Thematic Field: Epistemologies of the South and Decolonial
WorkgroupParticipatory processes and methodologies
[+ View productions and content]Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities
Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities
NATIONAL UNIVERSITY OF RAFAELA
Argentina
Department of Social Sciences
Northern Coastal Regional University Center
University of the Republic
Uruguay
Our Working Group proposes as a field of study, reflection and intervention an area that is composed of two dimensions relevant to the work of Latin American social researchers: on the one hand, we will work on the processes of participation (instituting and instituted) seeking to improve our understanding of their trajectories of change, their challenges and the conditions for their functioning in this continent and in other regions; on the other hand, the field of participatory methodologies that accompany the processes of action reflection-action as an approach that supports the implementation of interventions.
PARTICIPATORY PROCESSES
Following Cunill (1997), four forms of participation can be identified: social, community, political, and civic. All involve ways of intervening in the public sphere, sometimes at the invitation of the State and other times at the initiative of the citizens themselves, pursuing different goals and with different interlocutors depending on the type of participation (Villarreal, 2009; Ziccardi, 1998). Among these, the creation and dissemination of multiple instruments of institutionalized civic participation constitutes one of the most innovative phenomena of late 20th-century democracies. Examples include neighborhood councils, participatory budgeting, municipal assemblies, participatory strategic plans, social advisory councils, participatory urban planning processes, and prior consultations with indigenous communities, among others. In this respect, Latin America has been a pioneer, for example, with the emergence of participatory budgeting in Porto Alegre in 1989, which has since spread throughout the world. Therefore, interest in the processes generated in these mechanisms invites us to critically analyze their evolution and assess their contribution to the quality of democracies.
On the other hand, we are interested in the collective action of Latin American organizations and social movements, for example, the autonomous forms of territorial organization of indigenous communities in Mexico and Peru, or forms of militant research such as popular universities in various countries, the processes followed by the MST or the National Movement for the Struggle for Housing in Brazil, mass actions such as #NiUnaMenos, #OcupaWallStreet or #ConMisHijosNoTeMetas, or the inorganic movement of protests for better social conditions and the promotion of a new constitution in Chile, among others.
It can be argued that in Latin America, demands for participation have impacted national and local constitutions, leading to an expansion of direct, participatory, and community-based democracy that must be critically analyzed in light of its practical application. To the increase in institutionalized mechanisms of participation (Welp, 2015), we must add the increase and diversification of participatory practices (protest mobilizations in Chile, Ecuador, and other countries, as well as other practices of social, community, and self-managed movements and organizations, such as those focused on popular education or community organizing). In this regard, Calderón (2016) points out that these practices have shown different directions and intensities. On the one hand, we find demands aimed at improving basic levels of access to and quality of public services, and on the other hand, demands more oriented toward intercultural dynamics. On one hand, new actors have appeared on the scene (such as the Mapuche, the Aymara, the Nasa people and other native populations) and on the other hand, new issues have emerged (equal marriage, legalization of marijuana, student and youth demands, among others).
Thus, these different forms of participation are gaining importance in Latin America, coinciding with a representative democracy that is being questioned in political and academic circles. But there is also the rise of nationalist, neoliberal, and populist right-wing movements with increasing militant support from evangelical churches that challenge many of the rights won through social struggles. One of the current challenges for democracies to overcome their shortcomings is to advance in terms of "quality," that is, to "democratize democracy" through citizen participation not only in free, fair, and frequent elections, but also in political decision-making and in demanding accountability from those in power (Levine and Molina, 2007; O'Donnell, 2004).
PARTICIPATORY METHODOLOGIES
This dimension is both independent of and complementary to the previous one, insofar as participatory research processes contribute to improving the chances of success of participatory processes. Latin America has been the scene of emergence and development of various participatory research methodologies (popular education, communication for social change, action research in social psychology, thematic research, participatory action research, systematization of experiences, collective recovery of memory and history, militant research), which have sought to contribute to the empowerment of popular sectors of the population that mobilize around collective demands and rights, forming organizations and social movements that are an alternative to the dominant models of the State and economy.
Indeed, with the thematic research incorporated by Paulo Freire into his educational proposal in the 1960s, and especially with the participatory action research developed by Orlando Fals Borda and his team of researchers at the beginning of the following decade (Gajardo, 1985), Latin American social sciences committed to emancipatory processes gained a methodological alternative to the prevailing positivism. Following the World Congress in Cartagena (1977), these emerging methodologies generated spaces for debate, interaction, and projection, becoming a dynamic research current that transcended the field of social sciences, impacting other areas such as planning, education, and social work.
The World Congress on Convergence (Cartagena, 1997) demonstrated that this rebellious methodology had achieved global reach and continued to expand its scope. The publication of anthologies and collaborative books on the subject (Brandao, 1987; Fals Borda and Anisur, 1991; Brandao and Streck, 2006), the creation of the International Journal of Action Research (IJAR) in 2008, and the Symposia on participatory methodologies held in Porto Alegre (2011), Copenhagen (2013), Bogotá (2015), Cartagena (2017), and Rosario (2018) confirm the continued relevance and vitality of this critical methodology.
Participatory methodologies have been a major contribution of Latin American social sciences to global knowledge, and in recent times there has been a renewed interest in these methodologies among new generations, who are also updating their content and proposals on the path to building truly sustainable participatory democracies. This is why today in Latin America, participatory research, in its different expressions, settings, and involving various actors, is an essential field of research and political practice for understanding the current reconfiguration of the social sciences and the increasingly close links between them and the political processes and social movements that promote participation.
Finally, it is worth noting that 2025 marks the centenary of the birth of Orlando Fals Borda, a foundational figure in participatory methodologies in social research and grassroots participatory democracies; therefore, during this period of the Working Group, we will be generating conditions and initiatives so that this year is recognized as the ORLANDO FALS BORDA YEAR OF PARTICIPATION.
- Brandão, Carlos (1987). Rethinking participant research. Sao Pablo, Brazilian publisher.
- Brandão, Carlos and Streck, Danilo (2006). Participating research. Or know the partilha. Aparecida, Ideas & lyrics.
- Calderón, Fernando (2016). Ten theses on social conflict in Latin America. CEPAL Review, 107 (August).
- Cunill Grau, Nuria (1997). Rethinking the public through society. New forms of public management and social representation. Venezuela: CLAD and Nueva Sociedad.
- Espinosa, Yuderkys; Gómez, Daiana and Ochoa, Karina (2014). “Introduction”. In: Yuderkys Espinosa et al. (eds.), Weaving in Another Way. Feminism, Epistemology and Decolonial Bets in Abya-Yala. Popayán: Editorial Universidad del Cauca. Proceedings of the GLEFAS Annual Meeting, Oaxaca, Mexico, July 16-18, 2015. Walsh, Catherine (ed.). (2013). Decolonial Pedagogies. Insurgent Practices of Resisting, (Re)existing and (Re)living. Volume I. Quito: Abya-Yala.
- Fals Borda, Orlando and Anisur, Rahman (1991). Action and knowledge. Bogotá: CINEP.
- Gajardo, Marcela (1985). Participatory research in Latin America. In: Working Paper # 261. Santiago. FLACSO.
- Levine, Daniel. and Molina, José (2007). The quality of democracy in Latin America: a comparative view. In Latin America Today, No. 45: 17-46.
Lissidini, A. and Blasina, E. (2013). Uruguay in the new post-materialist agenda: towards greater autonomy and enjoyment of life? Retrieved from
http://www.condistintosacentos.com/uruguay¬en¬la¬nueva
Post-materialist agenda towards greater autonomy and enjoyment of life/
- Lissidini, Alicia; Welp, Yanina and Zovatto, Daniel (2014). Politics in motion. In Alicia Lissidini, Yanina Welp and Daniel Zovatto (Comp.) Mechanisms of Direct and Participatory Democracy in Latin America. Mexico: ISBN 978-607-02-5407-9.
- Noboa, Alejandro; Bisio, Natalia; Suárez, Mariano and Robaina, Natalie (2013). Citizen Participation: The Public Management of Participatory Budgets seen from its protagonists. Salto: UdelaR.
- O'Donnell, Guillermo (2004). Democracy, Human Rights, Human Development. In The Quality of Democracy: Theory and Applications. G. O'Donnell, O. Iazzetta and J. Vargas Cullell. Notre Dame, University of Notre Dame Press: 7¬120.
- Quijano, Anibal (1992). “Coloniality and modernity-rationality”. In: Heraclio Bonilla (ed.), The conquered: 1492 and the indigenous population of the Americas. Quito: FLACSO-Libri Mundi.
- Rodríguez-Villasante, Tomás (2015) 'Action-reflection-action for the 21st century'. Bogotá: In: III International Symposium Participatory Action Research Homage to Orlando Fals Borda. Bogotá: National Pedagogical University, p. 15.
- Rodríguez-Villasante, Tomás (2006). Creative overflows. Styles and strategies for social transformation. Madrid: Catarata.
- Streck, Danilo; Sobokka, Emil and Eggert, Edla (2014). Know and transform. Curitiba: Editora CRV.
- Torres, Alfonso. (2016) 'The collective recovery of history and memory as a popular educational practice', Decisio, 43–44 (January-August), pp. 16–22.
- Villarreal, María (2009). Citizen participation and public policies. Tenth Political Essay Contest. Mexico: State Electoral Commission of the State of Nuevo León. Available online. Retrieved from http://www.ceenl.org.mx/educacion/certamen_ensayo/decimo/MariaTeresaVillarrealMartinez.pdf
- Walsh, Catherine (ed.). (2013). Decolonial Pedagogies: Insurgent Practices of Resisting, (Re)existing, and (Re)living. Volume I. Quito: Abya-Yala
- Welp, Yanina (2015). Citizen participation, power and democracy: notes for a debate. In Journal of the Argentine Network of Participatory Budgeting.
- Ziccardi, Alicia (1998). Governance and citizen participation in the capital city. Mexico: UNAM and Miguel Ángel Porrúa.
Following the idea of the two dimensions that make up our field of work as a GT, we can say that beyond the generic recognition of the virtues of participatory mechanisms and processes as potential generators of transformations, reflections on these phenomena, which are widely perfectible, need to be nourished by practice, research and criticism.
As Ford and Carné (2009) argue, despite the proliferation of participatory public policies, participation in these mechanisms has not been shown to inherently generate creative proposals for addressing social problems. The same could be said of many non-institutionalized processes. To address this context, we conduct research and engage with participatory processes to deepen our analysis of their theoretical relevance. From our Working Group, in collaboration with regional and international networks and other working groups, we focus on research, action, and training agendas that contribute to strengthening knowledge and practices related to the quality of citizen and social participation processes and methodologies. Thus, we aim to guide our contributions toward the co-generation of situated knowledge, based on critical reflection from universities, public organizations, and civil society organizations.
For their part, the various forms of participation challenge some of the contradictions that need to be addressed (economic, political, environmental, food-related, labor-related, and cultural) associated with the capitalist model of production and consumption of goods and the exploitation of people and the environment. Along these lines, we recognize the participation of decolonial organizations and movements focused on gender, diversity, and care, as well as Indigenous, Afro-descendant, and peasant communities, which reclaim alternative practices of knowledge and power, challenging the patriarchal and colonial culture of Latin America. Promoting outreach to share the experiences of struggle built from resistance is part of our objectives as a group. We aim to make visible new participatory processes that will allow us to build new transformations.
Another key focus of the Working Group will be to continue discussions on methodological contributions and advance participatory action research methodologies. These methodologies foster the co-creation of knowledge, starting from the recognition, understanding, and appreciation of transformative trajectories and lived experiences within complex realities. This is achieved by connecting diverse perspectives and ways of knowing and existing (legal, economic, technical, spiritual, cultural, environmental, and others). Knowledge of participatory methodologies strengthens the practices of citizens, organizations, and researchers, facilitating the improvement of political and social processes. Thus, resolving vicious cycles in our knowledge construction involves recognizing and valuing trajectories of change rooted in social and collective memory (Torres, 2016; Barragán and Torres, 2017; Santandreu and Betancourt, 2019) and intervening in the process, considering solutions from within and focusing on social creativity developed with the individuals involved (Villasante, 2011) (Rodríguez-Villasante, 2006). The application of these tools, which involve different approaches to working with stakeholders, allows for the co-construction of knowledge grounded in the transformation trajectories of organizations, communities, and individuals. This should be triangulated with other instruments (interviews, surveys, ARS, or others), generating new knowledge about the practices of people, organizations, and territories.
Participatory research (as a developing paradigm) draws on participatory methodologies (initially Participatory Action Research, among others) because its purpose is emancipation, transformation, or change. In this sense, it understands Latin American social reality as a complex world characterized by diverse contradictions, including those between nature and humanity, class, gender, ethnicity, and age, all of which are addressed from the ontology, epistemology, theory, and methodologies specific to Latin America. Participatory research is an ongoing, emerging dialogue of knowledge, which is being built as a counter-hegemonic theory that empowers communities to construct their own history and become a source of power.
However, a certain naturalization and excessive instrumentalization of participatory methodologies could lead us to the paradox of having participatory methodologies that do not subvert the processes in which they intervene (Santandreu, 2019). Critical reflection on our practice and the theoretical development with which it engages should therefore be a central and permanent aspect of the Working Group.
The democratic deficits in our sociopolitical reality, linked to its structural systems of inequality, demand approaches that promote the collective construction of knowledge, the articulation between knowledge and action, and an ecology of knowledges that propose postcolonial, post-development, and post-capitalist visions (Torres, 2014; Sousa Santos, 2010; Mignolo, 2005) openly oriented toward the search for creative local alternatives. The advancement of participatory methodologies is openly oriented toward these visions and, through its combination of reflection-action-reflection (Rodríguez-Villasante, 2015), already boasts significant processes of co-construction of knowledge by and for communities. Furthermore, it is necessary to contribute, through participatory methodologies, to making disadvantaged groups (due to gender, ethnicity, economic status, among others) visible from a political standpoint and to combating these inequalities from a common ground that allows for analyzing how to understand differences. Denaturalizing discrimination and combating gender oppression, beyond the fact that women's inequalities of opportunity may be related to problems of other minorities or to broader socio-political issues, undoubtedly implies making visible the power relations between men and women (Fernández, 2009).
In summary, we can say that participatory methodologies provide innovative ways of understanding complex phenomena such as collective action and social and political participation, allowing us to enhance our knowledge of the experiences that have been developing in the countries of the region, and in turn, due to their own vocation to learn together with the subjects (Villasante, 2011), they allow us to improve the experiences at the same time as we learn.
Addressing these components will allow the GT to move towards a better understanding of the problems, building "common worldviews" on the divergences and convergences of participatory processes and methodologies in Latin America and Spain, weaving networks for collective action.
- Ford, Alberto and Carné, Martín (2009). Challenges of participation in the implementation of public policies. In AA.VV., Building trust. Towards a new link between State and Civil Society. Volume II. Buenos Aires: Undersecretariat for Institutional Reform and Strengthening of Democracy (Chief of Cabinet of Ministers, Presidency of the Argentine Nation), CIPPEC.
- Mignolo, Walter (2010). The Idea of Latin America. The Colonial Wound and the Decolonial Option. Barcelona: Editorial Gedisa SA
- Paño Yáñez, Pablo, Rébola, Romina, Suárez Elías, Mariano (2019) Participatory Processes and Methodologies. Reflections and experiences for social transformation. CLACSO UDELAR.
- Santandreu, Alain (2019). 'Between subversion, subsidy and the temptation of Procrustes. Militant research as a touchstone of indolent PAR', in Paño, P., Rébola, Romina., and Suárez, Mariano. (eds.) Participatory Processes and Methodologies: Reflections and experiences for social transformation. First. Salto: CLACSO, UDELAR, pp. 42–56.
- Santandreu, Alain and Betancourt, Oscar. (2019) Trajectories of Change. Knowledge management for the
Learning and change in practice. First. Quito: Abya Yala, CoPEH-LAC, IDRC and ECOSAD.
- Sousa Santos, Boaventura. (2010). Decolonizing knowledge. Reinventing power. Montevideo: Trilce.
- Torres, Alfonso. (2014). Making history from below and from the South. Bogotá: Ediciones Desde Abajo.
- Villasante, Tomás. (2011). Styles and epistemology in participatory methodologies. In Pablo Paño and Andrés Falck (Eds.) Participatory Democracy and Participatory Budgeting: An Approach and Deepening of the Current Debate. Málaga: CEDMA
- Suárez, Mariano, Signorelli, Gisela, Mérida, Juan, Del Prado, Leonel [Coordinators] (2022) Participatory Experiences in the Global South: Other Possible Democracies? Working Groups Collection: CLACSO. National University of Rosario. Buenos Aires. https://www.clacso.org.ar/libreria-latinoamericana/libro_por_programa_detalle.php?campo=programa&texto=5&id_libro=2485
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
To contribute significantly to the
production of
knowledge about
processes and
methodologies
participatory, articulating Latin American working networks on the issue
Specific objectives:
1. To promote knowledge production through joint research among members of the GT, including undergraduate and postgraduate thesis students
2. To promote interaction between research teams of the GT and other working groups.
1.b. To carry out an international research project that seeks to comparatively analyze the current state of institutional participation in Latin America from a local perspective. In this first year, the task will be to map experiences and analyze trends in the different countries.
2 - Resume the meetings with GT EP and Critical Pedagogies and CEAAL on SYSTEMATIZATION OF EXPERIENCES, developed during 2021. New reflections for collective production
1.b. Generate a map that shows the situation of the selected Ibero-American countries in relation to the institutionalized experiences of participation at the local level.
2. Up to 3 virtual meetings per year. 1 shared production
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
To disseminate knowledge and experiences on the subject and to create
collectively new training proposals
Specific objectives:
1. Promote a space for dissemination on social media for the GT
2. Promote an identification for the GT.
3. Strengthen the Sentipensante Bulletin as a tool for disseminating information about the GT.
4. Design a postgraduate training space in participatory methodologies.
5. Promote training spaces on participatory methodologies among undergraduate students of the Universities linked to the GT.
6. Promote opportunities for academic mobility and internships among members of the GT.
7. Publish books edited by members of the GT between 2021 and 2022.
8. Promote the joint publication of a second book with the Working Group on Popular Education and Critical Pedagogies
9. Improve communication between members of the GT, regarding professional profiles and expertise related to participatory processes and methodologies.
10. Participate in spaces for debate and dissemination of knowledge about participatory processes and methodologies.
2. Design a logo for the identification of the GT in activities and productions.
3.a. Disseminate activities through the Sentipensante Newsletter Link:
https://sites.google.com/view/red-sentipensante/
3.b. Increased participation of group members in the Bulletin and encouragement of members of other related working groups to publish.
3.c. ISSN management and publication in the editorial collection of CLACSO Working Groups.
4. Presentation of a Virtual Higher Diploma in the 2023 call of the CLACSO Postgraduate Network.
5. Design of a Training Course in Participatory Methodologies aimed at undergraduate students, with the participation of the members of the GT.
6. Organization of visits and internships for members at the universities participating in the Working Group. To this end, a list will be compiled of academic groups and centers within the Working Group that can host and organize exchange activities, and support will be sought for advanced students and researchers in training to undertake academic mobility activities.
7.a. Publication of two books by the Working Group. First Book: Participatory Experiences and Methodologies. Second Book: Participatory Epistemologies and the Pandemic. Co-published with the CLACSO Working Groups Collection. Digital distribution
7.b. Printing of copies in paper format.
8. Joint edition with the Working Group on Popular Education and Critical Pedagogies of the Second Book Reinventing Ourselves with Paulo Freire.
9. Mapping of actions of members of the Network to facilitate exchanges: research programs, teaching and actions of linking with the community.
10.a. “International Days of Action Research and Community Development” to be held in Bilbao on April 26-27-28, 2023. In this event, organized by Parte Hartuz (UPV/EHU), we will participate as a Working Group of the coordination, articulating the task with a group that is applying for a CLACSO Working Group in the current call called "Urban Agenda and Participation"
local"
10. b. Dossier on Participation Processes, State and Territory, the result of the international seminar held on May 23 and 24, 2022 in Mexico. The dossier will be published in the journal Contraste Regional in Mexico, which belongs to the Center for Interdisciplinary Research in Regional Development, a CLACSO Center that belongs to CONACYT in Mexico.
2. Working Group Logo. Improved group identification.
3.a. Up to 3 annual publications of the Sentipensante Bulletin.
3.b.Improved dissemination of GT activities and publications of GT members and other invited GTs
3.c. ISBN and entry into the CLACSO Working Groups Collection
4. Virtual Higher Diploma in the CLACSO Postgraduate Network
5. Training course for undergraduate students.
6. At least two instances of academic mobility per year, among members of the GT.
7.a. Two GT books published. Digital dissemination in the CLACSO GT Collection
7.b. Printing of at least 100 copies in paper format
8. Publication of the Second Book co-edited with the Working Group on Popular Education and Critical Pedagogies.
9. Map of GT members to improve exchanges within the group.
10.a Presentations and panel discussions at the event organized by Parte Hartuz in April 2023.
10.b. Strengthening links with groups and networks linked to participation.
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
Promote spaces for dialogue and reflection with actors: local governments, social and community organizations, and social movements.
Specific objectives:
1. Recovering spaces for exchange between Territories and Universities, an experience initiated in 2021 by this Working Group.
2. Strengthen social media outreach tools.
3. Plan actions to connect with social actors and territorial groups.
4. Support local governments on issues of participation.
2. Development of podcasts with current topics that are linked to the GT's themes, to be shared through Radio Regional CENUR Litoral Norte, digital social networks and the GT's Instagram/Facebook, the Sentipensante Bulletin, the DETE Network Observatory, the Praxis Institute's YouTube channels, among other dissemination spaces.
3. Formation of an extension project among members of the GT, through the SPU - UNNE with the incorporation of social actors and territorial collectives.
4. Collaborative actions regarding training processes for impactful participation in public policy, together with the School of Participation of the District Institute for Participation and Community Action (IDPAC) - Bogotá. The central themes that the school will work on, and in which we can provide support, are: training processes in the area of participatory budgeting and participation in the policy of the care economy system.
2. At least 3 podcasts published per year.
3. SPU UNNE extension project. Submission to the call with the lines linked to the GT, with institutional and collective endorsements.
4. Conducting two workshops as part of the collaborative activities with the School of Participation (Bogotá)
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
To deepen links with other organizations and networks at the Latin American level and other international spaces that address participatory processes and methodologies.
Specific objectives:
1. Participate in spaces promoted by other networks and organizations
2. Plan dissemination activities with other networks and organizations to which members of the GT are linked.
2.a. Dissemination activities in conjunction with CEPED (Centre Population et Développement - University of Paris) and the French Research Institute for Development (Institut Reserche pour le Développement), for the exchange of experiences in participatory research and its analysis. Activities in conjunction with the Faculty of Humanities and the CES (both of UNNE).
2.b. Collaboration in the organization of an event on participation together with the applicant group "Urban Agenda and Participation"
local" (See in knowledge dissemination space)
2.a. At least one activity for 2023.
2.b. Strengthening links between networks linked to participation with researchers from Latin America and Europe.
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
To contribute significantly to the
production of
knowledge about
processes and
methodologies
participatory, articulating Latin American working networks on the issue
Specific objectives:
1. Analyze the situation of institutionalized participation in Latin America.
2. Promote academic publications by undergraduate and postgraduate thesis students and young researchers.
3. Encourage interaction between research teams of the GT for the definition of a glossary on participation
4. Co-generate productions between diverse knowledge (academic and non-academic)
5. Invite members to contribute to a new book by the Working Group
2. Publications by undergraduate and postgraduate thesis students and researchers
young journals from universities of GT members, as well as in the Sentipensante Bulletin.
3. a. Issuance of a call for proposals and preparation of a Dictionary/Glossary of Participation terms
3.b. 3. Construction of a Research Network in the territory: Education and Work.
4. Collective writing among other academic and non-academic actors for the promotion of other narratives, in university journals and the sentipensante bulletin.
5. Call for submissions and writing process for the new GT book on Epistemology and Experiences to be published in 2025.
2. At least two publications by thesis students in journals and the Sentipensante bulletin.
3. a. Production of a Glossary on participation.
3.b. Formation of a Research Network.
4. At least one collective publication between academic and non-academic knowledge.
5. Call for GT members for new book.
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
To disseminate knowledge and experiences on the subject and to create
collectively new training proposals
Specific objectives:
1. To maintain the Sentipensante Bulletin as a space for disseminating the Working Group's information.
2. Design a postgraduate training space in participatory methodologies.
3. Promote academic opportunities, internships, and teacher exchanges among members of working groups.
4. Generate reflection on current issues related to participatory processes and methodologies.
5. Promote critical reflection on the articulation between participation and education to generate inclusive and transformative practices.
6. Strengthen the links between the two Working Groups.
2. Presentation of a Virtual Higher Diploma in the 2023 call of the CLACSO Postgraduate Network.
3.a. The organization of visits and internships for members at the Universities participating in the GT will continue, prioritizing the participation of members in training.
3.b. Teaching exchanges in face-to-face and virtual spaces of undergraduate and postgraduate courses developed by members of the GT.
3.c.Summer School Implementation
4. a. Publication of a collective book by the GT. Epistemology and Experiences.
4.b. Publication of the Dictionary/Glossary of Participation Terms.
4.c. Hybrid (in-person-virtual) Working Group Meeting. This will be a research and planning meeting within the framework of an academic event organized by Parte Hartuz (Working Group members) at the University of the Basque Country (Bilbao). Virtual participation mechanisms will be provided for members unable to attend in person. Participants will have the opportunity to publish in a monograph on participation, Participatory Action Research (PAR), and community development, with publication guaranteed by the open-access journal Prisma Social (indexed in Scopus - Q3).
4.d. Publication of a shared article by members of the GT in a Scientific Dissemination Journal (Possibly the Latin American Journal of Environmental Humanities and Territorial Studies)
peer-reviewed, in Latindex)
5 and 6. Meeting co-organized between the Working Groups on Popular Education and Critical Pedagogies and Participatory Processes and Methodologies entitled: “Education and Participation. Thinking about the processes of transformation and knowledge construction”. It will be held in person at the Maldonado Campus of CURE (University of the Republic, Uruguay).
2. Complete the diploma within the CLASCO Postgraduate Network.
3.a. At least two completed internship exchanges.
3.b. At least three teaching exchanges for undergraduate and postgraduate courses.
3.c. At least one Summer School stay for 2024-2025.
4.a. A collective book by the GT on Epistemology and Experiences published.
4.b. A published Dictionary/Glossary of Participation terms.
5 and 6. Generation of different exchange spaces in various formats (workshops, round tables, panels, etc.)
5 and 6. It is expected that the participants of both GTs will strengthen their critical perspective and creativity regarding the processes worked on.
5 and 6. Strengthening of links and joint work plans between both GTs.
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
Promote spaces for dialogue and reflection with actors: local governments, social and community organizations, and social movements.
Specific objectives:
1. To maintain spaces for exchange between Territories and Universities.
2. Strengthen social media outreach tools.
3. Plan actions to connect with social actors and territorial groups.
2 and 3. Continuity of activities started in 2023
3. a. Participation of actors linked to community engagement processes in the meeting co-organized between the Working Groups on Popular Education and Critical Pedagogies and Participatory Processes and Methodologies entitled: “Education and Participation. Thinking about the processes of transformation and knowledge construction”. It will be held in person at the Maldonado Campus of CURE (University of the Republic, Uruguay).
3.b. Collective writing actions or other forms of communicating experiences (audiovisual) among other academic and non-academic actors for the promotion of other narratives.
3.c. Launch pilot projects together with the Provincial Council of Gipuzkoa to work in different municipalities of the territory with the agents involved and develop strategies to take advantage of the insertion of community development in the basic education curriculum.
2. and 3. Sustainability of actions initiated in 2023, for the entire three-year period.
3.a. Participation of at least one political/social actor or territorial collective in the Face-to-Face Meeting.
3.b. At least one publication/audiovisual of collective reflection by 2024.
3.c. Implement processes of participation and community action associated with the educational field in those territories.
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
To deepen links with other organizations and networks at the Latin American level and other international spaces that address participatory processes and methodologies.
Specific objectives:
1. Participate in spaces promoted by other networks and organizations
2. Co-organize with other networks and the Working Group on Popular Education and Critical Pedagogies on Critical Extension Days
1. b. At least 2 annual participations in spaces organized by other networks. (DETE Network, Network of Argentine Universities in Territorial Development, CEAAL, CIMAS? I would add here spaces where we have connections and can delve deeper)
2. Organize a meeting in Maldonado on participation and education together with Popular Education and Critical Pedagogies, articulating in turn other networks and institutions CURE and GEPADE UDELAR, Praxis Institute UTN Rafaela, RED DETE and Network of Argentine Universities in Territorial Development (See in Knowledge Dissemination).
1.b. At least 2 annual participations in spaces organized by other networks.
2. Face-to-face meeting co-organized in Maldonado (Uruguay)
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
To contribute significantly to the
production of
knowledge about
processes and
methodologies
participatory, articulating Latin American working networks on the issue
Specific objectives:
1. Develop the second phase of the international comparative research on institutional participation in Latin America from a local perspective.
2. Publish new book by the Working Group on Epistemologies and Experiences.
2. Completion and publication of the new GT book on Epistemology and Experiences.
2. Publication of New Book GT: Epistemologies and Experiences.
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
To disseminate knowledge and experiences on the subject and to create
collectively new training proposals
Specific objectives:
1. Organize a meeting for the dissemination of undergraduate theses related to participation topics.
2. Organize an in-person meeting of the Working Group within the framework of the CLACSO Conference
3. Participate in face-to-face sessions of the CLACSO Conference
4. Promote opportunities for academic mobility among members of the GT.
2. Face-to-face meeting of the Working Group within the framework of the CLACSO Conference
3.a. Panel of the Working Group at the CLACSO Conference
3.b. InterGT Workshop/Panel for the CLACSO Conference
4. Organization of visits and internships for members at the Universities participating in the GT, prioritizing the participation of members in training.
2. A face-to-face meeting of the Working Group within the framework of the CLACSO Conference
3.a. and b. 2 Panels/Workshops within the framework of the CLACSO 2025 Conference.
4. At least one exchange per year.
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
Promote spaces for dialogue and reflection with actors: local governments, social and community organizations, and social movements.
Specific objectives:
To deepen the exchange of experiences and reflections with political and social actors.
1. Organize new spaces for dialogue with stakeholders.
2. Co-generate a collective publication that systematizes the exchanges of the three years, within the framework of the GT.
1.b. Training course for action: for social and political actors on participatory techniques, tools and processes.
2. Collective publication on the systematization of the exchange spaces developed in the three years of the GT.
1.b. Design and implementation of a training course for action for social and political actors.
2. A publication of collective systematization of exchange spaces
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
To deepen links with other organizations and networks at the Latin American level and other international spaces that address participatory processes and methodologies.
Specific objectives:
1. Participate in dissemination activities linked to other networks and organizations.
1.b. Annual participation in spaces organized by other networks. (DETE Network, Network of Argentine Universities in Territorial Development, CEAAL, CIMAS Network, International Association for Public Participation, among others)
1.b. At least two participations per year.
Total number of researchers admitted: 117
Center for Social and Humanistic Research
Faculty of Social and Human Sciences
University of Antioquia
Colombia
Department of Social Sciences
Agronomy faculty
University of the Republic
Uruguay
Institute for Socioeconomic Research
Faculty of Social Sciences
National University of San Juan
Argentina
CURE-UDELAR
Uruguay
Observatory of Social Participation and Territory
University of Playa Ancha
Chile
University of La Laguna Department of Geography and History Faculty of Humanities Guajara Campus
Spain
Master's student in Territorial Development FRRA UTN and Interdisciplinary Regional Team Rafaela Ministry of Education of the Province of Santa Fe
Argentina
CURE-UdelaR
Uruguay
Institute for Advanced Study
University of Santiago, Chile
Chile
Institute for Socioeconomic Research
Faculty of Social Sciences
National University of San Juan
Argentina
University of Cuenca
Ecuador
Department of Social Sciences
Northern Coastal Regional University Center
University of the Republic
Uruguay
S / D
Chile
Center for Social and Humanistic Research
Faculty of Social and Human Sciences
University of Antioquia
Colombia
Pontifical Catholic University of Peru
Peru
Center for Studies in Local Development Management
University of Holguín
Cuba
General Directorate of Production and Recreation of Knowledge
National Experimental University of the Arts
Venezuela
University of the Basque Country
_Others
Department of Social Sciences
Northern Coastal Regional University Center
University of the Republic
Uruguay
Department of Social Sciences
Faculty of Humanities
National Pedagogical University
Colombia
Center for Social Studies
Rectorate of the UNNE
Northeastern University
Argentina
Department of Social Sciences
Northern Coastal Regional University Center
University of the Republic
Uruguay
University of the Basque Country
Spain
National Technological University, Rafaela Regional Faculty, Argentina.
Argentina
CENCA Institute of Urban Development - National University of San Marcos
Peru
University of Nariño, Colombia
Colombia
University of Valladolid
Spain
Center for Social Studies
Rectorate of the UNNE
Northeastern University
Argentina
Institute of Political Studies
University of Antioquia
Colombia
Center for Conflict and Social Cohesion Studies
Universidad de Chile
Chile
Observatory of Social Participation and Territory
University of Playa Ancha
Chile
Institute for Socioeconomic Research
Faculty of Social Sciences
National University of San Juan
Argentina
Institute of Political Studies
University of Antioquia
Colombia
Center for Studies in Local Development Management
University of Holguín
Cuba
Praxis Institute FRRA UTN and Faculty of Professional Studies of UNRaf
Argentina
San Francisco Xavier University of Chuquisaca
Bolivia
Alternative City
Chile
Faculty of Political Science and International Relations - UNR
Argentina
Creasvi Foundation
Spain
ECOSA Consortium for Health, Environment and Development
Peru
ORKESTRA Institute of Territorial Competitiveness of the University of Deusto (Basque Country)
Spain
Department of Social Sciences
Northern Coastal Regional University Center
University of the Republic
Uruguay
Mariana University - Unimar
Colombia
Mariana University - Unimar
Colombia
National Technological University, Rafaela Regional Faculty, Argentina.
Argentina
University of the Basque Country
Spain
Center for Regional Development Studies and Public Policy
University of Los Lagos
Chile
Complutense University of Madrid
Spain
Department of Sociology, 524 West 59th Street, New York, NY, 10019
S / D
Bolivia
UTN Rafaela
Argentina
Institute for Cooperation and Self-Development (ICADE)
Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities
Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities
NATIONAL UNIVERSITY OF RAFAELA
Argentina
Faculty of Education Sciences
Catholic University of the East
Colombia
University of the Valley
Colombia
Network of Researchers and Social Organizations of Latin America
Argentina
Academic Pedagogical Institute of Social Sciences
National University of Villa María
Argentina
l'ARADA Cooperative
Spain
Faculty of Social Sciences-UNA
National University of Asuncion
Paraguay
Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities
Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities
NATIONAL UNIVERSITY OF RAFAELA
Argentina
University of the Basque Country/Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea. Faculty of Social Sciences and Communication. Department of Political Science and Public Administration
Spain
University of the Basque Country/ Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea. Faculty of Social Sciences and Communication. Department of Political Science and Public Administration.
Spain
Metropolitan University of Educational Sciences
Chile
Faculty of Higher Studies Iztacala, National Autonomous University of Mexico.
Mexico
University of Chile
Chile
National Technological University, Rafaela Regional Faculty, Argentina.
Argentina
Vice-Rectorate for Research and Innovation
University of Cuenca
Ecuador
Observatory of Social Participation and Territory
University of Playa Ancha
Chile
Observatory of Social Participation and Territory
University of Playa Ancha
Chile
Department of Social Sciences
Northern Coastal Regional University Center
University of the Republic
Uruguay
Complutense University of Madrid
Spain
Institute for Socioeconomic Research
Faculty of Social Sciences
National University of San Juan
Argentina
University of the Basque Country
Spain
Network of Researchers and Social Organizations of Latin America
Argentina
Faculty of Social Sciences-UNA
National University of Asuncion
Paraguay
Autonomous University of Mexico City
Academic coordination
Autonomous University of Mexico City
Mexico
l'ARADA Cooperative
Spain
Center for Studies in Local Development Management
University of Holguín
Cuba
Institute for Socioeconomic Research
Faculty of Social Sciences
National University of San Juan
Argentina
South in Action, a non-governmental development organization
Honduras
CURE-UdelaR
Uruguay
Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences, Mexico
Mexico
Center for Social and Humanistic Research
Faculty of Social and Human Sciences
University of Antioquia
Colombia
UNIVERSITY OF GRANADA
Spain
Alternative City Association
Dominican Republic
Faculty of Education
Faculty of Education
University of Antioquia
Colombia
University of Ciudad Juárez
Mexico
Faculty of Education
Faculty of Education
University of Antioquia
Colombia
University Institute for Democracy, Peace and Security of the National Autonomous University of Honduras
Honduras
HARVEST
Honduras
Observatory of Social Participation and Territory
University of Playa Ancha
Chile
Center for Intercultural and Indigenous Studies, CIIR
Chile
University of the Basque Country
Spain
Faculty of Social Work
National University of Entre Rios
Argentina
Universidad de Chile
Chile
Chilean National Congress
Chile
Louis Joseph Lebret OP Research Center for Economics and Humanism
Santo Tomas University
Colombia
University of the Republic
Uruguay
Department of Social Sciences
Northern Coastal Regional University Center
University of the Republic
Uruguay
Federal University of Santa María Associate Professor III of the Department of Educational Fundamentals, of the Educational Center, UFSM
Brazil
University of Cuenca
Ecuador
Institute for Advanced Study
University of Santiago, Chile
Chile
Center for Social and Humanistic Research
Faculty of Social and Human Sciences
University of Antioquia
Colombia
Observatory of Social Participation and Territory
University of Playa Ancha
Chile
ORKESTRA Institute of Territorial Competitiveness of the University of Deusto (Basque Country)
Spain
Faculty of Journalism and Social Communication
National University of La Plata
Argentina
Research Secretariat
Faculty of Philosophy and Letters
University of Buenos Aires
Argentina
Department of Sociology
Faculty of Social Sciences
Universidad de Chile
Chile
CURE-UDELAR
Uruguay
Center for Social Studies
Rectorate of the UNNE
Northeastern University
Argentina
CLACSO
Argentina
University of Antioquia
Colombia
Network of Researchers and Social Organizations of Latin America
Argentina
FACULTY OF SOCIAL SCIENCES AND HUMANITIES OF THE UNIVERSITY OF ANTIOQUIA
Colombia
Universidad Veracruzana
Mexico