectives of critical thinking with a powerful interest in advocating for the transformation of socio-territorial realities across diverse latitudes. It represents a commitment to change and emancipation, aiming to disrupt and end the social and spatial inequalities and injustices in which we find ourselves immersed. As Carlos Walter Porto (2015) argues, it is necessary to map the territory, the space—that is, to geo-graph the land, as social movements of re-existence do—in the sense of approaching the feeling-thinking of territory/territoriality/territorialization. Furthermore, we must be clear that no "reflection" or "thought" is neutral, since everything has an object and content, and is simultaneously a choice of will (Lefebvre, 1986:35).
The origins of geography in Latin America and the Caribbean, as a modern discipline, were linked to the independence processes of our countries. The need to create a detailed inventory and registry of natural resources, towns, and populations led to its development at the beginning of the internal colonialism processes in the nascent republics. Within this context, geographical societies began to emerge in Latin American countries, serving as counterparts to the geographical societies of the 19th-century European empires.
The process of institutionalizing the discipline in academia was linked to this process and also to the teaching of geography in schools and universities. Official atlases and maps emerged in response to the needs of nation-states, and the military in particular; they were key devices and instruments for creating the geographical imaginaries of the new nations based on the physical and cultural geography of each country (Delgado, 2019), with a strategy of knowledge colonization imposed on local knowledge and wisdom.
Alongside this process, representations of geographic spaces were created and imposed from a Eurocentric, colonial, modern, and patriarchal perspective. This approach has not only been deployed through official maps but has also been disseminated at various points in history from different centers of education and knowledge production, even today. This has occurred at both the school and university levels, thus rendering invisible the diverse knowledge and wisdom of the peoples of Latin America and the Caribbean, as well as those of various Global Souths, silencing and concealing other forms of knowledge and diverse ways of life.
According to Fals Borda (2009), we can say that, for those in power, traditional forms of spatial representation are a strategic tool and knowledge for maintaining the political, cultural, and economic status quo of the modern-colonial-patriarchal capitalist system. They require the adherence to certain rules, norms, methods, and techniques that conform to a single type of rationality.
For Latin American and Caribbean geographers, critical geography cannot be understood without citing Brazilian geography and its theoretical and practical (political) references, which championed a movement to renew the hegemonic and conservative thought of that country, moving from "resistance to the offensive," as Moraes (2008) aptly states. This necessarily implies a critical review of the analytical and methodological categories from which we engage with diverse forms of knowledge when addressing socio-spatial conflicts and manifestations. This critical perspective on geography is open to social theories, linking and articulating knowledge of territories to the social production of spaces.
Critical geography is not separate from the social processes we experience in most of our countries. The rise of political groups and parties in government belonging to the most reactionary and oppressive right wings has deepened neoliberal and extractive strategies and policies, threatening the social gains achieved in recent decades. However, there are glimmers of hope in some countries, and after a conservative cycle in our continent, one could say that a new progressive cycle is emerging, especially in order to avoid repeating past mistakes and implement the social justice our people need.
Given the current global and local context of crisis in the political, economic, cultural, environmental, social, and scientific spheres (marked by severe cuts in public education budgets and funding for science and technology), practices that constantly violate human rights and intensify strategies of plunder and dispossession against communities, coupled with the expansion of practices of socioeconomic exclusion and marginalization affecting broad sectors of society, it is essential to strengthen critical research and action groups and networks whose aim is to challenge these social realities. In this way, the spatial logic of neoliberal capitalism and its underlying patriarchal and colonial patterns will be understood, enabling a collective and collaborative production of knowledge in conjunction with diverse social groups and movements, while also influencing the political sphere.
It is therefore important to advocate for the strengthening of critical geographical thinking in various fields, from which the dialogue of knowledge and the listening to other voices can be made possible, those that emerge from the re-existence and becoming of the processes of resistance, struggle and social movements in defense of territories and life.
Our proposal also refers to the articulation with Souths from diverse latitudes from which we can create ties of collaboration and solidarity not only in our continent but also in Africa and Asia, generating internationalist relations from academia and social movements.
Based on the collective work and experience we have gained as a Working Group in the two previous calls (2016-2019 and 2019-2022), and after a critical review of our practices, recovering the work themes of those who are part of it and the links we have with various groups and social movements in different places, we propose the following lines of work for the next three years, which will be guided in order to achieve concrete results and organize ourselves as a group with a large number of participants:
To address its nature and given the diversity of research interests of the people in the Group, the following subgroups or axes are formed:
1. Latin American and Caribbean Geopolitics. Migrations and Infrastructures of Dispossession.
2. Agrarian conflicts, struggles, and social movements linked to rural and peasant-indigenous areas. Scenarios of climate change, socio-environmental problems, and approaches to risk.
3. Social cartography and other methodologies, Geographic bases, GIS and participatory geotechnologies
4. Disciplinary training, Critical geographical thinking
5. Urban problems and urban social movements
Depending on the number of members and new requirements, it may be possible to propose the creation of new thematic areas and/or the elimination or merger of existing ones.
The creation of project committees may be proposed for the development of specific projects, with the duration of each project committee being compatible with the needs of the project in question.
Fals Borda, O. (2009) A Sentient Sociology for Latin America. Siglo del Hombre Editores and CLACSO. http://bibliotecavirtual.clacso.org.ar/ar/libros/coedicion/fborda/fborda.pdf
Federico Ferretti, Philippe Pelletier (2013). On the origins of critical geography. Spatialities and relations of domination in the work of the anarchist geographers Reclus, Kropotkin and Mechnikov. Germinal Journal of Libertarian Studies, pp. 57-72. < https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00954956 >
Lefebvre, H. (1986), Formal logic, dialectical logic, Editorial Siglo XXI, Mexico.
Moreira, Ruy (2010). What is Geography - new version rewritten and updated. 2nd ed. São Paulo: Brasiliense, v. 1. 94p.
Porto-Gonçalves, CW, Aichino, GL, Correa, A., Martínez, JJH, Palladino, L., Pedrazzani, CE, & Ensabella, B. (2015). GEO-GRAPHICS WITH CARLOS WALTER PORTO-GONÇALVES / Pp.241–263. Cardinalis, (4). Recovered from https://revistas.unc.edu.ar/index.php/cardi/article/view/11809
Santos, B. de Sousa (2016) Inaugural lecture “The Epistemologies of the South: Political and Epistemic Challenges”. Within the framework of the international course “Situated Thought and Struggles. Towards a Cartography of the South”. South-South University, CLACSO and CES. October 11, 2016. CLACSO Network of Postgraduate Programs in Social Sciences.
Critical geographical thought in Latin America and the Caribbean presents various challenges, one of which is the production of knowledge. This field interweaves multiple perspectives with a strong interest in advocating for the transformation of socio-territorial realities in diverse latitudes and interconnected contexts.
It is relevant to the socio-territorial transformation processes that societies/groups experience. The struggle for property, housing, the production of differentiated spaces, or the displacement of populations to different regions of the world, among other things, are processes rooted in disputes over power and territories. Neoliberal policies are intensifying in most Latin American countries, affecting different groups/communities, which are repressed, displaced, and marginalized from their territories of origin and belonging.
Indigenous and peasant communities face dispossession as a result of extractive projects, infrastructure development, and the expansion of monocultures. They stand against the commodification of land, and states deny them the value of their land and territory.
The reproduction of capital increases its accumulation circuits, disrupting the expanded reproduction of life, where economic and life forms are linked to nature.
In Latin American urban spaces, spatial inequalities are increasing due to various processes of accumulation by dispossession. This generates multiple forms of violence and tension. New peri-urban spaces emerge that contrast with the ways of life of the communities, and urban elites occupy these spaces as second homes or for new forms of environmental development.
Popular education movements, which emerged and consolidated in Latin America, seek to discuss practices and experiences that are rendered invisible and denied in formal education. The history and geography content in formal education tends to transmit a positivist view of space as a static container, unchanging in time and with little connection to human beings. Lacoste (1976) argues that the true value of geographic space remains hidden, except among elites who have constructed a "smokescreen" that obscures the importance of spatial knowledge, thus keeping it in the hands of a few and creating a monopoly on it.
Critical geographies posit space as a social construct, enabling the recognition of difference. While they have contributed to the understanding of differentiated social space, the position of male power is not entirely challenged. Dialogue with feminist geography from other regions has broadened the horizons of geographical debates, contributing from situated knowledge. Microsocial and qualitative perspectives are articulated in the analysis of space, highlighting intersectionality and the subaltern voices of women, lesbians, gays, transgender people, queer people, and others traditionally excluded from spatial analysis (Zubia & López, 2015).
It is essential to emancipate pluriculturalism and biodiversity in Latin America as factors for the protection, respect, and safeguarding of its peoples, aiming for authentic and local education rooted in local knowledge and geographies that contribute to Latin American reality, reclaiming traditional knowledge and territories. We need to rethink the relationship between humanity and the environment, using multidimensional and multi-scalar approaches.
Geographers linked to different areas of knowledge contribute from their practical experience. They question, demand, and propose diverse ways of understanding territorial contexts and their actors, a plurality of voices that combine to confront and transform socio-territorial contexts.
Accordingly, the GT is interested in the training and practice of critical Latin American geographical thought, accompanying socio-spatial processes and transformations that have occurred and are occurring in Latin America and the contributions that can be made from Geography, highlighting new forms of spatial representation and questioning the hegemonic forms of official representation.
The Geopolitical Emergence of Domination
Eurocentrism imported slavery, feudalism, and colonialism, but also emancipatory ideas that combat this domination; these ideas were inspired by modern European humanism, which fermented in the independence movements and decolonial processes known up to that point in Latin America. The evils of Imperial Colonial Europe also created antidotes to its barbarism (Morin, 2007), which must be brought into dialogue.
In the 21st century, Latin America and the Caribbean have undergone significant transformations in the structures and orientations of their political landscapes. This period has been characterized by the establishment of governments with a relatively distinct left-leaning tendency; however, right-wing governments with authoritarian practices persist within their states.
Supranational blocs have been formed with a new geopolitical projection that goes beyond the economic and commercial dimension, and encompasses a growing negotiation of areas of political power between the center and the periphery of the world-system, in the face of the still persistent expressions of geoeconomic and social fragmentation (Preciado and Uc, 2010).
Latin American Critical Geographical Thought has sparked interest among Latin American geographers connected to geographical problems from a critical perspective. This highlights the need for spaces for reflection and collective construction of geographical practice in relation to this line of thought.
Considering the Global South as a source of knowledge that allows for an epistemological disruption, a revolution in theory (Santos, 2016), with a strong critique—both internal and external—of the epistemological, ontological, and methodological model of Western modernity, we appeal to cognitive justice and to promoting, within the disciplinary field, other ways of knowing and producing knowledge in a profound dialogue with other academic and extra-academic fields of knowledge, as well as with territorial knowledge.
As part of our practice, we propose a process of articulation and cooperative and collaborative work with the CLACSO Working Groups. We also aim to strengthen research, training, and exchange networks with the Latin American Network of Geographers of Roots (GeoRaizAL) and PANGEA (Colombia), the GeoComunes Collective and Community Geographies (Mexico), the Puerto Rican Geography Collective, the Bolivian Critical Geography Working Group, and other networks, collectives, and groups active in Latin American geographic work.
Our commitment to social change through the design of public policies at global and regional levels involves initiating, maintaining, and strengthening relationships with academic, political, and geoeconomic organizations, such as the UN regional system in Latin America (ECLAC, UNU, UNEP, UNDP, UNESCO, and others). This includes the 2018 merger of the International Council for Science (ICSU) and the International Social Science Council (ISSC), which created the International Council for Science (ISC). We must also mention our relationship with FLACSO (Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences) and the OAS (Organization of American States), specifically with its research arm in geography, history, anthropology, and cartography, the Pan American Institute of Geography and History (PAIGH).
Finally, we will coordinate with international organizations that bring together various professional interest groups such as the International Sociological Association - ISA, the International Geographical Union - IGU and the International Political Science Association - IPSA, among others.
In the words of Yves Lacoste (1976), geography is a weapon of war; therefore, it is necessary to rethink in each project and action how it is used and
Marin Vargas, GM (2014) The State-Centric Model and Double Co-optation: A Look at the Trajectory of the State. Political Searches, 3. Retrieved from https://www.academia.edu/7674897/El_modelo_Estado-c%C3%A9ntrico_y_la_doble_cooptaci%C3%B3n_Una_mirada_a_la_trayectoria_del_Estado
Morin, E. (2005) A Brief History of Barbarism in the West. Paidós Publishing House.
Preciado Coronado, J., & Uc, P. (2010) The construction of a critical geopolitics from Latin America and the Caribbean. Towards a regional research agenda. Geopolitics (s), 1(1), 65-94.
Zubia, F. & López, A. (2015) Feminist geographies: itineraries and debates on reflections about the cultural study of spatialities.
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
2. Participation of GT members in the Editorial Committee of the ESPIRAL journal and in the processes of arbitration of contributions in the various sections of the journal.
3. Publication of a collective book by the members of the Working Group, within the CLACSO Working Group Notebooks Collection.
2. A Dossier and Collective Thematic Publication in new issues of the ESPIRAL magazine. Example: Geographies of Indigenous Peoples.
3. Participation of 03 members of the CLACSO GT in the Editorial Committee of the ESPIRAL magazine.
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
2. Strengthen the articulation with the GTs with which activities were carried out at the CLACSO 2022 Mexico Conference, and collaborate with the dissemination of knowledge on the topics they address.
3. Maintain dissemination on social networks (Facebook, Instagram and Twitter among others).
4. Being Co-Organizer of EGAL 2023 Dominican Republic.
1.1 Invitation to the CLACSO GTs with a contribution (article or other section) in the various upcoming dossiers of the Bulletin and ESPIRAL magazine.
2. Propose a thematic table, panel or session on the geographies of indigenous peoples in regional events of Social Sciences and Geography.
3. Update our online presence, including social media, websites, and other forms of online or offline visibility.
4. CLACSO sponsorship of the XIX EGALC 2023 Dominican Republic (Meeting of Geographies of Latin America and the Caribbean)
2. Academic articulation and dissemination of knowledge that emerge from the work of the CLACSO GT's.
3. To achieve a wide dissemination in virtual media, both of materials and content prepared by members of the GT as well as various publications that we consider linked to Latin American and Caribbean critical geographical thought.
4. Organize a panel, event or activity about indigenous peoples at EGAL 2023 Dominican Republic.
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
2. To articulate actions/relationships between academia and social movements from a theoretical, epistemic and emancipatory practical perspective.
3. Participate in public funding competitions in science, technology and innovation organizations.
2. Establish action networks with social movements in shared research processes. Establish agreements with social organizations and civil society to have a presence and influence the public debate in a selected country.
3. Registration of our members in the various science, technology and innovation agencies of Latin America and the Caribbean.
2. Promote agreements with national or subnational governments to generate knowledge and expertise that impacts public management.
3. Implementation of action networks in operation and in shared research processes in knowledge management from science, technology and innovation agencies.
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
2. Strengthen the articulation and joint work with the Latin American Root Geographers Network (GeoRaizAL) and PANGEA (Colombia), the GeoComunes Collective and Community Geographies (Mexico), the Puerto Rican Geography Collective, GT Bolivian Critical Geography, and other networks, collectives and groups that are active within the Latin American geographical endeavor.
3. Propose the UNESCO Chair with a theme selected and prioritized by our CLACSO Working Group.
2. Conduct coordination meetings and joint projects with the international institutions AUIP, UGI, ISA, IPGH and ALAS, linking them with our groups, collectives and social movements allied to our CLACSO Working Group.
3. Draft the document to be proposed for the UNESCO Chair in a selected country.
2. Propose events and research projects for competition for academic funds and sponsorships according to the schedules and requirements of the conveners.
3. To highlight the importance of having a UNESCO Chair from our CLACSO Working Group.
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
4. Promote the development of publications on the general axis Critical Geographical Thinking: territories, resistances and emerging issues, based on the panels held within the framework of the 8th and 9th CLACSO Conferences (2018 and 2022) and others.
5. Create (virtual) spaces for critical reflection on knowledge production among members of the Working Group on Latin American critical geographical thought.
4. Prepare thematic articles by Panel participants and members of the Working Group who participate in Conferences and Forums.
5. Conduct virtual forums and debates in which the results of ongoing research and projects related to the proposed work areas of our CLACSO Working Group are shared.
4. Prepare thematic articles by Panel participants and members of the Working Group who participate in Conferences and Forums.
5. Continue with our event platform created in 2021 and continued in 2022, the "Latin American and Caribbean Perspectives" Seminar.
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
4. Propose joint Tables/Panels with various academic allies (universities, collectives and social movements) in various academic events, LASA, SINGA, ALASRU and ALAS, in addition to joint meetings in those instances or others that may arise.
5. To sponsor the First Latin American and Caribbean Congress of Geographies organized by the Latin American and Caribbean Studies Commission of the IGU.
4. Collaboratively build proposals in accordance with the themes and axes of the events selected this year.
5. To convene, manage and develop a thematic table on Original Geographies at the First Latin American and Caribbean Congress of Geographies 2024.
4. Systematization and dissemination of our collective participations in the current year.
5. Strengthen our focus on studies of indigenous peoples.
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
4. Promote dialogue with those actors (governments, NGOs, academia, others) who are linked to actions of transformation and construction of social impact projects.
4. To build spaces for influence and dissemination of information that allow for interrelationships with decision-makers at different scales of social innovation in a critical way and with the use of geotechnologies.
4. Build at least one space for critical training aimed at social organizations: Social Innovation Laboratory from the Peoples.
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
4. To sponsor the creation of the Doctorate in Geography and Environmental Sustainability at the Universidad Mayor de San Andrés in Bolivia.
4. Propose professors who are members of our CLACSO Working Group to strengthen the academic offering of the UMSA Doctorate.
4. To propose a virtual training model from our CLACSO Working Group to the academic community and civil society, especially social movements that need tools from geography to achieve their territorial objectives.
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
7. To collaborate in integrating Latin American and Caribbean critical geographical thinking perspectives into the content of various curricula as part of the object of study of Geography as a discipline.
8. Coordinate the thematic issue on Indigenous Geography in the journal Rupturas, of CICDE-UNED (Costa Rica).
7. Develop content and materials in various formats (texts, infographics, teaching materials, among others) on perspectives and themes related to critical geographical thinking.
7.1 Actively participate in advising, working and creating various spaces and/or careers linked to the perspective.
8. To convene, manage, edit and publish the thematic issue on Original Geographies in the journal Rupturas (CICDE-UNED, Costa Rica).
6.1 Create a repository of undergraduate and postgraduate course programs that are taught.
6.2 Create a network/platform of Latin American critical geographical thinking professors.
7. New seminars, undergraduate and postgraduate training courses linked to the perspective.
7.1 New careers and/or contributions to the review of study plans for undergraduate, graduate and postgraduate careers.
8. Thematic issue published in the indexed journal Rupturas.
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
6. Participate in, sponsor, and support academic events such as EGAL 2025 (Meeting of Geographies of Latin America) and/or national geography events for both professionals and students
6. Contact and exchange with event organizers.
6. Academic sponsorships and co-organization of national and international events
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
6. Promote synergies between the results of the GT's research and projects that improve the advice and links that GT members provide to social organizations.
6. Promote meetings with research centers to create academic working networks in countries prioritized by the CLACSO Working Group.
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
4.1 Preparation of concrete materials in various formats to share in the media offered by CLACSO and in other media and social networks.
Total number of researchers admitted: 56
Collective for Social Studies and Research
Argentina
Faculty of Human Sciences
National University of the Center of the Province of Buenos Aires
Argentina
Miranda International Center Foundation
Venezuela
Faculty of Geological Sciences - UMSA
Bolivia
Department of Social Sciences
Faculty of Humanities
National Pedagogical University
Colombia
Meritorious Autonomous University of Puebla (BUAP)
Mexico
Center for Research and Studies in Fine Arts (CIEBA) and Cross Line of Public Art (LTAP) of CIEBA.
Portugal
NATIONAL UNIVERSITY OF COLOMBIA
Colombia
Department of Political Science
Faculty of Law, Political Science and Social Sciences
National University of Colombia
Colombia
Center for Social Research, Puerto Rico
Faculty of Social Sciences
University of Puerto Rico
Puerto Rico
Postgraduate studies in Development Sciences
University of San Andres
Bolivia
Division of Social Sciences and Humanities
Metropolitan Autonomous University - Xochimilco Unit
Mexico
University of San Andres
Bolivia
Center for Studies and Promotion of Development
Peru
Faculty of Political Sciences and Sociology
-Complutense University of Madrid
Spain
Faculty of Social Work
Faculty of Social Work
National University of La Plata
Argentina
Postgraduate Program in Geography
Institute of Sciences, Campus da Praia Vermelha, Department of Geography
Federal Fluminense University
Brazil
State University of Pará
Brazil
Colombia
Peruvian Center for Social Studies
Peru
Center for Social Research, Puerto Rico
Faculty of Social Sciences
University of Puerto Rico
Puerto Rico
Post-Graduation Program in Society, Culture and Frontiers
Universidade Estadual do Oeste do Paraná-UNIOESTE-Foz do Iguaçu campus- Paraná-BRAZIL
Brazil
Universidad Nacional Mayor de San Marcos
Peru
Center for Studies and Promotion of Development
Peru
Division of Social Sciences and Humanities
Metropolitan Autonomous University - Azcapotzalco Unit
Mexico
University of Jena
Germany,
Operational Center for Housing and Settlement AC
Mexico
Center for Social Research, Puerto Rico
Faculty of Social Sciences
University of Puerto Rico
Puerto Rico
Department of Geography Graduate Program in Geography Universidade Federal de Pernambuco
Brazil
Center for Social Research, Puerto Rico
Faculty of Social Sciences
University of Puerto Rico
Puerto Rico
Institute for Professional Development and Higher Studies Prof. Juan E. Pivel Devoto
Uruguay
Postgraduate College.
Mexico
Permanent Seminar on Chicano and Border Studies, Directorate of Ethnology and Social Anthropology, National Institute of Anthropology and History
Mexico
ALTERNATIVE Center for Social Research and Popular Education
Peru
Edward J. Bloustein School of Planning and Public Policy
United States
ALTERNATIVE Center for Social Research and Popular Education
Peru
Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences, Argentina
Argentina Program
Argentina
Institute of Geographical Research IIGEO - UMSA
Bolivia
Department of Political Science
Faculty of Law, Political Science and Social Sciences
National University of Colombia
Colombia
International Geographical Union - Peru
Peru
University of Nariño
Colombia
Externado University
Colombia
Center for Social Research, Puerto Rico
Faculty of Social Sciences
University of Puerto Rico
Puerto Rico
University Institute for Development and Cooperation / Complutense University of Madrid
Complutense University of Madrid
Spain
Center for Social Research, Puerto Rico
Faculty of Social Sciences
University of Puerto Rico
Puerto Rico
CEPIES UMSA
Bolivia
Faculty of Political Sciences and Sociology
-Complutense University of Madrid
Spain
University of San Andres
Bolivia
Pedagogical and Technological University of Colombia
Colombia
Tierra Libre
Colombia
Center for Research in Culture and Development
Research Vice Presidency
State Distance University
Costa Rica
Faculty of Humanities and Arts - University of Tolima
Colombia
Division of Social Sciences and Humanities
Metropolitan Autonomous University - Xochimilco Unit
Mexico
School of Political Science
Faculty of Social Sciences
Costa Rica university
Costa Rica
National University of Asuncion
Paraguay
Universidad Nacional Mayor de San Marcos
Peru