Thematic Field: Feminisms and Gender Politics
WorkgroupFeminisms, resistance and emancipation
[+ View productions and content]Economic Research Institute
National Autonomous University of Mexico
Mexico
Center for Women's Studies
Central University of Venezuela
Venezuela
Nearly two decades into the 4st century, we are witnessing a strengthening of the feminist movement globally, which some thinkers call the Fourth Wave of Feminism and others consider a new feminist revolution. This renewed vigor arises in a context where policies that roll back rights and ideologies that dismantle utopian ideals have also been gaining strength, fueled by media manipulation that even induces mass support. However, Latin American and Caribbean feminisms are not simply reactive to the advances of the right wing; their trajectories are broader and stem from accumulated historical thought and action. There is a strong projection of ideas, analyses, and political practices that include genealogies stretching back centuries of struggle and resistance, as well as an articulated presence within the processes of seeking structural transformations in our countries and the region.
With the progressive hegemony the region experienced over the last two decades, unique conditions arose for the advancement of feminist thought and movements, combining convergences, critiques, and tensions with various government policies. The search for a post-neoliberal transition—in a global context where, on the contrary, this agenda expanded and entrenched itself, wreaking havoc even in the Global North—fueled unprecedented proposals for systemic change. Faced with the return of neoliberalism, feminist movements have launched mobilizing actions that today have translated into initiatives with global reach and impact, such as the March 8th strike and the "Ni Una Menos" (Not One Less) marches across the continent. The massive outcry against gender violence and femicides was a major fissure that facilitated the movement's emergence from its ghetto.
This stage in Latin America, in which the right wing is regaining hegemony, is marked by new phenomena that combine with old resources of oligarchic power. Manipulated elections, "soft" coups, and attacks on democracy using tactics such as post-truth and lawfare have revealed their progressive impacts since around 2015. The political map of Latin America has been changing, not without resistance, and it is debated whether they will be able to maintain their hold on power.
In our region, right-wing religious fundamentalist movements, very specific interests of de facto groups that aspire to use political power for their benefit, local alliances with global forces, middle classes frightened by popular power and a hypothetical destruction of family and institutional stability, widespread extractive and consumerist culture, and also disenchantment with progressive left-wing popular governments, made possible the seizure of political power by right-wing governments that strive to build a reactionary social base.
The use of fear as leverage for certain political positions is a very old strategy. And among the specters conjured up to frighten people are "gender policies," "populist social policies," and "gender ideology," which are accused of being capable of destroying the "family"—a paramount value for most of our societies—and of destroying institutions, economic growth, and productive capacity.
Currently, we are witnessing a systematic and virulent attack on critical thinking in its most transformative forms, linked to fundamentalism and neoconservatism, the apparent weakening of the United Nations, an assault on the very notion of human rights, and on everything that signifies the expansion of rights and the inclusion of human groups in citizenship, increasing privileges and distancing large sectors of society from lives worth living. There are parts of humanity that are considered valuable, and in contrast, an increasingly numerous and multi-localized disposable humanity.
Today, violence of many kinds is perpetrated against those who are vulnerable and have been historically excluded and marginalized socially and economically (women, racialized people, the poor, and others), because it serves to punish rebellion and because it supports exploitation. Thus, the gaps widen: the poor, women, Indigenous and Afro-descendant peoples, migrants, the elderly, people with disabilities, and sexual dissidents continue to be condemned to this world. And in the current moment in Our America, they are also blamed for what are labeled as trends that undermine social stability and economic well-being.
Confronting the "left" in power and its "ills" is the unifying discourse of the new right, which came to power through various means, not all legal or legitimate. The main ills are the rise of popular movements, their diversity, and their demands for expanded rights and justice, as well as the equitable distribution of wealth and well-being. New political models are presented as the continued face of the popular uprising and social movements that brought "corrupt and authoritarian politicians" to power. Reinstitutionalization, reform in every sense, and class reconciliation are the most frequently used narratives.
The political leadership of post-neoliberal left-wing governments bears significant responsibility for the resonance these narratives achieve, having underestimated the significance and impact of corruption. Government complicity with corrupt public works schemes, the obscene enrichment of shadowy figures linked to power, capital flight, and hidden accounts in tax havens held by businesspeople and politicians fueled social unrest and the desire for a change of course. (Hernán Ouviña and Mabel Thwaites Rey, 2018) This is not to deny, of course, the ongoing undermining of trust and hope carried out through communication channels and activism promoted by restorationist interests and funded by international organizations.
The rise of the far right is not exclusive to Latin America and the Caribbean. It is clear that in the US and Europe, reactionary populisms have taken hold, advocating anti-gender policies, xenophobia, racism, and attacks on the social gains of the working class. Immigrants are the primary target of their attacks, but so are gender policies, especially laws against gender violence, abortion, and same-sex marriage, advocating for a more traditional family model. For example, Trump established the Global Gag Rule, which prohibits foreign non-governmental organizations (NGOs) receiving US healthcare from providing legal abortion services. There is also an instrumentalization of gender, for example, in cases of gender violence by Matteo Salvini in Italy, who blamed immigrants. Incidentally, these same arguments were used in our region by Lenin Moreno in Ecuador.
Radical and intertwined feminisms confront this global and regional right wing by forming an international movement that has been strengthening, articulating diverse experiences and forms of struggle, with a massive presence in the streets and in relation to other social movements.
In the recent history of Latin America and the Caribbean, the first decade of this century gave rise to a series of movements that, as a reaction to the decade of neoliberalism and its resulting impoverishment, spurred widespread social mobilization within a context favorable to progressive governments. This context also saw the development of the most recent stage in the genealogy of Latin American and Caribbean feminism, characterized by a reaction against the hegemonic liberal feminism of the 90s, which coexisted with a less visible socialist feminism in many countries of the region. These new feminisms present themselves as dissident, opposed to neoliberal policies, and are decolonial, anti-racist, and anti-patriarchal. From the year 2000 onward, feminist movements have experienced a revitalization of activism and an explosion of feminist diversity.
Our feminisms have become a new political agent, a force that challenges crucial issues that partisan politics has so far ignored: the body, love, desire, sexuality, motherhood as a choice and not an obligation, the right to abortion, women's poverty, the economy for the sustainability of life, women's participation and their effective rights, but above all, it challenges social transformation and the depth and scope of emancipation.
Feminism, as a social movement and as critical thought, has made significant contributions to the processes of deconstruction and confrontation with hegemonic knowledge and power structures. From its inception, it has constituted itself as a space of resistance, of questioning practices, and of ethical alternatives to dominant models. Latin American and Caribbean feminisms represent a commitment to another possible world, a proposal for other worlds, a vindication of a utopia, defined as anti-patriarchal, anti-capitalist, anti-colonial, and anti-racist. These adjectives not only characterize these feminisms but also refer to the intertwining of oppressions, defined as intersectionality. Latin American and Caribbean women experience gender oppression intersected with class, ethnic, territorial, colonial, and heteronormative oppression.
Feminism, as an emancipatory process, also requires learning from its own processes. Therefore, it is a significant challenge to generate pedagogical and self-directed learning tools, from within the social movement itself, that allow for the systematization of learning experiences from and for feminism. Learning from these processes, through collective and autonomous methodologies, not only allows us to record and generate a collective memory of struggle, but also, through its dissemination, makes visible and allows us to share the diverse organizational and educational strategies conceived and implemented by the various communities—autonomous, partisan, social, cultural, and community-based—that are currently thinking about and building feminisms. Feminism needs to learn from other feminisms: from those that envision utopias for the present, impacting daily life and our ways of living together, and from those that project utopias for the future, establishing as a fundamental principle the eradication of the heteropatriarchal system, as well as the promotion of the autonomy of women and sexual minorities in any social project.
In this context, Latin American and Caribbean feminisms resist colonization, promoting emerging processes generated from communities, from grassroots organizations, from the struggles of anonymous leaders who renew hope and set in motion, under precarious conditions, political resistances and mobilizations that generate displacements and transformations in the daily lives of women, but also put the establishment and its institutions under tension.
Guimaraes, Adriana and Cernov, Ana (2019) The true opponents of Bolsonaro. In Nueva Sociedad, Digital Edition, May 2019. Available at https://nuso.org/articulo/feminismo-bolsonaro-brasil/, accessed 22/06/2019
López Segrera, Francisco (2016) Crisis of Post-Neoliberalism and Rise of the New Right. Buenos Aires: CICCUS Editions. CLACSO
Ouviña, Hernán and Thwaites Rey, Mabel. [Eds.] (2018). States in Dispute: Rise and Fracture of the Cycle of Challenge to Neoliberalism in Latin America. Buenos Aires: CLACSO. El Colectivo. Quimantú. Desde Abajo. Bajo Tierra Ediciones. Zur. IEALC.
The main purpose of the Working Group is to analyze feminisms, as critical thought and as a movement, in their theories and analyses, in their demands and proposals, in their achievements, in their failures and in their political strategies, in the current moments in Latin America and the Caribbean, highlighting their contributions to collective social emancipation, in the contexts of power disputes that intersect in our region.
Latin American and Caribbean feminisms have contributed, and continue to contribute, much to the struggles for social transformation; they are the clearest guarantee that such transformation will actually occur. In this vein, we aim to highlight the innovative political practices that feminisms in the region have developed, as well as their resistance and struggles, in situations where a hostile environment becomes a stimulus for women's organizations. For example, in Brazil, countless formal and informal groups have been created to protest, organize, debate, learn, and support women during a brutal attack on their rights. We also consider it necessary to showcase strategies employed in other contexts, where feminist disputes are instrumentalized to bolster political positions and actions in various spheres.
Feminist movements are developing a powerful campaign to occupy public spaces throughout the region. Massive marches and sit-ins have taken place in several countries, and in others, the presence of feminists making demands and carrying out various actions is now commonplace. They have also burst onto the media scene to challenge hegemonic narratives and confront violence. We believe this is leading to political and social reconfigurations, as well as changes within the movement itself, which must be analyzed in their evolution and consequences. What kind of modifications are occurring in strategies and collective imaginaries as a result?
Based on a pluralistic and democratic conception, feminisms propose a different way of doing politics. Feminisms propose a different way of interpreting reality, denouncing denied or excluded problems, making women visible in their experiences of oppression but also in their contributions to society, denaturalizing the patriarchal systems of violence in which they have historically been socialized, and proposing alternative forms of expression and political mobilization. Resisting the brutal attack on social reproduction, women have entered the political arena with their positions, their strength, and their strategies. Given that other transformations have failed, the challenge now is to avoid repeating old practices. The demands of the feminist struggle are, in essence, demands for women's citizenship rights, but a diverse and inclusive citizenship that recognizes those who have been oppressively invisible. The feminist movement, emerging and becoming visible in the occupation of public space, and as an instance of collective action of protest and proposals, brings with it new challenges to respond to the changing realities of our region.
In theory, we aim to account for and discuss the most recent developments and productions of Latin American and Caribbean feminist critical thought, such as new theoretical reflections—transversal and intersectional—on understanding phenomena of race, territory, sexuality, class, and generations. Our focus includes the contributions of decolonial, Indigenous, Afro/Black, autonomous, popular, and community feminisms, ecofeminism and feminist economics, LGBTI perspectives, feminist liberation theology, and peasant feminism. We will also engage with the viewpoints of activist, academic, and institutional feminisms.
We consider it important to uncover the conceptual frameworks that still underpin and perpetuate gender oppression in much of the intellectual work of our region, and to confront resistance and discrimination within research communities. It is also about fostering connections, encounters, and exchanges between the knowledge built through activism within diverse feminist movements and institutionalized academic and scientific knowledge. We aim to contribute theoretically and methodologically to an anti-hegemonic, countercultural, non-liberal, anti-system, anti-patriarchal, and anti-capitalist feminist thought.
We also consider it relevant to critically examine the gender and women's equality policies implemented in Latin America, highlighting both progress and shortcomings in the various political stages we have experienced. These debates will include the discussion raised by several feminist voices regarding the unwavering hope placed in state action and the achievements of the Sustainable Development Goals, as well as in the gender-sensitive social responsibility of national and transnational corporations, in contrast to other possible paths of transformation more focused on community, grassroots, and cultural action. Some exemplary topics for this analysis undoubtedly include: pathways to achieving women's effective right to a life free from violence, the right to freedom of choice regarding motherhood and sexuality, the rise of prostitution and trafficking, women's organizing to defend territories and natural resources, the economy and public policies from a feminist perspective, social reproduction, and care work. A noteworthy theme is the recognition, empowerment, and inclusion of women's voices in political spaces and the creation of equal opportunities for a better quality of life, a militant anti-racism in a region that is a melting pot of origins and colors.
Significant feminist research has made progress on the aforementioned issues. Undoubtedly, its findings point to direct courses of action that will allow us to move beyond the current situation and embrace profound civilizational alternatives. The numerous feminist collectives promoting (re)educational processes to eradicate violence through a radical transformation of the justice system, the reorientation of public denunciation to cultivate critical consciousness—driven by feminist journalists and communicators—the processes of transformation "from within" science and technology to incorporate gender as a category of critical analysis, the struggle to decriminalize and legalize abortion, the redefinition of solidarity economies, and the proposals of Indigenous women to defend the land, territory, and humanity itself, are just a few examples of the steps taken toward a radical social transformation. This transformation, while not neglecting formal politics, fosters active and decisive community or collective social participation that, from a political perspective, points to realistic paths for change.
Blazquez Graf, Norma; Flores Palacios, Fátima and Ríos Everard, Maribel (2012) Feminist Research: Epistemology, Methodology and Social Representations. Mexico: UNAM, Center for Interdisciplinary Research in Sciences and Humanities: Regional Center for Multidisciplinary Research: Faculty of Psychology.
Fulchiron, Amandine ( 2016) "Sexual violence as genocide", Mexican Journal of Political and Social Sciences, National Autonomous University of Mexico, Year LXI, no. 228, September-December 2016.
Monzón, Ana Silvia (2019) Voices of Women. Radio program since 1993.
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
To account for and discuss the theoretical contributions of Latin American and Caribbean feminisms in their epistemological and theoretical diversity.
Enriching research with contributions from the activist practices of feminist movements
Observatory of gender policies in the region
Articulation of debates and sharing with the other Working Groups that work on the topic of gender and feminisms
Strengthen dialogue with researchers from other CLACSO Working Groups.
Promote the circulation of GT's output in social and political organizations and movements
To begin an academic and operational design of a group training experience in gender and feminisms
Exchanges with governmental and cooperation institutions and organizations to present analyses and proposals.
Exchanges with feminist movements to articulate common strategies.
Coordination with the ALAS Gender Working Group.
Articulation with CODESRIA.
Linkage with some of the Women Deliver activities
Articulation with Fazendo Género Working Groups
Articulation with Feminist Articulation MARCOSUR
Articulation with ACAS
Hold a GT meeting to discuss research papers and articles in order to improve their perspectives and positions
Organize meetings with national and regional feminist movements to foster dialogue among different forms of knowledge.
Participation of female researchers as teachers and lecturers in the Gender Seminars offered by CLACSO.
Feminist Theoretical and Political Training Course with guests from the GT (Recife, Brazil)
Conduct interviews with prominent Latin American and Caribbean feminists in academia, activism and/or politics
Meetings and digital exchanges with other working groups that address gender and feminism issues
To monitor the policies for the advancement of gender equality developed by the states and governments of our region
Develop a Virtual Seminar on women's movements in Central America
Publication of a collective book resulting from the research carried out during this period.
Publish interviews with feminist activists from the region. Audio or video format.
Seminars given in the Diploma in Public Policies and Gender Justice on the CLACSO Platform
International Course on Public Policy and Gender Justice
Line of work articulated with another Working Group on Feminisms and Gender
Publication of documents and articles on gender public policies developed in the region
Seminar Program: Women's Movement in Central America
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
Promote the circulation of GT's output in social and political organizations and movements
To begin an academic and operational design of a group training experience in gender and feminisms
Conduct meetings and participate in CLACSO Working Groups
Produce academic and popular articles for various media outlets.
Conduct discussions and forums on the topics under study
Organize two panels at ALAS 2019
Organize a Panel at Fazendo Género 2020
Interest and good attendance at the activities open to the public organized by the GT
Panels approved and completed at ALAS 2019.
Publication of papers in the ALAS Proceedings
Contribution to undergraduate and postgraduate training in the institutions with which the members of the GT are related
Panel approved and carried out at Fazendo Género 2010
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
Exchanges with feminist movements to articulate common strategies.
Participation in events organized by governmental and cooperation institutions and organizations
Participation in events and meetings with feminist movements to articulate common strategies.
Participation and joint activities of feminist debates at the Pan-Amazonian Social Forum, Colombia
Joint actions with social movements and GT
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
Articulation with CODESRIA.
Linkage with some of the Women Deliver activities
Articulation with Fazendo Género Working Groups
Articulation with Feminist Articulation MARCOSUR
Inclusion of GT activities in the Women Deliver 2019 Platform
Participation in joint activities for the dissemination and production of knowledge and feminist political action
Collaboration with other working groups on the topic and with feminist academic networks to include them in the design of the training experience in gender and feminisms
Activities included in various feminist dissemination platforms.
Academic design of the training experience in gender and feminisms
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
Studying the practices of action within the feminist movements of the region, decision-making, leading participation, autonomy, etc.
Analyze the alliances that strengthen feminist action and study the forces that oppose feminist achievements
Preparation of presentations and organization of panels for LASA 2020
Articulation of debates and sharing with the other Working Groups that work on the topic of gender and feminisms
Observatory of gender policies in the region
Hold at least one face-to-face GT meeting.
Hold virtual meetings every two months.
Maintain frequent exchange and communication through virtual networks and media.
Organization of Panels for LASA 2020
Meetings and digital exchanges with other working groups that address gender and feminism issues
To monitor the policies for the advancement of gender equality developed by the states and governments of our region
Publication of the texts produced, through co-editions, and in academic journals
Public events with good attendance
Articles published in newspapers in the region.
Two panels created at LASA 2020
Progress on the lines of joint work with other working groups that address the issue of gender and feminisms
Publication of documents and articles on public gender policies that are
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
Participate in debates and events held by other Working Groups and in Congresses and Meetings in Social Sciences
Recording interviews in podcast format
Feminist Theoretical and Political Training Course with guests from the GT (Recife, Brazil)
Public presentation in each country of the publications produced
Participation in LASA, ALAS and other international events with GT production
Participation with talks and teaching in the CLACSO Virtual Seminars
Contribution to undergraduate and postgraduate training in the institutions with which the members of the GT are related
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
To contribute to the drafting of letters from social movements and declarations addressed to the State
Collaboration with networks such as the Network of Women Transforming the Economy and feminist research networks in the region
Maintain frequent exchanges and carry out joint actions with the networks
Conduct two public events on the occasion of the GT meeting
To actively promote the participation of GT members in radio and television programs, as well as in the print media of different countries, in order to offer feminist analyses and perspectives on different problems and situations.
Activity developed in synergy with a network such as World March of Women, REMTE, Feminist Articulation MARCOSUR, etc.
At least two meetings and discussions with feminist and social movements in the region.
Meetings with public policy decision-makers.
Establish alliances and join forces with social movements
To pressure the State with women's demands
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
Articulation with Feminist Articulation
Articulation with ACAS
Participation in joint activities for the dissemination and production of knowledge with the MARCOSUR Feminist Articulation
Joint work with ACAS
Articulation with ALAC Academic Networks
(Articulation actions for relevant and rigorous comparative social research)
Research on the bicentennial of independence in several countries of the region.
Articulation of debates and sharing with the other Working Groups that work on the topic of gender and feminisms
Observatory of gender policies in the region
Hold at least one face-to-face GT meeting.
Hold virtual meetings every two months.
Maintain frequent exchange and communication through virtual networks and media.
Meetings and digital exchanges with other working groups that address gender and feminism issues
To monitor the policies for the advancement of gender equality developed by the states and governments of our region
Publication of the texts produced, through co-editions, and in academic journals
Public events with good attendance
Articles published in newspapers in the region.
Progress on the lines of joint work with other working groups that address the issue of gender and feminisms
Publication of documents and articles on gender public policies developed in the region
(Actions for training, visibility and communication of production)
To contribute to the drafting of letters from social movements and declarations addressed to the State
Collaboration with networks such as the Network of Women Transforming the Economy and feminist research networks in the region
Maintain frequent exchanges and carry out joint actions with the networks
Conduct two public events on the occasion of the GT meeting
To actively promote the participation of GT members in radio and television programs, as well as in the print media of different countries, in order to offer feminist analyses and perspectives on different problems and situations.
Activity developed in synergy with a network such as World March of Women, REMTE, Feminist Articulation MARCOSUR, etc.
At least two meetings and discussions with feminist and social movements in the region.
Meetings with public policy decision-makers.
Establish alliances and join forces with social movements
To pressure the State with women's demands
(Relationships with science and technology organizations, non-governmental organizations, trade unions, social movements, etc.)
To contribute to the drafting of letters from social movements and declarations addressed to the State
Collaboration with networks such as the Network of Women Transforming the Economy and feminist research networks in the region
Maintain frequent exchanges and carry out joint actions with the networks
Conduct two public events on the occasion of the GT meeting
To actively promote the participation of GT members in radio and television programs, as well as in the print media of different countries, in order to offer feminist analyses and perspectives on different problems and situations.
Activity developed in synergy with a network such as World March of Women, REMTE, Feminist Articulation MARCOSUR, etc.
At least two meetings and discussions with feminist and social movements in the region.
Meetings with public policy decision-makers.
Establish alliances and join forces with social movements
Pressuring the States or with the demands of women
(Scientific networks, international cooperation organizations, academic institutions)
Articulation with Feminist Articulation
Participation in joint activities for the dissemination and production of knowledge with the MARCOSUR Feminist Articulation
Total number of researchers admitted: 35
Economic Research Institute
National Autonomous University of Mexico
Mexico
SOS CORPO Feminist Institute for Democracy
Brazil
Miranda International Center Foundation
Venezuela
Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences, Guatemala
Guatemala
Economic Research Institute
National Autonomous University of Mexico
Mexico
SOS CORPO Feminist Institute for Democracy
Brazil
Academic Pedagogical Institute of Social Sciences
National University of Villa María
Argentina
Center for Interdisciplinary Research in Sciences and Humanities
National Autonomous University of Mexico
Mexico
Inter-American Commission of Women
_Others
Economic Research Institute
National Autonomous University of Mexico
Mexico
Center for Studies in Emancipatory Education and Critical Pedagogy
Venezuela
Departments of Social Sciences and Humanities - UCA
Centroamerican University
El Salvador
School of Humanities
National University of San Martin
Argentina
Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences, Ecuador
Ecuador
Center for Women's Studies
Central University of Venezuela
Venezuela
Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences, Argentina
Argentina Program
Argentina
Gino Germani Research Institute
Faculty of Social Sciences
University of Buenos Aires
Argentina
Economic Research Institute
National Autonomous University of Mexico
Mexico
JAINA Study Community
Bolivia
Core of Social Sciences and Humanities
Universidad of the Border
Chile
Center for Advanced Studies in Childhood and Youth of CINDE and the University of Manizales
Research and Development Field
International Center for Education and Human Development Foundation CINDE
Colombia
Center for Research in Women's Studies
Research Vice Presidency
Costa Rica university
Costa Rica
Center for Psychological and Sociological Research
Cuba
Faculty of Humanities and Educational Sciences
University of the Republic
Uruguay
Center for Women's Studies
Central University of Venezuela
Venezuela
Graduate Program in Geography
Federal University of Sergipe
Brazil
Economic Research Institute
National Autonomous University of Mexico
Mexico
Federal University of Grande Dourados Foundation
Faculty of Human Sciences
Federal University of Grande Dourados
Brazil
Pontifical Catholic University of Rio Grande do Sul - PUC/RS
Brazil
Center for Research in Women's Studies
Research Vice Presidency
Costa Rica university
Costa Rica
University of Chile, Undergraduate Department
Chile
Center for Women's Studies
Central University of Venezuela
Venezuela
Department of Sociology, University of Havana
-Faculty of Philosophy and History.
-University of Havana
Cuba
[widget id=”custom_html-11″]
[print friendly]