Thematic Field: Sport and Society
WorkgroupSport, culture and society
[+ View productions and content]School of Psychology
Pontifical Catholic University of Valparaíso
Chile
Gino Germani Research Institute
Faculty of Social Sciences
University of Buenos Aires
Argentina
This proposal builds upon three years of previous work by our CLACSO Working Group, which focused on public policies related to sport in participating countries. A primary outcome of the project was the identification of unequal access to sport and physical activity for historically disadvantaged social groups. A secondary outcome was the recognition of a set of factors that undermine the training and competition conditions of high-performance athletes. Similarly, we addressed the situation of professional sports such as football and basketball, where market forces often take precedence over the notion of sport as a right. During these years, amidst the increasing commodification of the sporting field, we had the opportunity to learn about social movements fighting for the presence and visibility of minority groups in this arena, as well as grassroots organizations that carry out daily activities to mitigate the negative consequences of the current phase of capitalism.
In the face of the panorama of global capitalism and the advance of conservative policies in Latin America and the world, but also considering the alternative experiences of popular projects - called "post-neoliberal" - in countries of the region, this working group intends to discuss different aspects of the articulation between SPORT, CULTURE AND SOCIETY.
In Latin America, beginning in the second half of the 20th century and with the adoption of the Washington Consensus (Gentili, 1997), the neoliberal capitalist project declared its interest in the market as a promoter of society and as a valid agent in public decision-making. In this context, sport is no exception. The increasing commodification of this practice also reflects the role sport plays in global culture, as seen in the organization of major sporting events. However, when sports programs and events are organized according to economic logic, the consequence is a persistent disparity in access for both participants and spectators.
Thus, the universal interest in sport is not limited to the political sphere; it also manifests economically through the presence of international organizations such as the IDB, the IMF, the World Bank, and the OECD. These organizations invest in promoting sport by conducting studies and providing their opinions and guidelines to the states with which they interact. Along with establishing international funding channels for implementing similar programs throughout Latin America, the approaches of these organizations shape problems and construct a specific target social group: the vulnerable. To them, a pre-designed, globally implemented model is offered as a solution, where sport serves as a catch-all for addressing various social issues.
However, the presence and funding of these international organizations in the current context of capitalism in Latin American countries suggests an area of discussion that we cannot ignore: the reflection on the tension between the commodification of different aspects of the lives of citizens in Latin America and the progression of the expansion and acquisition of rights in more democratic societies.
Despite the diverse realities of the countries comprising this network, within which the sociocultural dynamics specific to each context become relevant, we have established a set of lines of inquiry that challenge us as a Working Group. Thus, without losing sight of local particularities, we hope that the questions guiding this research will lead to the identification of patterns surrounding the problems that characterize the region.
First, it is essential to continue studying state public policies that promote the right to access and sustainably participate in physical activity and/or sport. We therefore seek to understand the measures (or lack thereof) that governments at their various levels (national, provincial, local) formulate and effectively implement for the inclusive growth and development of sport and physical activity. In light of current government decision-making, it is also crucial to understand the strategies that grassroots organizations employ in their communities to negotiate with the privatization process.
Secondly, envisioning democratic societies implies generating resources and information to create opportunities for minority groups and/or those historically relegated to silence and ostracism. Therefore, within the current global context of women's rights movements, one topic for discussion among the Working Group members concerns gender relations in various sports. Around this theme, we intend to examine the construction of hegemonic and alternative masculinities and femininities in this field, the violence perpetrated against women and gender non-conforming individuals, the organizational and advocacy strategies of athletes, and the construction of gendered representations in mainstream media. We began exploring this issue in Cuadernos del Mundial (World Cup Notebooks), a compilation of short texts by authors from different countries, reflecting on the Women's World Cup held in France between June and July 2019, which our Working Group coordinated.
Why sport? Because it serves as a space to observe how inequalities are conceived and addressed; how projects are developed to expand rights for vulnerable and historically excluded sectors; what measures are in place for the inclusion of women and athletes with disabilities at both amateur and professional levels; what meanings different social actors assign to sports practices; how physical education has been conceived throughout history in schools and professional training spaces, and how these practices are conceived today in such institutions; and what role workers play in these processes.
This process is catalyzed by statements, propaganda, and programs from international bodies and international sports organizations that shape the training of sports workers, particularly sports technicians (as well as coaches, graduates, and other figures linked to teaching), from a perspective limited to internal logic (what happens on the field), a technical approach (referring to technique, tactics, and rules), and whose sole objective is the record (Vaz, 2005). This pursuit of records organizes a pyramidal logic of technical training and athletes' career paths, from sports initiation to specialization and finally to elite sport. It also organizes the training of workers around how to build more effective and efficient bodies, in a constant, ultimately frustrated struggle for better performance in defining an individuality, demanding the constitution of bodies that produce techniques as tools for themselves—that is, self-exploited bodies. Thus, bodies must be "toughened," sacrificed, and organized according to dominant models to enter the labor market, depending on the demands of each sport. It is the sports technicians and coaches who, under the new hegemony of the "coach," sculpt these bodies, seeking to eliminate flaws and repress dissenting performances. These juxtaposed alliances between state and market should lead Latin American universities, together with social organizations, to critically examine and transform the training of their professionals and researchers, as well as create conditions to redefine their integration into the workforce. Otherwise, sport functions (has functioned and will continue to function) as a mere reproducer of the power relations that the neoliberal capitalist system seeks to perpetuate.
Gentili, Pablo (1997) The Washington Consensus and the crisis of education in Archipiélago Magazine, number 29, 55-65, Spain.
Vaz, Alexandre (2005) Doping, sport, performance: notes on the “limits” of the body. Revista Brasileira de Ciências do Esporte, 27(1), 23-36.
Sport in Latin America has become an object of study within the social sciences since various researchers undertook the project of studying this social practice (Guedes 1977, Da Matta 1982, Archetti 1985). The area of discussion began to consolidate with the functioning of the CLACSO Sport and Society group, led by Pablo Alabarces, which over the years has trained social scientists who are developing and expanding this field of study through undergraduate and graduate research, the organization of seminars, and the publication of academic articles and books.
Sport has been presented by Simoni Guedes (1977) as a zero institution. This means that diverse interests and disputes are at play in every practice, multiplying the meanings through which sport is understood in society. Heinemann (2001) points out that sport has no inherent values. The values surrounding this social institution change throughout history. Governments, dictatorships, corporations, organizations, and local communities have constructed ways of understanding and promoting this practice in society, in a field that is always in conflict and where impositions, resistance, and negotiations of meaning occur.
Archetti, for his part, has suggested that “sport, understood as a central and not marginal activity, is a fruitful entry point for capturing important cultural, historical, and social processes. Sports, therefore, represent a complex space for the visualization of identities, as well as a space for dominant and challenging social and moral codes” (Archetti n.d.: 3). Along the same lines, Pablo Alabarces (2000) argues that: “Sport is not a ‘reflection’ of some postulated essence of society, but an integral part of it, moreover, a part that can be used as a means to reflect on society” (2000: 11).
In this regard, Roberto DaMatta (1982) argues that sport is as much a part of society as society is a part of sport. Along these lines, drawing on ritual theory, he views sport as a social drama through which society perceives and interprets itself, proposing the study of the different ways in which this practice is appropriated.
Eduardo Santa Cruz (1999) pointed out that when modern Western-rooted sports first appeared in Latin America, only Europeans had the right to play. Later, aristocratic and popular sectors gradually adopted the various practices we now know as sports. For this reason, further study of the dynamics of appropriation, inclusion-exclusion, access, development, and promotion of sport in Latin America remains essential.
For Butler (2002), gender is a dynamic, performative concept and a sociohistorical construct, linked to the cultural production of each society at a given time, and which exposes inter- and intra-gender relations of power and domination. In the field of sports, gender studies provide the epistemological and theoretical tools to understand the inequalities in access to and participation in sports for sectors that have been historically marginalized. Statistics in Latin America indicate that women and girls face greater difficulties in participating in physical activities and/or sports than their male counterparts. This situation is exacerbated when focusing on women and girls from vulnerable socioeconomic backgrounds. Therefore, this project has a particular interest in the study of gender, and also in sexual dissidence within the sports sphere. On the one hand, the objective is to understand the social foundations of discourses that preserve the hegemony of the male gender (constructed around a single model: middle-class, white, and heterosexual men) over all other genders and sexual identities. On the other hand, the aim is to understand the actions of these groups in their struggle to achieve equality in sports. In this way, we can observe the implications of gender roles in the "sportification" and "spectacularization" of a technologically and globally communication-driven society, as well as the narratives (visual and textual) surrounding gender and embodiment (Vélez, 2011).
Archetti, Eduardo (1985) Football and ethos in Monographs and Research Reports. Research Series, No. 7, FLACSO, Buenos Aires.
Archetti, Eduardo (Undated) Anthropology of sport. Unpublished manuscript.
Butler, Judith (2002) Bodies That Matter: On the Material and Discursive Limits of Sex, Paidós, Buenos Aires.
Da Matta, Roberto (1982) Esporte na Sociedade: An essay on Brazilian football, in Da Matta (org.) Universo do Futebol. Esporte e Sociedade Brasileira, Pinakotheke, Rio de Janeiro.
Guedes, Simoni (1977) O Futebol Brasileiro: Institucao zero. Master's diss. URFJ, Rio de Janeiro.
Heinemann, Klaus (2001) The values of Sport. A sociological perspective. Physical Education and Sports, no. 64, pp. 17-25, Catalonia.
Vaz, Alexandre (2005) Doping, sport, performance: notes on the “limits” of the body. Revista Brasileira de Ciências do Esporte, 27(1), 23-36.
Vélez, Beatríz (2011) Football from the stands. Passions and fantasies, Sílaba Publishing House, Medellín.
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
Develop national research projects to identify the critical aspects that promote or resist the inequalities experienced by Latin American populations in access, development and promotion of sport, allowing us to conduct comparative studies.
Periodic meetings for theoretical discussion and methodological planning of national working groups.
Design of the fieldwork and methodology indicated to obtain relevant qualitative and quantitative data for each country.
Integration of young researchers in training into working groups.
Obtaining reliable qualitative and quantitative data for use by state agencies, NGOs and international organizations.
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
To generate reflections and comparative studies that allow the consolidation of the proposed study topics.
Communicate the results of national research - and when results are obtained from regional comparison - to a broad audience.
Conducting comparative studies to consolidate the proposed field of study, impacting the training of new generations.
Creation of a website that allows communication of the results and discussions that the members of the Working Group will develop during the period.
Participate in CLACSO's media outlets: CLACSO TV and Megafón.
An annual book is published with research results from members of the GT.
At least 3 articles are written annually comparing the Latin American realities present in the GT.
Research results are disseminated through videos, podcasts, posters, and brochures.
Opinion columns are also written and sent to national and international media outlets.
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
To promote research and extension projects and generate a seedbed for new proposals.
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
Strengthen the presence of Social Studies of Sport in Latin American (LASA, ALAS) and global (International Sociology of Sport Association –ISSA) academic networks
Communication with global networks or associations for social studies of sport
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
Creation of a compilation book that houses the research results of the members of the GT.
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
To generate reflections and comparative studies that allow the consolidation of the proposed study topics.
Communicate the results of national research - and when results are obtained from regional comparison - to a broad audience.
Conducting comparative studies to consolidate the proposed field of study, impacting the training of new generations.
Creation of a website that allows communication of the results and discussions that the members of the Working Group will develop during the period.
An annual book is published with research results from members of the GT.
At least 3 articles are written annually comparing the Latin American realities present in the GT.
Research results are disseminated through videos, podcasts, posters, and brochures.
Opinion columns are also written and sent to national and international media outlets.
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
To generate reflections and comparative studies that allow the consolidation of the proposed study topics.
Communicate the results of national research - and when results are obtained from regional comparison - to a broad audience.
Communicate the results of national research - and when results are obtained from regional comparison - to a broad audience.
An annual book is published with research results from members of the GT.
At least 3 articles are written annually comparing the Latin American realities present in the GT.
Research results are disseminated through videos, podcasts, posters, and brochures.
Opinion columns are also written and sent to national and international media outlets.
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
Total number of researchers admitted: 71
Faculty of Human and Social Sciences, Cooperative University of Colombia
Faculty of Human and Social Sciences
Cooperative University of colombia
Colombia
Universidad de Chile
Chile
University of the Republic
Uruguay
Gino Germani Research Institute
Faculty of Social Sciences
University of Buenos Aires
Argentina
Federal University of Tocantins
Brazil
The National Institute of Scientific Research
to Canada
PhD in Social Studies
Faculty of Science and Education
University Francisco Jose de Calda
Colombia
Federal University of Santa Catarina
Brazil
Institute for Research in Humanities and Social Sciences
National University of La Plata - National Council for Scientific and Technical Research
Argentina
Center for Psychological and Sociological Research
Cuba
Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences, Ecuador
Ecuador
Federal Institute of Santa Catarina - Câmpus Chapecó; and Universidade Federal da Fronteira Sul - Post-Graduation Program in Geography
Brazil
Postgraduate degree in Communication
Pontifical Catholic University of Valparaiso
Chile
Center for Communication Studies
Institute of Communication and Image
Universidad de Chile
Chile
The Daughters of Sago Collective
El Salvador
Institute of Linguistics, Folklore and Archaeology (ILFYA); Faculty of Humanities, Social Sciences and Health; National University of Santiago del Estero.
Argentina
Faculty of Humanities and Educational Sciences
University of the Republic
Uruguay
UFRGS
Brazil
Federal Fluminense University
Brazil
Institute for Research in Humanities and Social Sciences
National University of La Plata - National Council for Scientific and Technical Research
Argentina
Gino Germani Research Institute
Faculty of Social Sciences
University of Buenos Aires
Argentina
Interdisciplinary School of Advanced Social Studies
National University of San Martín (UNSAM)
Argentina
University of Hamburg
Germany,
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul
Brazil
Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences, Ecuador
Ecuador
Center for Psychological and Sociological Research
Cuba
Center for Advanced Studies
Faculty of Social Sciences
National University of Cordoba
Argentina
Federal University of Minas Gerais
Brazil
Department of Social and Political Sciences
Ibeoamerican University
Mexico
Gino Germani Research Institute
Faculty of Social Sciences
University of Buenos Aires
Argentina
Costa Rica university
Costa Rica
National Council for Scientific and Technical Research
Argentina
Center for Psychological and Sociological Research
Cuba
University of Salento
Italy
Higher Institute of Physical Education / University of the Republic
Uruguay
Caribbean University Corporation
Colombia
Federal University of Espirito Santo
Brazil
Gino Germani Research Institute
Faculty of Social Sciences
University of Buenos Aires
Argentina
Faculty of Humanities and Educational Sciences
University of the Republic
Uruguay
Center for Psychological and Sociological Research
Cuba
School of Psychology
Pontifical Catholic University of Valparaíso
Chile
Institute for Research in Humanities and Social Sciences
National University of La Plata - National Council for Scientific and Technical Research
Argentina
Faculty of Humanities and Educational Sciences. UNLP
Argentina
Costa Rica university
Costa Rica
Higher Institute of Physical Education - UdelaR
Uruguay
Ibero-American University, Mexico City
Mexico
National University of Colombia
Colombia
Interdisciplinary School of Advanced Social Studies
National University of San Martín (UNSAM)
Argentina
Higher Institute of Physical Education - University of the Republic
Uruguay
Institute of Anthropology of Cordoba (IDACOR) - National University of Cordoba (UNC)
Argentina
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul
Brazil
Faculty of Political and Social Sciences
National Autonomous University of Mexico
Mexico
Ibeoamerican University
Mexico
Universidad Católica
Bolivia
Sports Management School (Barcelona)
Spain
Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul - UFRGS
Brazil
Faculty of Humanities - National University of Salta
Argentina
Center for Psychological and Sociological Research
Cuba
Faculty of Psychology of the National University of La Plata
Faculty of Psychology
National University of La Plata
Argentina
University of Cundinamarca
Colombia
The College of Saint Louis AC
Mexico
Division of Social Sciences and Humanities
Metropolitan Autonomous University - Xochimilco Unit
Mexico
Pontifical Catholic University
Chile
Ibero-American University, Mexico City
Mexico
Federal University of Paraná (UFPR)
Brazil
Center for Sociological, Economic, Political and Anthropological Research
Pontifical Catholic University of Peru
Peru
UNIVERSITY ACADEMY OF CHRISTIAN HUMANISM
Chile
Institute for Research in Humanities and Social Sciences (IDIHCS/CONICET)
Argentina
[widget id=”custom_html-11″]
[print friendly]