Thematic Field: Epistemologies of the South
Workgroup: Decolonial epistemologies, territorialities and culture
[+ View productions and content]Faculty of Social Sciences
Faculty of Social Sciences
National University
Costa Rica
Institute of Contemporary Social Studies
central University
Colombia
Post-Graduation Program in the Integration of Latin America
University of São Paulo
Brazil
Latin America/Caribbean is a continent marked by the coloniality of power, as affirmed by several Latin American thinkers such as Aníbal Quijano, Walter Mignolo, Orlando Fals Borda, and which lives under a capitalism marked by dependency in the sense given to it by the Brazilian economist Ruy Mauro Marini, with the economies of the countries being organized within a logic of unequal transfer of values to the central economies of capital.
For this reason, social logics of labor overexploitation are constructed in Latin America, legitimized by racist mechanisms targeting the ethnic origins of its populations (Indigenous and Black). As a counterpoint to this process, these populations subjected to these oppressive logics strengthen their experiences of alternative social interaction through cultural and communicative practices that redefine their territories.
Understanding these decolonial experiences requires decolonial epistemologies and methodologies of knowledge. Such experiences remain marginal in academia because they reproduce an "international division of intellectual labor" that establishes the construction of theoretical and epistemic paradigms as central to the core countries of capital, while these paradigms are merely applied in peripheral continents, such as Latin America.
Based on this context, the present working group proposes to discuss topics such as:
Experiences of Latin American social movements based on decolonial epistemological proposals and participatory methodologies;
Alternative socialities built from the potential of the popular classes in particular expressed through cultural practices and the reinterpretation of territories.
Theoretical and methodological proposals based on decolonial epistemologies from the perspective of alternative forms of sociability expressed in the experiences of the popular classes;
Resistance to racism, prejudice, sexism and xenophobia from the perspective of the potential to build alternative forms of sociability and changes in the oppressive social order.
QUIJANO, A. Coloniality of Power, Eurocentrism and Latin America. Buenos Aires: CLACSO, 2005
Background
The proposed working group is the product of links established by the Center for Latin American Studies on Culture and Communication (CELACC) of the University of Sao Paulo (Brazil), the Center for Education for Development of the Minuto de Dios University (Uniminuto) of Bogotá (Colombia), the Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences (FLACSO) Argentina headquarters, the Institute of Contemporary Social Studies of the Central University of Bogotá (Colombia), the Postgraduate Program in Urban Planning of the University of Vale do Paraíba (PLUR-Univap) of San José de los Campos (Brazil). This group of institutions began its articulation due to the international research project coordinated by CELACC-USP entitled “Social movements, culture, communication and territory in Sao Paulo, Buenos Aires and Bogota”, financed by the Brazilian development agency FAPESP (Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo) and carried out in the years 2016 to 2018.
The project's overall objective was "to contribute to the construction of a theory and methodology for analyzing new social movements in Latin America, based on the need to reconstruct the public sphere project, taking as its foundation the crisis of the traditional model built on the experience of liberalism and the particularities of the continent's nation-building, and highlighting elements that could offer possibilities for a reconceptualization of these social movements, considering the specificities of Latin America." For this reason, the methodological approach adopted was based on the studies of the Peruvian educator Oscar Jara Hollyday, entitled "Systematization of Experiences and Dialogue with Other Participatory Methodological Proposals," developed by thinkers such as Fals Borda and Paulo Freire, among others.
Based on this, the Brazil-Colombia colloquium on participatory methodologies was held in 2017 with the presentation of seven papers on the subject, four Brazilian and three Colombian. The results of this colloquium were published in a special edition of the CELACC/USP ExtraPrensa magazine.
The experience of carrying out the project enabled the articulation of researchers from different institutions who have been discussing these participatory methodological strategies, as a way of a unique realization and understanding of the experiences of social movements, and who point to the need for a deeper discussion by Latin American universities and intellectuals, as a convergence with the theories of decoloniality.
The experiences generated by the methodological procedures employed in the aforementioned project, such as the courses, seminars, and meetings held with social movements, revealed innovative possibilities for knowledge construction through dialogues of knowledge. Among the most significant results of this experience, we can highlight the need for a discussion of the concept of social movements, especially since it continues to be permeated by a Eurocentric perspective. This perspective is based on the existence of a public sphere to incorporate the diverse collective initiatives undertaken by subjects subjected to the brutal logics of oppression inherent in the coloniality of power. These initiatives point to the redefinition of territories, the reconstruction of communicative flows, and the reconstruction of cultural identities. At certain times, such initiatives fall within what Hohmi Bhabha and Stuart Hall call the "threshold time of minorities," when they analyze the practices of demanding diversity by discriminated groups. While these practices do not completely challenge the hegemonic power of globalization and capital, they also prevent the flow of power from becoming totalitarian. However, it is possible to expand upon such experiences through James Scott's concept of infrapolitics, which posits that all initiatives with a symbolic sense of contrast to the hegemonic order possess political significance; or through his concept of "hidden transcript." Scott considers this discourse to be composed of discursive and behavioral elements generally imperceptible to an outside observer, but which represent essential, everyday resistance strategies used by marginalized populations against processes of economic exploitation, structural violence, and sociopolitical deprivation imposed by the dominant elite. This "hidden transcript" is grounded in a popular culture ("folk culture") that defines and legitimizes various forms of resistance against the hegemonic culture of the elite and the chronic violence (of high or low intensity) perpetrated against marginalized groups by that culture (Scott 1985, 1989, 2013).
Based on these reflections, the activities carried out in 2016 and 2017 in São Paulo, Buenos Aires, and Bogotá facilitated encounters between universities and social leaders from the periphery (understood here as all those involved in collective actions in peripheral territories) who, in defense of cultural identity values, redefine territories and construct alternative flows of communication and information. These issues were discussed in 2018 at the Symposium organized by CELACC.
For this reason, we understand that the construction of a space for theoretical reflection, based on decolonial thought, articulated with participatory methodological strategies, is the focus of the practices carried out by social movements in the peripheral territories of Latin America, which is why it is important to understand their political dynamics on the continent.
Theoretical foundation:
The thematic foundations of the GT Decolonial epistemologies, territorialities and culture It is grounded in the epistemology of decolonial theories developed by thinkers such as Aníbal Quijano, Walter Mignolo, Orlando Fals Borda, and Paulo Freire; the Marxist theory of economic dependency proposed by Ruy Mauro Marini, Theotonio dos Santos, and Vania Bambirra; and the participatory methodologies of social movements. The main vectors of this Working Group's discussions are the reconfiguration of territories based on the practices carried out by movements in these localities, the construction of their own communication flows (particularly through the appropriation of information and communication technologies), cultural resignifications arising from the confrontation of cultural and historical traditions with realities imposed by power mechanisms, and all of this seen as forms of resistance to the colonial mechanisms of power.
Thus, the idea of decoloniality that the Working Group intends to discuss is not merely a theoretical conceptualization constructed from academic reflection; rather, it is the product of a systematization of experiences and practices carried out by individuals in peripheral territories. Therefore, it is pertinent to establish an interconnection between the concept of decoloniality and that of participatory strategies, so that discussions are built upon encounters and dialogues of knowledge between the university and social movements, within an epistemic perspective akin to Paulo Freire's proposal in his Pedagogy of the Oppressed.
From this perspective, we seek to relativize established knowledge and commit to research that transforms the conditions under which coloniality (power, knowledge, and being), patriarchy, and various systems of oppression are reproduced. To this end, we are interested in understanding Latin American realities and their political processes from the periphery, considering not only the geopolitical production of knowledge but also urban peripheralization and the "rural" and peri-urban sectors of our Latin American countries. This is achieved through comparative analyses that allow us to understand similar processes, discontinuities, transformations, and continuities.
To this end, the proposal of this group is to bring together researchers, “peripheral” intellectuals who develop studies and approaches from collaborative and delocalized research methods of the “positivist” logic from which common senses and transdisciplinary knowledge are built that aim to strengthen decolonized epistemologies.
Barth, Frederik 1969. Ethnic Groups and Boundaries. The Social Organization of Culture Differences. Boston: Little, Brown and Company.
Boccara, Guillaume 2003. “Rethinking the Margins/Thinking from the Margins: Culture, Power, and Place on the Frontiers of the New World” Identities: Global Studies in Culture and Power No. 10, pp. 58-81.
Chomsky, Aviva and Steve Striffler 2007. Under the Mantle of Coal: Towns and Multinationals in the Mines of El Cerrejón, Colombia. Bogotá: Editorial Pisando Callos.
Coronil, Fernando 2002 [1997]. The Magical State. Nature, Money and Modernity in Venezuela. Caracas: Nueva Sociedad-Consejo de Desarrollo Científico y Humanístico de la Universidad Central de Venezuela.
Bourdieu, Pierre. 1991. The Logic of Practice. Taurus: Madrid.
Bourgois, Philippe. 1994. Banana, ethnicity and social struggle in Central America. San José: Ecumenical Department of Research.
Escobar, Arturo. 2012. The invention of development. Popayán, Editorial Universidad del Cauca.
Escobar, Arturo. 2014. Sentipensar con la tierra. Nuevas lecturas sobre desarrollo, territorio y diferencia. Medellín: Ediciones Unaula.
Fals-Borda, Orlando and Anisur Rahman, Muhammad 1991. Action And Knowledge Breaking the Monopoly with Participatory Action-Research. London: Intermediate Technology Publications.
Femenías, Maria Luisa. (2011, January-June). Latin American feminisms: an overview. In La Manzana de la discordia. 6(1). 53-59.
Femenías, Maria Luisa. (2007). Outline of a Latin American feminism. In. Articles. Journal of feminist studies. Florianópolis. 15(1). 11-25.
Göbel, Barbara and Astrid Ulloa 2014. “Colombia and extractivism in Latin America”, in: Göbel, Barbara and Astrid Ulloa (Eds.) Mining extractivism in Colombia and Latin America. Bogotá: Editorial Universidad Nacional de Colombia, pp. 15-35.
Guber, Rosana 2005. The Metropolitan Savage. Reconstruction of Social Knowledge in Fieldwork. Buenos Aires: Paidós.
Gudynas, Eduardo 2004. “Conceptions of nature and development in Latin America”, in: Person and Society, Vol. 13, No. 1, pp. 101-125.
Hall, Stuart 2010. Without guarantees: trajectories and problems in cultural studies. Popayán, Ediciones Envión.
Harvey, David 2003. The New Imperialism. Oxford, Oxford University Press.
Harvey, David 1989. The Condition of Postmodernity. Cambridge, Blackwell Publishers.
LeGrand, Catherine 2006. “Transnational Histories: New Interpretations of Enclaves in Latin America” Nomads No. 25, pp. 144-154.
Hermitte, Esther 1970. Supernatural power and social control in a contemporary Mayan village. Mexico City, Inter-American Indian Institute.
Hill Collins, Patricia. (2000-2009). Black Feminist Thought: Knowledge, Consciousness, and the Politics of Empowerment. New York and London: Routledge Classics.
Hill Collins, Patricia. (2004). Black Sexual Politics. African Americans, Gender, and the new racism. New York and London: Routledge Classics.
hooks, bell. (2004). Black women. Shaping feminist theory. In hooks, bell et al. Other unappropriable ones, feminism from the borders. Madrid: Traficantes de sueños.
Lugones, M. (2008). Coloniality and Gender. Tabula Rasa. (9). 73 -101.
Mbembe, Achille 2011. Necropolitics. Madrid: Melusina Editorial.
Mbembe, Achille 2006. “The banality of power and aesthetics of Vulgarity in the Postcolony” in: Gupta, Akhil and Arhadna Sharma (Eds.) The Anthropology of the State. To Reader. Malden, Blackwell Publishing, pp. 381-400.
Nacuzzi, Lidia R. 2002. “Reading between the lines: an eternal doubt about certainties”. In: Sergio Visacovsky and Rosana Guber (Eds.). History and styles of fieldwork in Argentina. 229-262. Buenos Aires, Editorial Antropofagia.
Nash, June 2008. We eat the mines. The mines eat us.
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
These programs are:
1. Territorialities, processes of social mobilization and popular resistance.
2. Decolonial feminisms and diverse economies.
Development of the following research projects:
2020-2022. Prolam/Celacc/Eca/Usp/Brasil Research Project - Social Movements, Culture, Communication and Territory in Latin American Cities. Principal Investigators: Dennis Oliveira and Fabiana Felix do Amaral e Silva
2020-2021 - Prolam/Celacc/Eca/Usp/Brasil - Research Project: Insurgent Peripheries: The Potential of Cultural and Media Initiatives of Young People from the Periphery. Principal Researchers: Dennis Oliveira, Joao Roque, Maira Carvalho Moraes
2020-2022 Celacc/Eca/Usp/Brazil - Research Project: Social Movements and Collective Actions: For Another Political System in Peripheral Latin American Territories
.Principal researchers: Fabiana Felix do Amaral e Silva
2019-2022. RELAM. Violence, social mobilization and resistance in marginalized urban areas of Latin America and the Caribbean. Principal Investigators: Jean Francois Mayer and Tina Hilgers.
2019-2020. CED-Uniminuto. Research project “Recognition and collective recovery of local experiences of resistance against extractivism in southern Bogotá: histories, social transformations and disputed territories”. Principal Investigator: Tatiana Gutiérrez.
2020-2022. Uniminuto. Socio-ecological connectivity research project in Southern Bolívar. Principal Investigator: Tatiana Gutiérrez.
2020-2021. CED-Uniminuto. Research project on Popular Consultations and Territorialities in Resistance. (Participation of students from the CED research group). Principal Investigator: Carlos Rincón.
2019-2020. A Truth from the Victims' Perspective. Methodological Contributions to Clarifying the Effects of the Internal Armed Conflict with Afro-Colombian Organizations in Buenaventura. IESCO - Principal Investigator Yilson Beltran.
2019-2021. Social construction of territory from a critical intercultural perspective – 2019 Piloto University of Colombia -
2020. Andean celebrations in informal neighborhoods of the City of Buenos Aires. FLACSO Argentina. Principal Investigator: Paula Mascías. (Seeking funding).
2020. Construction of territorial development indicators for territories with archaeological heritage. FLACSO Argentina. Principal Investigator: Paula Mascías. (Seeking funding).
Most of them have their own funding.
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
1. Working meeting. GT Meeting. (2020 first semester). Buenos Aires. Argentina. Host institution FLACSO. In this first meeting, conceptual and methodological discussions will be held on the basis of which the research is being developed in a decentralized manner, in order to better clarify the articulation of said research in the two proposed research programs.
2. Symposium: Culture as a Possibility for Encounter and Integration in Latin America. Host Institution: CELACC-Sao Paulo (Brazil). Second Semester of 2020
Publications
1. 2020. Book on social movements, culture, communication and territory in Sao Paulo, Bogota and Buenos Aires.
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
1. Diploma courses on training in collective leadership and territorialities. Contribution of cartographies and participatory methodologies.
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
1. Prolam. Postgraduate Program for Latin American Integration. (Master's and Doctoral Degrees). -USP- Brazil
2. Master's Degree in Research on Contemporary Social Problems. IESCO- Central University.
3. Doctorate in Social Sciences from the National University of Costa Rica.
4. PhD in Sustainable Territorial Management. Pilot University.
5. International Postgraduate Course in Management and Policy in Culture and Communication, FLACSO Argentina.
6. Master's Project in Social Studies with emphasis on transformations and Development. (CED and FCCH- Uniminuto).
7. Doctorate and Master's Degree in Political Science (Concordia University - RELAM)
8. Doctorate and Master's Degree in Urban and Regional Planning (University of Vale do Paraíba PLUR/UNIVAP-Brazil)
Strengthening the collaboration with the Latin American Sociological Association (ALAS). One of the members is the Vice President of ALAS, and possibly another of the researchers in the Working Group will be the Colombian Representative to ALAS.
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
2020-2022.
2019. Subjectivities and Community Economies Subjectivities and Community Economies: a
Dialogue of experiences between the Territorial Area for Training and Reintegration of Icononzo, Tolima and the Santa Rosa neighborhood, Bogotá. (2019) IESCO- Central University. Principal Investigator. Andrea Neira. (Case ETCR-Icononzo).
2019-2020. CED-Uniminuto. Research project: Subjectivities and community economies: a
Dialogue of experiences between the Territorial Training and Reintegration Area of Icononzo, Tolima, and the Santa Rosa neighborhood, Bogotá. Principal Investigator: Girlandrey Sandoval (Santa Rosa Neighborhood Case Study)
2019-2020. Audiovisual Policies and Dissident Perspectives. Reception Study on Television Representations of Trans*, Transvestite, and Non-Binary People. FLACSO Argentina. Principal Investigator: Belén Igarzábal.
2020 - 2021 Emergencies of a feminist economy. Multilocal ethnography of care practices proposed by the FARC- in the ETCRs of Icononzo- Tolima and Mutatá- Urabá Antioqueño (2020) IESCO- Principal Investigator Andrea Neira.
2020-2022- CELACC. Black and peripheral feminism. Principal investigator Elite Edwiges Barbosa.
2019-2020. CED-Uniminuto. Research project “Recognition and collective recovery of local experiences of resistance against extractivism in southern Bogotá: histories, social transformations and disputed territories”. Principal Investigator: Tatiana Gutiérrez.
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
1. Meeting-Colloquium in alliance of centers and units, on critical thinking in Latin America (Host institutions: CED UNIMINUTO; IESCO- Universidad Central; Universidad Piloto). First semester of 2021
Working group meeting in Flaco/Buenos Aires
Book “Territories and ethics for life” (Colombia; CED-IESCO).
and publication of a book based on research from GT member centers
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
1. Prolam. Postgraduate Program for Latin American Integration. (Master's and Doctoral Degrees). -USP- Brazil
2. Master's Degree in Research on Contemporary Social Problems. IESCO- Central University.
3. Doctorate in Social Sciences from the National University of Costa Rica.
4. PhD in Sustainable Territorial Management. Pilot University.
5. International Postgraduate Course in Management and Policy in Culture and Communication, FLACSO Argentina.
6. Master's Project in Social Studies with emphasis on transformations and Development. (CED and FCCH- Uniminuto).
7. Doctorate and Master's Degree in Political Science (Concordia University - RELAM)
8. Doctorate and Master's Degree in Urban and Regional Planning (University of Vale do Paraíba PLUR/UNIVAP-Brazil)
Strengthening the collaboration with the Latin American Sociological Association (ALAS). One of the members is the Vice President of ALAS, and possibly another of the researchers in the Working Group will be the Colombian Representative to ALAS.
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
2020-2022. Prolam/Celacc/Eca/Usp/Brazil
Research Project - Social Movements, Culture, Communication, and Territory in Latin American Cities. Principal Investigators: Dennis Oliveira and Fabiana Felix do Amaral e Silva
2020-2022 Celacc/Eca/Usp/Brazil - Research Project: Social Movements and Collective Actions: For Another Political System in Peripheral Latin American Territories
.Principal researchers: Fabiana Felix do Amaral e Silva
2019-2022. RELAM. Violence, social mobilization and resistance in marginalized urban areas of Latin America and the Caribbean. Principal Investigators: Jean Francois Mayer and Tina Hilgers.
2020-2022. Uniminuto. Socio-ecological connectivity research project in Southern Bolívar. Principal Investigator: Tatiana Gutiérrez.
2020-2022- CELACC. Black and peripheral feminism. Principal investigator Elite Edwiges Barbosa.
2020-2022. Latin American Critical Thought. Principal Investigator: Vivian Urquidi.
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
Books and publications
3. 2021-2022. Book that compiles the results of the research developed in the GT. (Compilations).
4. Special issues of the international journals Nómadas del IESCO and Revista Extraprensa del CELACC, on the two research programs.
5. 2021-2022. Book on Violence, Mobilization and Resistance. (RELAM).
Publication of a book with the results of the research developed in GT (based on previous events), a book about violence
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
1. Prolam. Postgraduate Program for Latin American Integration. (Master's and Doctoral Degrees). -USP- Brazil
2. Master's Degree in Research on Contemporary Social Problems. IESCO- Central University.
3. Doctorate in Social Sciences from the National University of Costa Rica.
4. PhD in Sustainable Territorial Management. Pilot University.
5. International Postgraduate Course in Management and Policy in Culture and Communication, FLACSO Argentina.
6. Master's Project in Social Studies with emphasis on transformations and Development. (CED and FCCH- Uniminuto).
7. Doctorate and Master's Degree in Political Science (Concordia University - RELAM)
8. Doctorate and Master's Degree in Urban and Regional Planning (University of Vale do Paraíba PLUR/UNIVAP-Brazil)
Strengthening the collaboration with the Latin American Sociological Association (ALAS). One of the members is the Vice President of ALAS, and possibly another of the researchers in the Working Group will be the Colombian Representative to ALAS.
Total number of researchers admitted: 24
Autonomous University of Mexico City
Academic coordination
Autonomous University of Mexico City
Mexico
Faculty of Social Sciences
Faculty of Social Sciences
National University
Costa Rica
Center for Latin American Studies on Culture and Communication - ECA-USP
Brazil
Center for Education for Development
University Corporation God's Minute
Colombia
Center for Education for Development
University Corporation God's Minute
Colombia
Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences, Argentina
Argentina Program
Argentina
Popular School of Culture for Peace
Bolivia
Faculty of Political and Social Sciences
National Autonomous University of Mexico
Mexico
Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences, Argentina
Argentina Program
Argentina
Center for Education for Development
University Corporation God's Minute
Colombia
Pilot university of colombia
Colombia
Plurinational School of Public Management
Bolivia
Center for Latin American Studies on Culture and Communication - ECA-USP
Brazil
Universidad de Chile
Chile
Montreal Latin American Studies Network
to Canada
Post-Graduation Program in the Integration of Latin America
University of São Paulo
Brazil
Institute of Contemporary Social Studies
central University
Colombia
Center for Latin American Studies on Culture and Communication - ECA-USP
Brazil
Graduate School
-National University of Education Enrique Guzmán y Valle
Peru
Institute of Contemporary Social Studies
central University
Colombia
Post-Graduation Program in the Integration of Latin America
University of São Paulo
Brazil
Center for Latin American Studies on Culture and Communication - ECA-USP
Brazil
Post-Graduation Program in the Integration of Latin America
University of São Paulo
Brazil
Interdisciplinary School of Advanced Social Studies
National University of San Martín (UNSAM)
Argentina
[widget id=”custom_html-11″]
[print friendly]