Thematic Field: Environment, climate change and social development

WorkgroupEnergy and sustainable development

[+ View productions and content]
1. Name of the Working Group.
Energy and sustainable development
Coordinator(s) of the Working Group
Esteban Serrani
Interdisciplinary School of Advanced Social Studies
National University of San Martín (UNSAM)
Argentina
Nora Estela Fernandez Mora
Latin American Center for Research in Social Sciences and Humanities
Faculty of Human Sciences
Pontifical Catholic University of Ecuador
Ecuador

2. Critical location of the topic in the Latin American and Caribbean context and in relation to global dynamics.

The global energy landscape is unfolding on two fronts with distinct timelines and overlapping agendas: on the one hand, climate change, which prioritizes a long-term decarbonization agenda; and on the other hand, the post-pandemic energy crisis, exacerbated by the armed conflict in Eastern Europe, which shapes short-term energy security and access agendas. In all likelihood, the new configuration of the energy regime at both regional and national levels will result from the effective or ineffective interplay of these agendas in the medium term.

The global climate crisis is putting existing production and consumption systems under strain, including the fossil fuel energy regime deployed since the 19th century. In its sixth report, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) dispels any doubt regarding the origin of this crisis: the observed increases in greenhouse gas (GHG) concentrations since around 1750 are unequivocally caused by human activities (IPCC, 2021), a period that coincides with the beginning of the Industrial Revolution. In this sense, the consequences of climate change range from impacts on natural ecosystems, such as glacial retreat, rising sea levels, and an increase in extreme weather events (droughts and floods), to socioeconomic impacts on food security, water quality, fisheries, infrastructure, and more. Paradoxically, Latin America has a low historical incidence of GHG accumulation in the atmosphere, as does the entire Global South (Hickel, 2020), while at the same time being particularly vulnerable to such impacts due to its geographical, climatic, socioeconomic and demographic characteristics (Bárcena et al, 2020).

According to the IPCC (2018), global warming is likely to reach 1,5°C above pre-industrial levels between 2030 and 2050 if it continues at the current rate. To avoid exceeding this increase, rapid and far-reaching transitions in energy, land, urban, and infrastructure systems would be necessary. Net global anthropogenic CO2 emissions would need to decrease by approximately 45% by 2030 compared to 2010 levels and reach zero around 2050.

In the economic structure, the energy sector accounts for the largest share of global emissions, at 76% of the total, according to data from the Climate Watch platform. Therefore, reducing emissions from the energy sector plays a central role in international climate commitments. The Paris Agreement was adopted in 2015 with the aim of reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions in order to limit the increase in average global temperature to well below 2 degrees Celsius and as close as possible to 1,5 degrees Celsius, thus avoiding the most severe impacts of climate change, such as increased droughts, floods, and severe storms. Given the impossibility of reaching a consensus on a single universal formula for emissions mitigation, it was agreed that each country would decide its own targets for the period 2020-2030 and submit its Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs), including the mitigation measures to be implemented in the energy sector. Likewise, the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development (2030 Agenda), adopted by the United Nations in 2015, promotes Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), including one specifically focused on energy (SDG 7), which aims to ensure access to affordable, reliable, sustainable, and modern energy. Its targets are universal access to modern energy services, doubling the rate of improvement in energy efficiency, and substantially increasing the share of renewable energy in the global energy mix by 2030.

In addition to the climate crisis, the post-pandemic and international war fronts have emerged. As a result of the Covid-19 crisis, global energy-related CO2 emissions had decreased by 5,2% in 2020, nearly 2 Gt, the largest decrease since World War II, due to reduced oil use for land and air transport. However, following the worst effects of the pandemic, the world experienced an extremely rapid economic recovery, driven by unprecedented fiscal and monetary stimulus and a swift, albeit uneven, rollout of vaccines. The recovery in energy demand in 2021 was hampered by adverse weather and energy market conditions, leading to increased coal burning despite renewable energy generation recording its highest annual growth ever. Emissions increased by 6% compared to 2020, at almost 2,1 Gt, making 2021 the year with the largest year-on-year increase in energy-related CO2 emissions in absolute terms (IEA, 2021).

As a consequence of the supply crisis, a new scenario of high energy prices has emerged since the end of 2021, threatening other value chains such as food production and strategic inputs, for example, steel, aluminum, and fertilizers. In this context, a global recession is looming in the immediate future. At the same time, higher energy costs are having a significant impact on the economies of Latin American countries that import natural gas and fossil fuels. On the other hand, oil and natural gas exporting countries are benefiting from increased revenues that are helping to alleviate the dire social situation left by the pandemic.

In this context, there is a shift in priority from decarbonization on the energy agenda to energy security, as the market reports energy scarcity and high prices. At the same time, Europe's response to the outcome of COP26, held in Glasgow in November 2021, within the broader context of the energy crisis (preceding the war between Russia and Ukraine), was the European Union's approval of an addendum to the Green Finance Taxonomy. This addendum considers both natural gas and nuclear energy as transitional energy sources for the green economy, which will complement other renewable sources in shaping the global energy mix in the medium term.

Current global transformations also present internal challenges and new export markets for Latin American countries. Throughout the region, state-controlled oil and electricity companies are almost entirely diversifying their portfolios toward renewable energy. There is also a presence of technology-based companies and scientific organizations focused on clean energy innovation. As developed countries decarbonize, they increasingly demand critical minerals and new non-fossil fuels (NFFs), a situation that presents a significant paradox. Within the framework of the global energy transition, the region faces a choice: either be a mere supplier of mineral products and bear the environmental impacts of more intensive exploitation, or become involved in the value chains of energy storage systems such as lithium-ion batteries and in vectors such as blue hydrogen (obtained from natural gas and carbon capture and storage) and green hydrogen (obtained from renewable energy sources such as wind and solar).

Bravo, D. (2015). Energy and sustainable development in Cuba. Centro Azúcar Magazine. Vol. 42, October-December, 2015. Editor: Yailet Albernas Carvajal. ISSN: 2223-4861.
Calvo, R. et al. (2021) Development of energy poverty indicators in Latin America and the Caribbean. Santiago, Chile: Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC). Natural Resources and Development Series, No. 207.
Cortés, M; Brigith, J. (2021) Proposal to formalize and calculate energy poverty in Colombia
Geocommons. (2021). Illuminating the contradictions of the Mexican Electricity System and the energy transition: Key questions to understand them and build other energy models. Rosa Luxemburg Foundation Mexico, Central America and the Caribbean Office.
Giannini Pereira, M., Vasconcelos Freitas, MA, & da Silva, NF (2011). The challenge of energy poverty: Brazilian case study. Energy Policy, 39(1), 167–175.
González-Eguino, M. (2015). Energy poverty: An overview. In Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews (Vol. 47, pp. 377–385).
Guerrero, A. (2021) Geopolitics of the Global Energy Transformation and Territorial Dynamics of the Energy Transition in South America. In Ambiente & Sociedade São Paulo. Special Dossier: Energy Territories, Vol. 24, 2021. p. 1-21, 2021.
Hickel, J. (2020). Quantifying national responsibility for climate breakdown: an equality-based attribution approach for carbon dioxide emissions in excess of the planetary boundary. Lancet Planet Health, 4, pp. 399–404.
International Energy Agency (IEA) (2022). Global Energy Review: CO2 Emissions in 2021. https://www.iea.org/reports/global-energy-review-co2-emissions-in-2021-2?utm_content=buffer1d873&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter.com&utm_campaign=buffer
IPCC (2018). Global Warming of 1,5°C. IPCC Special Report. Summary for Policymakers. https://www.ipcc.ch/site/assets/uploads/sites/2/2019/09/IPCC-Special-Report-1.5-SPM_es.pdf
IPCC (2021). Summary for Policymakers. In: Climate Change 2021: The Physical Science Basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.
Lampis, A. (2009). What about Social Vulnerability in Colombia? Connecting “freedom from” and “freedom to.” Society and Economy Magazine, 19, 229–261.
Leite, A. (2007). Energy in Brazil. Rio de Janeiro: Elsevier, 2nd edition.
Losekann, L, Hallack, M, (2018). New energies are renewed in Brazil: challenges and opportunities. In: Negri, JAD et al. (orgs.), Desafios da Nação: artigos de apoio, vol. 2. Brasília: Institute of Applied Economic Research (IPEA).
Pérez Roig, D. (2021a). State hydrocarbon policy and accumulation mode during post-convertibility Argentina (2002-2011). Economia e Sociedade, 30(2), 519–550.
Sabbatella I, Santos T (2019) The IPE of Regional Energy Integration in South America. In: Vivares E (ed) Routledge Handbook to Global Political Economy. Routledge, London and New York, p 719-740.
Sauer, IL (2016) The pre-salt geopolitics and hegemony of oil face climate change and energy transition. In: Adolpho JM ; Aroldo M., Almeida Campos, D; Cordani.UG (Org.). Mineral Resources in Brazil. Rio de Janeiro: Brazilian Academy of Sciences, p. 316-330.
Sen, A. (1976). Poverty: An Ordinal Approach to Measurement. Econometrica, 44(2), 219–231.
Van de Graaf, T.; Sovacool, B.; Ghosh, A.; Kern, F.; Klare, M.. (2016). “States, markets, and institutions: Integrating international political economy and global energy politics.” In T. Van de Graaf, B. Sovacool, A. Ghohs, F. Kern, & MT Klare (Eds.). The Palgrave handbook of the international political economy of energy. Palgrave Handbooks.
3. Justification and analysis of the theoretical relevance of the topic in relation to the analyzed context.

Latin America and the Caribbean (LAC) is one of the most unequal regions in the world, where 20% of the population holds 83% of the wealth and with an informality rate of 53%, according to ECLAC data. Furthermore, the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated income inequality and increased job insecurity.

Despite its historically low emissions contribution and current figure of only 8% of total emissions, the region is particularly vulnerable to the impact of climate change due to its geographic, climatic, socioeconomic, and demographic characteristics. One example is the high sensitivity of its natural assets, such as forests and biodiversity, to climate change. It is estimated that by 2050, the economic cost of climate change in the region will represent between 1,5% and 5% of the current regional GDP, due to the sum of agricultural and hydroelectric generation losses, disease vectors, and extreme weather events, among other factors (Bárcena et al., 2020). Given the increased frequency of extreme weather events and the inertial trajectory of greenhouse gas emissions, implementing adaptation processes to reduce the expected damage is unavoidable (Bárcena et al., 2020).

Furthermore, Latin America and the Caribbean (LAC) boasts a cleaner energy mix than the global average due to the contribution of hydroelectric power and lower coal consumption. The region is also not immune to the energy transition process. However, unlike other energy transitions that arose as a consequence of the emergence of new technologies and/or resource discoveries, the current one is a purposeful transition based on the need to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions (Kern & Markard, 2016). Therefore, the current transition is toward low-carbon economies (non-conventional renewable energies, hydroelectric, and nuclear), although it should also be noted that natural gas is gaining relevance as a less polluting option among fossil fuels, since it produces approximately half the CO2 emissions of coal, complementing renewable energies given the variability and instability of wind and solar power generation. As a corollary to this decarbonization process, a global scenario of new geopolitical disputes has been configured (IRENA, 2019a) and the transition towards a new technological paradigm that can open national development strategies by promoting new industries, supply chains and "green" jobs (IRENA, 2019b).

Regarding access to energy, Latin America and the Caribbean (LAC) faces challenges, even though its situation is positive compared to other regions. The electricity access rate is 97,8% (among the highest in the world), but 18,5 million people still lack access. While 87% have access to clean and efficient cooking technologies, 84 million people remain without access, with the resulting health consequences, especially for women (Rivera Albarracín, 2021).

The energy transition, based on sustainable renewable energy and energy efficiency, should be a means to increase access for these populations. The concept of a just transition can mediate between the region's development aspirations and the need to mitigate climate change. However, this requires a discussion based on principles of equity regarding how to implement it in terms of time and pace, without leaving behind the populations and developing countries most dependent on income from the production and export of fossil fuels (Rivera Albarracín, 2021).

During the previous period, the Working Group aimed to study the energy policies adopted in the region, their effects on current development patterns, and their main obstacles. Through six published thematic bulletins and numerous activities, the Group addressed historical issues such as security of supply and access to energy; rent-seeking by producing countries and the trade burden on importing countries; the socio-environmental impacts of energy production and consumption; the role of state-owned enterprises and foreign direct investment; the development of endogenous industrial capabilities; and technological dependence. Furthermore, the Group explored energy as a driving force behind numerous regional integration projects.

For the next period, the challenges, opportunities, and barriers to the energy transition in Latin America and the Caribbean (LAC) will be addressed. This entails exploring not only energy security policies but also a research agenda linked to decarbonization and a just transition (the speed and pace of clean energy integration into the energy mix) and to technological and productive development (expansion of industrial capacity, innovation, and sustainable finance). The research project "Critical Perspectives on Energy Transitions in LAC" will be developed, along with a special issue of Mexico's El Trimestre Económico entitled "Climate Crisis and Energy Transitions in LAC: Tensions and Disputes between Climate, Economy, and Society." Furthermore, bimonthly discussion sessions on the progress of the research and the special issue will continue, with the findings being compiled into thematic bulletins that the Working Group will publish twice a year, as in the previous period.

On the other hand, in recent years, Latin American and Caribbean social sciences have begun to focus on developing the concept and measurement of energy poverty, due to the growing recognition that access to energy is fundamental to human development. Although this recognition is not new, it has gained more attention within the contribution of critical development studies to the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), given that lack of access to energy has been linked to various social, environmental, and health problems. Thus, measuring energy poverty has become a central theme for the Working Group, complementing the study of energy transition policies, as it allows for its connection to other issues of fundamental current relevance, such as the democratization of access to energy and public services. In this regard, the Second International Seminar on Energy Poverty in Latin America and the Caribbean will be developed, together with the Energy Poverty Network (RedPE) and the Latin American Energy Inclusion Network (RedIEL), the international seminar on the renegotiation of the Itaipu Dams of 2023 (central aspect of public goods and access to energy), while promoting a) meeting spaces for academic exchange, b) the articulation with other CLACSO Working Groups (such as the Global Environmental Change Working Group and the Political Ecologies of the South Working Group), and c) supporting young researchers in the development of their postgraduate theses.

Finally, dialogues will be promoted with regional energy organizations such as OLADE and ECLAC; academic institutions such as CONACYT of Mexico, CONICET of Argentina, CYTED of Spain, and CASS of China; and social organizations such as Latindadd, Public Services International (PSI), Oxfam, the Latin America and the Caribbean Tax Justice Network, and the Ebert Foundation. Links to the generation of alternative energies based on local cooperative experiences, such as the one developed by Onergia Cooperativas in Mexico, will also be explored. While some of these lines of inquiry were initially addressed in the previous period, they will be expanded and deepened through the integration of national case studies, comparative studies, bilateral relations studies, and multilateral integration frameworks.

Benites-Lazaro, LL, Giatti, LL, Junior, WS, & Giarolla, A. (2020). Land-water-food nexus of biofuels: Discourse and policy debates in Brazil. Environmental Development, 33, 100491.
Bertinat, Pablo (2016) Just energy transition. Thinking about energy democratization in Analysis, Number 1, Friedrich Ebert Stiftung.
Bertoni, R. (2011). Energy and development: the energy constraint in Uruguay as a problem (1882-2000). University Editions.
Campodónico Sánchez, H. (2004). Reforms and investment in the hydrocarbon industry of Latin America. ECLAC.
Geels, Frank (2002). Understanding the dynamics of technological transitions: a co-evolutionary and socio-technical analysis (p. 426). Enschede: Twente University Press.
Working Group on Energy and Sustainable Development (2020). Energy Transitions in Latin America. Buenos Aires: CLACSO.
Gudynas, Eduardo (2011) Development and environmental sustainability: diversity of positions, persistent tensions. In Matarán Ruíz, Alberto and López Castellano, Fernando (de.) The Earth is not silent: dialogues between sustainable development and post-development. Granada: University of Granada.
Hickel, J. (2020). Quantifying national responsibility for climate breakdown: an equality-based attribution approach for carbon dioxide emissions in excess of the planetary boundary. Lancet Planet Health, 4, pp. 399–404.
IPCC (2018). Global Warming of 1,5°C. IPCC Special Report. Summary for Policymakers. https://www.ipcc.ch/site/assets/uploads/sites/2/2019/09/IPCC-Special-Report-1.5-SPM_es.pdf
IPCC (2021). Summary for Policymakers. In: Climate Change 2021: The Physical Science Basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.
IRENA (2019a). A New World: The Geopolitics of the Energy Transformation. International Renewable Energy Agency, Abu Dhabi.
IRENA. (2019b). Renewable Energy Auctions: Status and Trends Beyond Price. IRENA.
Kern, F., & Markard, J. (2016). Analyzing Energy Transitions: Combining Insights from Transition Studies and International Political Economy. In The Palgrave Handbook of the International Political Economy of Energy (pp. 291–318). Palgrave.
Lampis, A. (2013). Vulnerability and adaptation to climate change: debates about the concept of vulnerability and its measurement. Cuadernos de Geografía: Revista Colombiana de Geografía, 22(2), 17-33.
Meyer, John (2020). The Renewable Energy Transition. New York: Springer-Verlag
Puyana, A., & Thorp, R. (1998). Colombia: Political economy of oil expectations. Flacso Mexico, TM editores, IEPRI.
Rivera Albarracín, L. (2020). Potentialities of the concept of “just transition” in the scenario of economic and social crisis in Latin America. Caravelle, 115, 105-120.
Sovacool, Benjamin (2014). What are we doing here? Analyzing fifteen years of energy scholarship and proposing a social science research agenda. Energy Research & Social Science, 1, 1-29.
Ugarteche, O., & LEÓN, CD (2022). China and the change of the energy matrix in Latin America: a global political economy approach. Brazilian Journal of Political Economy, 42, 442-459.
Van de Graaf, Thijs, Benjamin Sovacool, Arunabha Ghosh, Florian Kern, Michael Klare (eds.) (2016). The Palgrave Handbook of the International Political Economy of Energy. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Werner, D. (2012) Regional development and large hydroelectric projects (1990-2010): the case of the Madeira Complex. Inc. Soc., Brasília, DF, v. 6 no. 1, p.157-174, jul./dez. 2012
4. Three-year work plan (36 months), broken down by year.
WORK PLAN FOR THE FIRST YEAR (01/02/2023 al 31/12/2023)
OBJECTIVES
ACTIVITIES
EXPECTED OUTCOMES
KNOWLEDGE PRODUCTION
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
1. Prepare the research "Critical perspectives on energy transitions in Latin America and the Caribbean"

2. Conduct internal virtual training sessions on topics related to Energy and Sustainable Development

3. Special Issue in the Academic Journal El Trimestre Económico of Mexico. “Climate Crisis and Energy Transitions in Latin America. Tensions and Disputes between Climate, Economy and Society”

4. Promote the creation of a publication series at CLACSO on “Climate, Energy and Environment”

5. Preparation of thematic bulletins to disseminate reflections from the GT researchers.
1. Discussion of the research design. Definition of objectives, hypotheses, and methodology.

2. Conduct bimonthly videoconferences to promote the presentation of energy transition case studies based on the analysis of energy policy at the national, regional, and comparative levels.

3.1. Submission of proposal to the Journal.
3.2. Writing the articles

4. Presentation of proposal to CLACSO and greater coordination with other Working Groups

5. Preparation of two thematic bulletins per year to disseminate the thematic reflections that arise from the virtual training meetings.
1. First research progress report.

2. Systematized material as a record of the virtual meetings.

3.1. Proposal Document
3.2. Written Articles

4. Proposal presented and greater coordination with the other Working Groups

5. Presentation of 6 newsletters in 3 years.
DISSEMINATION OF KNOWLEDGE
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
1. Promote meeting spaces for work and academic exchange, and progressively increase the articulation of the work of the members of the GT.

2. Support for GT members in the completion of postgraduate theses on energy topics.

3. Development of a varied strategy of academic productions and audiovisual content to amplify the dissemination of energy topics both in academic settings and on the various social media platforms.

4. Promote the dissemination of research by members of the Working Group

5. Articulation with other CLACSO Working Groups

6. Submit a proposal for a Diploma in Climate, Energy and Sustainability at CLACSO.
1.1. International Seminar on the Renegotiation of the Itaipu Dams in 2023. Paraguay and Brazil. In conjunction with the members of the Working Group from both countries. Virtual-in-person.
1.2. Second international seminar on energy poverty in Latin America and the Caribbean, together with the Energy Poverty Network (RedPE) and the Latin American Energy Inclusion Network (RedIEL). Format to be defined.
1.3. Presentation of a proposal for a mini-conference “Dilemmas of the industrialization of energy transitions”, at the Annual Meeting of SASE (Society For The Advancement Of Socio-Economic), in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil

2. Promotion, accompaniment and support for young researchers who are interested in developing postgraduate theses on energy topics.

3.1 Development of a podcast-style audiovisual production on renewable energies in collaboration with the CLACSO technical teams
3.2 Development of a blog-website model taking into consideration the particularities of the different

4. Preparation of an annual bulletin with the main advances of the members of the GT (in collaboration with the CLACSO technical team) and a formal presentation in the postgraduate programs related to the topic in each of the member organizations of the GT

5. Development of 2 annual virtual meetings for exchange and reflection on energy transition processes in LAC with the Working Groups Global Environmental Change and Local Social Metabolism and Political Ecologies of the South

6. Prepare the proposal and submit it in the next open call of CLACSO.
1.1. Increase associative work by promoting participation in congresses and conferences held in the GT member institutions and related to the topics of the energy field.
1.2. Seminar Proceedings
1.3. Increase associative work by promoting participation in congresses and conferences held in the GT member institutions and related to the topics of the energy field.

2. 6 thesis projects of young researchers from the GT in postgraduate programs in 5 countries: Argentina, Brazil, Mexico, Germany and the United Kingdom

3.1. Audiovisual production. Dissemination through the networks of the institutes and member organizations of the GT
3.2. Preliminary version of blog-web page

4. Newsletters prepared and shared
Presentations in the various postgraduate programs

5. Increase dialogue and coordination between CLACSO Working Groups

6. Increase postgraduate training in the topics covered by the GT, which are currently scarce in CLACSO.
PROMOTION OF PUBLIC RESPONSIBILITY AND SOCIAL INTERVENTION ACTIONS
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
1. Promote dialogues with specialized national agencies and public energy companies

2. Promote dialogue with social and trade union organizations
1. Drafting of a national diagnostic document that contributes to the formulation of public policies.
Presentation of the document to national public agencies.

2.1 Start the search for new researchers in the countries of the GT member institutions.
2.2. Initiate the GT's dialogue with civil society networks in the region such as Latindadd, the Fiscal Justice Network and regional trade union networks
1. Generate dialogue and influence in national organizations specializing in the design of public energy policies.

2.1. Expand the composition of the GT members
2.2. Coordination of actions and strategies with different civil society interest groups linked to energy issues
ARTICULATION WITH OTHER LATIN AMERICAN, CARIBBEAN AND GLOBAL NETWORKS AND INSTITUTIONS
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
1. Initiate a strategy of linking with other donor institutions.

2. Promote CLACSO's dialogue with extra-regional strategic partners on issues related to climate change and the energy transition.
1. Manage the support of the Ebert Foundation to develop and strengthen the space for debate and academic activities and discussion with political and social actors from a critical and original perspective and approaches.

2.1 Promote strategic dialogue with the CASS of China through the organization of thematic forums for reflection and information exchange.
1. Diversification of funding sources to expand the work of the GT by receiving financial support for conducting workshops and working meetings.

2. Organizational meetings and organized dialogue and reflection forums.
New projects are initiated based on these initial actions.
WORK PLAN FOR THE SECOND YEAR (01/01/2024 al 31/12/2024)
OBJECTIVES
ACTIVITIES
EXPECTED OUTCOMES
KNOWLEDGE PRODUCTION
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
1. Prepare the research "Critical perspectives on energy transitions in Latin America and the Caribbean"

2. Conduct internal virtual training sessions on topics related to Energy and Sustainable Development

3. Special Issue in the Academic Journal El Trimestre Económico of Mexico. “Climate Crisis and Energy Transitions in Latin America. Tensions and Disputes between Climate, Economy and Society”

4. Promote the creation of a publication series at CLACSO on “Climate, Energy and Environment”

5. Preparation of thematic bulletins to disseminate reflections from the GT researchers.
1.1. Definition for case studies of comparable criteria on variables, indicators and secondary sources of information.
1.2. Writing the articles

2. Conduct bimonthly videoconferences to promote conceptual discussions on the link between energy democratization, climate justice, and energy poverty.

3.1. Double-blind peer review of articles
3.2. Publication of the Special Issue

4. Encourage the submission of book publication proposals

5. Preparation of two thematic bulletins per year to disseminate the thematic reflections that arise from the virtual training meetings.
1.1. Second research progress report.
1.2. Preliminary versions of the articles

2. Systematized material as a record of the virtual meetings.

3. Publication of the Special Issue

4. Proposals submitted.

5. Presentation of 6 newsletters in 3 years.
DISSEMINATION OF KNOWLEDGE
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
1. Promote meeting spaces for work and academic exchange, and progressively increase the articulation of the work of the members of the GT.

2. Support for GT members in the completion of postgraduate theses on energy topics.

3. Development of a varied strategy of academic productions and audiovisual content to amplify the dissemination of energy topics both in academic settings and on the various social media platforms.

4. Promote the dissemination of research by members of the Working Group

5. Articulation with other CLACSO Working Groups

6. Submit a proposal for a Diploma in Climate, Energy and Sustainability to CLACSO
1. Organization of an international seminar on energy and sustainable development. Possible venues: Argentina, Ecuador, Peru, Costa Rica.

2. Promotion, accompaniment and support for young researchers who are interested in developing postgraduate theses on energy topics.

3. Design and implementation of a blog/website, which will also allow the creation of a repository of articles produced within the framework of the GT as well as by its members

4. Preparation of an annual bulletin with the main advances of the members of the GT (in collaboration with the CLACSO technical team) and a formal presentation in the postgraduate programs related to the topic in each of the member organizations of the GT

5. Development of 2 annual virtual meetings for exchange and reflection on energy transition processes in LAC with the Working Groups Global Environmental Change and Local Social Metabolism and Political Ecologies of the South

6. Prepare the proposal and submit it in the next open call of CLACSO.
1. International Seminar in a country to be defined (depending on available funds).

2. 6 thesis projects of young researchers from the GT in postgraduate programs in 5 countries: Argentina, Brazil, Mexico, Germany and the United Kingdom.

3. Based on the contributions of the GT members, the blog-website begins to centralize energy discussions in the region and serves as a repository for other research in the energy field.

4. Newsletters prepared and shared
Presentations in the various postgraduate programs

5. Increase dialogue and coordination between CLACSO Working Groups

6. Increase postgraduate training in the topics covered by the GT, which are currently scarce in CLACSO.
PROMOTION OF PUBLIC RESPONSIBILITY AND SOCIAL INTERVENTION ACTIONS
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
1. Promote dialogues with specialized national agencies and public energy companies

2. Promote dialogues with regional energy organizations

3. Promote dialogue with social and trade union organizations
1. Drafting of a national diagnostic document that contributes to the formulation of public policies.
Presentation of the document to national public agencies.

2. Drafting of 1 regional diagnostic document that contributes to the formulation of public policies.
Presentation to regional organizations specializing in energy, such as ECLAC and OLADE.

3.1. Start the search for new researchers
in countries that are not yet part of the GT
3.2. Continue the GT's dialogue with civil society networks in the region such as Latindadd, the Fiscal Justice Network and regional trade union networks.
1. Generate dialogue and influence in national organizations specializing in the design of public energy policies.

2. Generate dialogue and influence in regional organizations specializing in the design of public energy policies.

3.1. Consolidate the expansion process by incorporating researchers from countries that do not yet participate in the GT.
3.2. Coordination of actions and strategies with different civil society interest groups linked to energy issues.
ARTICULATION WITH OTHER LATIN AMERICAN, CARIBBEAN AND GLOBAL NETWORKS AND INSTITUTIONS
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
1. Initiate a strategy of linking with other donor institutions.

2. Promote CLACSO's dialogue with extra-regional strategic partners on issues related to climate change and the energy transition.
1. Manage OXFAM's support to develop and strengthen the space for debate and academic activities and discussion with political and social actors from a critical and original perspective and approaches.

2.1 Promote strategic dialogue with the CASS of China through the organization of thematic forums for reflection and information exchange.

2.2. Promote CLACSO's strategic dialogue with the South-South Dialogue program through the organization of thematic forums for reflection and information exchange.
1. Diversification of funding sources to expand the work of the GT by receiving financial support for conducting workshops and working meetings.

2. Organizational meetings and organized dialogue and reflection forums. New projects are initiated based on these initial actions.
WORK PLAN FOR THE THIRD YEAR (01/01/2025 al 31/12/2025)
OBJECTIVES
ACTIVITIES
EXPECTED OUTCOMES
KNOWLEDGE PRODUCTION
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
1. Prepare the research "Critical perspectives on energy transitions in Latin America and the Caribbean"

2. Conduct internal virtual training sessions on topics related to Energy and Sustainable Development.

3. Special Issue in the Academic Journal El Trimestre Económico of Mexico. “Climate Crisis and Energy Transitions in Latin America. Tensions and Disputes between Climate, Economy and Society”

4. Promote the creation of a publication series at CLACSO on “Climate, Energy and Environment”

5. Preparation of thematic bulletins to disseminate reflections from the GT researchers.
1. Editing, compilation and publication of results

2. Conduct bimonthly videoconferences to promote exchanges that allow for a precise understanding of the links between international finance, the geopolitics of energy, and climate change.

3.1. Public presentation of the special issue
3.2. Dissemination of results

4. Encourage the submission of book publication proposals

5. Preparation of two thematic bulletins per year to disseminate the thematic reflections that arise from the virtual training meetings.
1. Publishing a book

2. Systematized material as a record of the virtual meetings.

3. Memoirs of the presentation meetings

4. Proposals submitted.

5. Presentation of 6 newsletters in 3 years.
DISSEMINATION OF KNOWLEDGE
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
1. Promote meeting spaces for work and academic exchange, and progressively increase the articulation of the work of the members of the GT.

2. Support for GT members in the completion of postgraduate theses on energy topics.

3. Development of a varied strategy of academic productions and audiovisual content to amplify the dissemination of energy topics both in academic settings and on the various social media platforms.

4. Promote the dissemination of research by members of the Working Group

5. Articulation with other CLACSO Working Groups

6. Submit a proposal for a Diploma in Climate, Energy and Sustainability to CLACSO
1.1. Third International Seminar on Energy Poverty in Latin America and the Caribbean, together with the Energy Poverty Network (RedPE) and the Latin American Energy Inclusion Network (RedIEL). Format to be defined.
1.2. Setting up a panel on studies at the XVI Conference on Social Studies of the Economy, EIDAES-UNSAM (Argentina). Investigate other international conferences or congresses where thematic panels can be set up.

2. Promotion, accompaniment and support for young researchers who are interested in developing postgraduate theses on energy topics.

3. Design and implementation of a blog/website, which will also allow the creation of a repository of articles produced within the framework of the GT as well as by its members

4.1. Holding multiple events to present the book “Critical Perspectives on Energy Transitions in LAC”
4.2 Preparation of an annual bulletin with the main advances of the members of the GT (in collaboration with the CLACSO technical team) and a formal presentation in the postgraduate programs linked to the topic in each of the member organizations of the GT

5. Development of 2 annual virtual meetings for exchange and reflection on energy transition processes in LAC with the Working Groups Global Environmental Change and Local Social Metabolism and Political Ecologies of the South

6. If the diploma course is approved.
1.1 Increase associative work by promoting participation in congresses and conferences held in the GT member institutions and related to the topics of the energy field.
1.2. Increase associative work by promoting participation in congresses and conferences held in the GT member institutions and related to the topics of the energy field.

2. 6 thesis projects of young researchers from the GT in postgraduate programs in 5 countries: Argentina, Brazil, Mexico, Germany and the United Kingdom.

3. Book presentation days in 6 countries: Argentina, Brazil, Ecuador, Peru, Mexico, Chile and Uruguay.

4. Newsletters prepared and shared
Presentations in the various postgraduate programs

5. Increase dialogue and coordination between CLACSO Working Groups

6. Delivery of the Diploma Course
PROMOTION OF PUBLIC RESPONSIBILITY AND SOCIAL INTERVENTION ACTIONS
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
1. Promote dialogues with specialized national agencies and public energy companies

2. Promote dialogue with social and trade union organizations
1. Drafting of 1 diagnostic document on the situation of public energy companies in the region.
Presentation of documents to the various national public companies.

2. Continue the dialogue with civil society networks in the region such as Latindadd, the Tax Justice Network, regional trade union networks and add other international networks, such as EURODAD and the Financial Transparency Coalition (FTC).
1. Generate dialogue and influence among officials of public energy companies.

2. To consolidate the GT's networking with other countries and regions, especially Europe and the United States
ARTICULATION WITH OTHER LATIN AMERICAN, CARIBBEAN AND GLOBAL NETWORKS AND INSTITUTIONS
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
1. Initiate a strategy of linking with other donor institutions.

2. Promote CLACSO's dialogue with extra-regional strategic partners on issues related to climate change and the energy transition.
1. Manage the support of Public Services International (PSI) to develop and strengthen the space for debate and academic activities and discussion with political and social actors from a critical and original perspective and approaches.

2.1. Promote strategic dialogue with the CASS of China through the organization of thematic forums for reflection and information exchange.
2.2. Promote CLACSO's strategic dialogue with the South-South Dialogue program through the organization of thematic forums for reflection and information exchange.
1. Diversification of funding sources to expand the work of the GT by receiving financial support for conducting workshops and working meetings.

2. Organizational meetings and organized dialogue and reflection forums. New projects are initiated based on these initial actions.

5. Members of the Working Group
Total number of researchers admitted: 87
Sebastian Ibarra Gonzalez
Department of Social Sciences and Humanities, University of Aysén
Chile
Marina Yesica Recalde
Environment and Development Program - Bariloche Foundation
Argentina
Raiana Schirmer Soares
Institute of Energy and Environment/USP
Brazil
Pablo Daniel Garibaldi
Faculty of Social Sciences, (UBA)
Argentina
Ingrid Rost-Góngora
Energy Poverty Network, University of Chile
Chile
Arantes Ferreira Danúsia
Faculty of Electrical Engineering and Computing of the State University of Campinas – FEEC/UNICAMP
Brazil
Diego Pérez Roig
Patagonian Institute of Humanities and Social Sciences Studies – IPEHCS-CONICET-UNCo
Argentina
Nora Estela Fernandez Mora [Coordinator]
Latin American Center for Research in Social Sciences and Humanities
Faculty of Human Sciences
Pontifical Catholic University of Ecuador
Ecuador
Alicia Puyana
Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences, Mexico
Mexico
Deborah Eliana Ascencio
Workers' Innovation Center
CONICET and UMET (Metropolitan University for Education and Work)
Argentina
David Bonilla Vargas
Economic Research Institute
National Autonomous University of Mexico
Mexico
Oscar Ugarteche
Economic Research Institute
National Autonomous University of Mexico
Mexico
Mariano Alejandro Barrera
Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences, Argentina
Argentina Program
Argentina
Israel Felipe Solorio Sandoval
Faculty of Political and Social Sciences
National Autonomous University of Mexico
Mexico
Lilia García Manrique
Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences, Mexico
Mexico
Felipe Botelho Tavares
"Brazilian Institute of Petroleum and Gas - IBP
Brazil
Jonatan Andrés Nuñez
Institute of Latin American and Caribbean Studies
Faculty of Social Sciences
University of Buenos Aires
Argentina
B. Mariana Galicia Ramos
Faculty of Economics, (UNAM)
Mexico
José Gabriel Luis Cordova
Department of Law, Faculty of Social Sciences, Central University “Marta Abreu” of Las Villas
Cuba
María Florencia Zabaloy
National University of the South, Department of Economics
Argentina
Javier Taks
Faculty of Humanities and Educational Sciences
University of the Republic
Uruguay
Clara Garcia
Faculty of Economics and Business Administration. Complutense University of Madrid
Spain
Luan Santos
Federal University of Rio de Janeiro. Macaé Campus
Brazil
Rodrigo Valdovinos Flores
Department of renewable energy and energy efficiency, Institute of the Environment (IDMA)
Chile
Daniel Sandoval
Division of Social Sciences and Humanities
Metropolitan Autonomous University, Cuajimalpa Unit
Mexico
Thauan Santos
Naval War College
Brazil
Angus McNelly
Society of Latin American Studies (UK)
United Kingdom
Lenin Mondol
Institute for Social Research
Faculty of Social Sciences
Costa Rica university
Costa Rica
Astrid Yanet Aguilera Cazalbón
Post-Graduation Program in International Relations, University of the State of Rio de Janeiro (PPGRI/UERJ)
Brazil
Paula Blodinger
Faculty of Political and Social Sciences, National University of Cuyo
Argentina
Martin Kazimierski
Institute of Latin American and Caribbean Studies
Faculty of Social Sciences
University of Buenos Aires
Argentina
Carlos Andrés Valdivia Alcántara
National University of Cuyo, Faculty of Political and Social Sciences.
Argentina
Bertoni Challenge
Faculty of Humanities and Educational Sciences
University of the Republic
Uruguay
Betina Cardoso
National University of Comahue (UNCo), Andean Patagonian Institute of Biological and Geoenvironmental Technologies (IPATEC-CONICET), Argentina
Argentina
Antonio Zambrano Allende
Postgraduate Program in Territorial Development in Latin America and the Caribbean
Paulista State University - UNESP
Brazil
Ramón Pichs Madruga
Center for World Economy Research
Cuba
María Eugenia Ortiz
Center for Studies in Citizenship, State and Political Affairs
Faculty of Social Sciences
University of Buenos Aires
Argentina
Edgar Israel Belmont Cortés
Department of Anthropology. Autonomous University of Querétaro.
Mexico
Sara María Costa Garay
Sovereignty Lab / Culture and Participation
Paraguay
Sigrid De Aquino Neiva
Institute of Energy and Environment / University of São Paulo (IEA/USP)
Brazil
Igor Fuser
Federal University of ABC (UFABC)
Brazil
Rubby Yesenia Parrado Rodríguez
National University of Colombia
Cesar Carrera
Center for Studies and Promotion of Development
Peru
Cassio Cardoso Carvalho
Federal University of ABC (UFABC)
Brazil
Ignacio Sabbatella
Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences, Argentina
Argentina Program
Argentina
Paola Velasco Herrejón
University College Cork / University of Cambridge
_Others
Humberto Campodónico
Center for Studies and Promotion of Development
Peru
Pablo Ferragut
Faculty of Humanities and Educational Sciences
University of the Republic
Uruguay
Vanessa Leticia Maria Cueto La Rosa
1. Civil Association LAW, ENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES (DAR)
Peru
Yudi Lorena Gomez Bravo
Nucleus of Strategic Studies, Geopolitics and Regional Integration (NEEGI)
Brazil
Andrea Michelle Viera Romero
University of Guayaquil (UG)
Ecuador
Jorgelina Sannazzaro
Energy Poverty Network
Chile
Lourdes Isabel Patiño Pascumal
School of Economics, University of Costa Rica
Costa Rica
Nestor Julian Antonio Cortes Oggero
Energy Poverty Network - University of Chile
Chile
Isabel Rodríguez Peña
Anahuac University
Mexico
Andrea Lampis
Institute of Energy and Environment/USP
Brazil
Andrea Molinari
Interdisciplinary School of Advanced Social Studies
National University of San Martín (UNSAM)
Argentina
María María Ibañez Martin
Department of Economics of the National University of the South - Institute of Economic and Social Research of the South (IIESS, CONICET-UNS)
Argentina
Icoana Laís Leitão Mascarenhas Martins
Latin American Institute of Economy, Society and Politics
-FEDERAL UNIVERSITY OF LATIN-AMERICAN INTEGRATION
Brazil
Jonathan Israel Garcia Olicon
Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences, Mexico
Mexico
Marcio Giannini Pereira
Electrical Energy Research Center - Eletrobras Cepel
Brazil
Lira Luz Benites Lazaro
Post-Graduation Program in the Integration of Latin America
University of São Paulo
Brazil
Tamara Oyarzún
Faculty of Social Sciences of the University of Chile (NIID-UCHILE)
Chile
Ariela Ruiz Caro
Center for Studies and Promotion of Development
Peru
Elaine Valton Legrá
Raúl Roa García Higher Institute of International Relations
Cuba
Esteban Serrani [Coordinator]
Interdisciplinary School of Advanced Social Studies
National University of San Martín (UNSAM)
Argentina
Carina Guzowski
National University of the South, Department of Economics
Argentina
Hans Jürgen
Chair of International and Intersocietal Relations, Latin American Forum
University of Kassel
Germany,
Rafael Almeida Ferreira Abrao
Federal University of ABC (UFABC)
Brazil
Rafael Fernández Sánchez
Faculty of Economics and Business. Complutense University of Madrid.
Spain
Josué Ernesto Rosendo Rentería
Center for Studies and Research of the Barranca.
Mexico
Leandro Navarro Rocha
Interdisciplinary School of Advanced Social Studies
National University of San Martín (UNSAM)
Argentina
Maite Alejandra Del Pilar Hernando Arrese
Transdisciplinary Center for Environmental Studies, Austral University
Chile
Mónica Santillán Vera
Center for Economic Research and Teaching AC
Mexico
Oscar Mauricio Hernández Carvajal
School of Social Sciences, Arts and Humanities
National Open and Distance University
Colombia
Tobias Franz
Society of Latin American Studies (UK)
United Kingdom
Cecilia Vuyk
Sovereignty Lab / Culture and Participation
Paraguay
Eliana Celeste Canafoglia
INCIHUSA. CONICET. UNCuyo
Argentina
Ana Lía Del Valle Guerrero
Department of Humanities of the National University of the South
National University of Sur
Argentina
Luis Eduardo Reina Bermúdez
School of Social Sciences, Arts and Humanities
National Open and Distance University
Colombia
Andrés Iván Mideros Mora
Latin American Center for Research in Social Sciences and Humanities
Faculty of Human Sciences
Pontifical Catholic University of Ecuador
Ecuador
Cesar Leonidas Gamboa Balbín
Derecho Ambiente y Recursos Naturales (DAR)
Peru
Carolina Grangeia
Production Engineering Program of the Federal University of Rio de Janeiro (UFRJ)
Brazil
Carolina Pasciaroni
Department of Economics (UNS)
Argentina
Lina Maria Londoño Sanchez
School of Social Sciences, Arts and Humanities (UNAD)
Colombia
Paz Isabel Araya Jofré
Energy Poverty Network
Chile
Deborah Werner
Urban and Regional Research and Planning Institute
Federal University of Rio de Janeiro
Brazil